I don't think there's any way of telling which will be a better player in 2016-17 for any program. The one thing that makes me wonder about Brown's recruitment is his idea that teams would want him as a "1". I saw nothing that led me to believe he'd be a solid 2 for sure never mind even close to a "1". Chris Mullin said he could be Russell Westbrook - I like Chris and loved his game but that's blowing some serious smoke. I get they say some things that kids want to hear but c'mon.
I agree with mauconnfan. Brown's quotes in the recent past continue to talk about playing PG and playing with the ball in his hands. Not to merge threads with the Ali de-commitment, but if I recall correctly, Prince also made similar comments about wanting to play the 1 and/or play with the ball in his hands, shortly after the de-commitment.
I think a lot of these guys see James Harden, Westbrook, etc. on the pro-level, who are more in the mold of Wing guards that are asked to play a lot of point for their teams. Again, I don't have any insight beyond reading the quotes and suspecting that this is the case.
KO and staff have Adams/Gibbs for this year and are recruiting some serious talent at the PG position (Gilbert, etc.) for next year. As we all know, they like to play two of these guys at the same time on the floor. Our wings need to be able to shoot, and slash to the basket after our PGs set them up. They are not necessarily expected to create for others off the dribble. I think DHam had to do a lot of that last year because 1) he has the talent to do it and 2) we only had one other player on the team who could create (Boat) and so he had to take on a lot more of that responsibility. I expect DHam to still do a lot of that this year (especially with the forwards), but, I hope, it won't be forced upon him as much as this past season and it should be more natural in the flow of the offense.
I suspect that is why some of our recruiting has been a bit hot/cold. Both player and team are much better off knowing exactly their role before they enroll with the team. We are never going to tell a kid what he wants to hear, just to have him commit. Sometimes there may be miscommunication through the process and the result usually is the player and/or team going in different directions. I see this as a good thing. We can't get everyone. We just need to try and get the guys that fit our team puzzle best.
We all know that our MO has been two PG's on the floor at the same time which has helped produced some of our best seasons. Let's hope history repeats itself again soon.