So who starts at QB next week? | Page 3 | The Boneyard
.-.

So who starts at QB next week?

I hope Edsall learns toward Shirrefs, but doesn't tell the media so the opposition doesn't know, need whatever advantage we can get vs USF.
 
We almost got beat by a 5th yr senior QB from HC tonight but thanks to another 5th yr senior from UCONN who came to our rescue that didn't happen. I think BS should get the nod against USF. The team just moved so much better and consistently with BS. We don't need anymore exhibition games. I'm sure Pindell will have other opportunities but against USF, I vote for Bryant. Pindell had that one great closeline rope tonight which proved to me he can wing it, however a lot of his throws looked like he was shot putting the ball. I say go with the hot hand against USF, Bryant Shirreffs.
 
Last edited:
Shireffs. There's no doubt. And he has real coaches now.

The kid is tough as nails, and the bright lights don't bother him. If we can get the darned OLine together, Bryant is going to win a lot of games for us...
 
.-.
I'm sorry that anyone even has a question about this it is 100% Bryant Sheriff's I sit in the front row 35-yard line right behind the offense. My next post will be an upload of the pictures of what happened to David Pindell after he was pulled from the game he absolutely gave up on his team.
 
How is this even a question?

By no means did Pindell look terrible, but we lose to Holy Cross tonight without Shirreffs coming into the game and giving us a spark.

Shirreffs or Pindell, I think after that game it's pretty evident that it's going to be a long season and both will see the field quite a bit each.
 
From Game Week/Post Game Thread:



Mike Anthony‏ @ManthonyCourant 19m 19 minutes ago
Pindell handled himself very well after game. "Proud of Bryant. I wasn't overly thrilled but it was an opportunity to learn."

Mike Anthony‏ @ManthonyCourant 18m 18 minutes ago
Pindell on QBs: "[Shirreffs] did his job, and I'm proud of him. We'll keep making each other better in practice, no matter who is starter."

Mike Anthony‏ @ManthonyCourant 15m 15 minutes ago
Shirreffs said he prepared like he was going to play the whole game, each play through, and was comfortable entering in 3rd Q

Mike Anthony‏ @ManthonyCourant 15m 15 minutes ago
Shirreffs approached Edsall couple days ago, stressed that he's committed to team, program and whatever role he plays. Edsall was impressed.


>>Asked who would be the starting quarterback vs. South Florida, Edsall said he'd wait to talk with players and coaches and review film, and said, "We're not going to hide anything, but [Bryant Shirreffs] did a really good job."<<

 
Last edited:
scottieskis said:
I'm sorry that anyone even has a question about this it is 100% Bryant Sheriff's I sit in the front row 35-yard line right behind the offense. My next post will be an upload of the pictures of what happened to David Pindell after he was pulled from the game he absolutely gave up on his team.
Expand ...
I did notice after BS lead the team down field to the his first touchdown, and the offense huddled at the sideline, DP was sitting off by himself. Kinda sad. I don't know if that's quitting on the team, but let's see your pics.
 
In all fairness to Pindell we just had a 71-yard TD drive then proceeded to gain 15 yards on 2 plays the next drive and that 2nd play was his fumble. He clearly had 1st game jitters, I wouldn't be so quick to push him out of the picture just yet. Give it a couple more chances and then if not BS it is.
 
scottieskis said:
I'm sorry that anyone even has a question about this it is 100% Bryant Sheriff's I sit in the front row 35-yard line right behind the offense. My next post will be an upload of the pictures of what happened to David Pindell after he was pulled from the game he absolutely gave up on his team.
Expand ...
This was evident on TV too. They kept cutting to Pindell and he was alone / standing and not showing emotion even though the team was scoring and playing well. The look on his face told it all. BS was the opposite when replaced by Williams or getting killed out there. He was always in it for the team.
 
.-.
blue93 said:
I wouldn't be upset by any means if BS gets the start next week, but the offensive line was MUCH better with him in the game than Pindell. I can't hold that against Pindell.
Expand ...

Yes you can. Experience and leadership count for a lot at the QB position. Pindell looked like the second coming of Donovan Williams' burned redshirt, and against a I-AA team. If he looks this bad against a lower division program, I shudder to think what's going to happen when you throw him out there against a real football team like USF.
 
huskyinfl said:
This was evident on TV too. They kept cutting to Pindell and he was alone / standing and not showing emotion even though the team was scoring and playing well. The look on his face told it all. BS was the opposite when replaced by Williams or getting killed out there. He was always in it for the team.
Expand ...
The kid is human... I think anyone in that spot would feel a little dejected and hard on himself. Lot of pressure on these guys.
Basing everything on one camera shot is unfair.
 
HC tacklers were in the Pindell's face right after the snap most of the time. Pindell was under pressure. He is young and has some jitters but he clearly has talent. The O line did not help Pindell and Newsome. But BS clearly saved the day and his leadership and experience showed. The team appeared to have lots of confidence in him. BS should be the starter based on accomplishment and success in game situation.
 
noeynox said:
With this OL, both will play. Could not get over how bad they were.
Expand ...


This. It really doesn't matter who plays QB if the line non-blocks the way it did last night. Newsome was swamped every time he got the ball. Not sure if someone is tipping the run or what. While Hopkins was a nice surprise, I didn't see anything that explains why he had more success in getting some blocks.

The defense was also horrendous. Teams that can't defend or block lose a lot of games.

The return game looked pretty solid though. Swann was clearly on a mission to return everything. Now that we have had an actual return game, he can go back to making good decisions and not forcing it. But, he looks like he might be a good one back there.
 
SubbaBub said:
This. It really doesn't matter who plays QB if the line non-blocks the way it did last night. Newsome was swamped every time he got the ball. Not sure if someone is tipping the run or what. While Hopkins was a nice surprise, I didn't see anything that explains why he had more success in getting some blocks.

The defense was also horrendous. Teams that can't defend or block lose a lot of games.

The return game looked pretty solid though. Swann was clearly on a mission to return everything. Now that we have had an actual return game, he can go back to making good decisions and not forcing it. But, he looks like he might be a good one back there.
Expand ...

Even with Swann's mistakes, I loved him returning kicks. He has a fearless approach that is just fun to watch. He hits holes fast and has the speed. He will only get better. Credit goes to RE for seeing the talent and trusting him back there.
 
.-.
gioff23 said:
U do not build a program by quitting on your QB after 1 week. Everyone knows BS played better. So what. There's a whole thread acknowledging we r in a rebuild. We r not rebuilding with a RSSr QB.

Please stop.
Expand ...

Everyone has valid points. However, I think gioff23 closing remark is most valid. Bryant won't be here next year. Yes, he is a better leader and the team has more confidence in him because of what.........experience.

I like Bryant and offer him a lot of respect for what he has done. Never had a solid group of supporting players around him.

Dave needs experience. Did anyone realistically think Tom Brady was taking over the program?

What other inexperienced QB on the sidelines would have done as good or better. He'll get better as he experiences adversity going from Jr college talent to FBS/FCS opposition. He, or some other QB on the bench has to experience football challenges and growing pains at this level as the program tries to rebuild for the future. ,,,,,,,, before the arrival of Fall 2018.

Bryant can be, and continues to be a valuable asset. He can be a tremendous learning asset to Dave P as we move forward
 
ShakyTheMohel said:
Even with Swann's mistakes, I loved him returning kicks. He has a fearless approach that is just fun to watch. He hits holes fast and has the speed. He will only get better. Credit goes to RE for seeing the talent and trusting him back there.
Expand ...

After fair catching with 7 yards of room, you knew he was returning the next punt regardless. I was surprised he wasn't benched after the punt sailed over his head but he did look like a jet.
 
tduconn said:
Everyone has valid points. However, I think gioff23 closing remark is most valid. Bryant won't be here next year. Yes, he is a better leader and the team has more confidence in him because of what....experience.

I like Bryant and offer him a lot of respect for what he has done. Never had a solid group of supporting players around him.

Dave needs experience. Did anyone realistically think Tom Brady was taking over the program?

What other inexperienced QB on the sidelines would have done as good or better. He'll get better as he experiences adversity going from Jr college talent to FBS/FCS opposition. He, or some other QB on the bench has to experience football challenges and growing pains at this level as the program tries to rebuild for the future. ,,,,,,,, before the arrival of Fall 2018.

Bryant can be, and continues to be a valuable asset. He can be a tremendous learning asset to Dave P as we move forward
Expand ...

By that logic, why play Pindell this season if next year he's just going to be a senior too?
 
tduconn said:
Everyone has valid points. However, I think gioff23 closing remark is most valid. Bryant won't be here next year. Yes, he is a better leader and the team has more confidence in him because of what....experience.

I like Bryant and offer him a lot of respect for what he has done. Never had a solid group of supporting players around him.

Dave needs experience. Did anyone realistically think Tom Brady was taking over the program?

What other inexperienced QB on the sidelines would have done as good or better. He'll get better as he experiences adversity going from Jr college talent to FBS/FCS opposition. He, or some other QB on the bench has to experience football challenges and growing pains at this level as the program tries to rebuild for the future. ,,,,,,,, before the arrival of Fall 2018.

Bryant can be, and continues to be a valuable asset. He can be a tremendous learning asset to Dave P as we move forward
Expand ...

We are rebuilding the entire team, not just quarterback. If BS is the better player, and right now it looks like he is, that helps everybody get better
 
Reality: HC wore down in the second half and BS had more time to throw than Pindell. The BIGGEST play of the game was the roughing the kicker penalty. Uconn then took the ball down the field and didn't score (failed 4th down), but it kept HC D on the field, stopped their momentum, and changed the field after that crazy punt downed at the one. If that penalty doesn't occur, uconn likely loses.

Back to the QB...neither was good. BS was so late on so many passes, his timing was terrible. he got lucky twice that defenders fell. Pindell looked lost for most of the game, bad decisions, throwing into double coverage, etc. he was also playing his first game and HC pressured him a lot more.

I hope Pindell is better than that, but I think you kep with BS. He's gonna throw a pick 6 or get his wRs killed if he continues to be that late with his passes, but could also be a reflection of lack of first string time, first game, etc. And, cannot discount that entire got a lift and played better once he was put in.
 
SubbaBub said:
This. It really doesn't matter who plays QB if the line non-blocks the way it did last night. Newsome was swamped every time he got the ball. Not sure if someone is tipping the run or what. While Hopkins was a nice surprise, I didn't see anything that explains why he had more success in getting some blocks.

The defense was also horrendous. Teams that can't defend or block lose a lot of games.

The return game looked pretty solid though. Swann was clearly on a mission to return everything. Now that we have had an actual return game, he can go back to making good decisions and not forcing it. But, he looks like he might be a good one back there.
Expand ...
Newsome isn't a between the tackles rb, he needs to be used in the passing game more and put Hopkins in to get the majority of the carries. I'd love to see both in the game at the same time. It would be nice to see the te s get some action, but they are probably being used to pass protect to help the disaster in the oline
 
.-.
Confident Carl said:
We almost got beat by a 5th yr senior QB from HC tonight but thanks to another 5th yr senior from UCONN who came to our rescue that didn't happen. I think BS should get the nod against USF. The team just moved so much better and consistently with BS. We don't need anymore exhibition games. I'm sure Pindell will have other opportunities but against USF, I vote for Bryant. Pindell had that one great closeline rope tonight which proved to me he can wing it, however a lot of his throws looked like he was shot putting the ball. I say go with the hot hand against USF, Bryant Shirreffs.
Expand ...
Lindell's long ball did seem like a shot put type delivery - other than that he did ok. He clearly has a running gear BS doesn't have but BS got it done.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Online statistics

Members online
392
Guests online
7,850
Total visitors
8,242
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
165,267
Messages
4,428,984
Members
10,270
Latest member
jess3039


p
p
Top Bottom