OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 359 | The Boneyard
.-.

OT: Best Pizza in CT

WrenchFan69 said:
Plenty of places have slices. Mario's in Waterbury, Pietro's in downtown Hartford, Michel Angelo's in Rocky Hill, Three Fellas in Marlborough, Giovanni's in Glastonbury come to mind. Problem is they mostly suck
Expand ...

I likeThree Fellas although, odd as it may sound, I find it significantly better cold than hot. Michelangelo's CAN be good but that is such a skeevy place inside and I've heard things over the years working in Rocky Hill.
 
Woodson said:
What the best pizza you can get these days in southeast CT/New London area? I don’t like a lot of stuff on it
Expand ...

From 2020.
Husky25 said:
2 Wives, Recovery Room, NY Pizza, and Fireside (under new ownership), even Illiano's are all decent in that area.
Expand ...

I still work down there and I used to be on the EB audit team back in the early 2000s.

Recovery Room was the best, but the other four are still pretty good.

There's also some places off the beaten path as well, such as Nino's in Uncasville. There is a Plum Tomato in Colchester and Salem. Rolling Tomato is in Groton. Wings 'n Pies on Rte. 12 (Groton) is a thicker product, but I don't know if I would call it Greek. Golden and Village on the Green (both on Rte. 12 in Preston) are definitely Greek style, if that floats your boat.
 
boog204 said:
I likeThree Fellas although, odd as it may sound, I find it significantly better cold than hot. Michelangelo's CAN be good but that is such a skeevy place inside and I've heard things over the years working in Rocky Hill.
Expand ...
I liked Three Fellas better when it wasn't in an Atlantis gas station.

It's not bad but it used to be better before they torn down the old gas station and 7-Eleven/Three Fellas building.
 
Husky25 said:
I liked Three Fellas better when it wasn't in an Atlantis gas station.

It's not bad but it used to be better before they torn down the old gas station and 7-Eleven/Three Fellas building.
Expand ...
Agree 10000%. It was also cheaper.
 
boog204 said:
I likeThree Fellas although, odd as it may sound, I find it significantly better cold than hot. Michelangelo's CAN be good but that is such a skeevy place inside and I've heard things over the years working in Rocky Hill.
Expand ...
I have never had a bad pizza from Michel Angelo's in Rocky Hill, though not New Haven style apizza. It is better than some of the surrounding area pizza places (including Sally's in Wethersfield). Definitely not very modern or fancy inside but not "skeevy" as you say, and you don't want to know about some of the big name resturants and what they do. You would not go out to eat then.
 
Last edited:
.-.
Woodson said:
What the best pizza you can get these days in southeast CT/New London area? I don’t like a lot of stuff on it
Expand ...
Vincitori Apizza in Niantic
Nino's in Uncasville Norwich area, perhaps Friendly Pizza in same area.
Fireside Pizza in Gales Ferry got good reviews from the Hartford Courant FWIW.
Pepe's at the Sun on off hours.
edit: Village Pizza in Preston City
 
Last edited:
Duncan Idaho said:
Vincitori Apizza in Niantic
Nino's in Uncasville Norwich area, perhaps Friendly Pizza in same area.
Fireside Pizza in Gales Ferry got good reviews from the Hartford Courant FWIW.
Pepe's at the Sun on off hours.
edit: Village Pizza in Preston City
Expand ...
I have no complaints about Pepe's from Mohegan Sun and I have grabbed clam pies from there multiple times.
 
Husky Alien said:
I have never had a bad pizza from Michel Angelo's in Rocky Hill, though not New Haven style apizza. It is better than some of the surrounding area pizza places (including Sally's in Wethersfield). Definitely not very modern or fancy inside but not "skeevy" as you say, and you don't want to know about some of the big name resturants and what they do. You would not go out to eat then.
Expand ...
Agree that it’s better than most is the surrounding places. Have always found it odd that that area has pretty mediocre options. I do like Village Pizza in Wethersfield and West Side in Rocky Hill does a good Greek style.
 
WrenchFan69 said:
Plenty of places have slices. Mario's in Waterbury, Pietro's in downtown Hartford, Michel Angelo's in Rocky Hill, Three Fellas in Marlborough, Giovanni's in Glastonbury come to mind. Problem is they mostly suck
Expand ...
How about Ernie’s and Bar? Don’t they sell by the slice, or Zuppardis maybe?
 
.-.
boog204 said:
Agree that it’s better than most is the surrounding places. Have always found it odd that that area has pretty mediocre options. I do like Village Pizza in Wethersfield and West Side in Rocky Hill does a good Greek style.
Expand ...
Being from the same area and agreeing on both of those choices, if you haven't tried Carbones specialty pizzas, I highly recommend them.
 
FLDawg16 said:
No, someone started a different thread about best pizza near Fairfield in January and it got merged into this one
Expand ...
If the "best of" poll thingy is going to continue to be there, it'd be nice to rotate it across each county in CT.
 
Last edited:
Random... But does anyone have a rec for a favorite place in Colchester? Have to be over there and figured, why not get pizza? I feel like I've had Plum Tomato but I do not remember if it was good or not.
 
boog204 said:
Random... But does anyone have a rec for a favorite place in Colchester? Have to be over there and figured, why not get pizza? I feel like I've had Plum Tomato but I do not remember if it was good or not.
Expand ...

Yes. It is good and they offer by the slice.
 
.-.
boog204 said:
I agree with this. Almost all of the neighborhood slice places in NYC are very good and consistently better than the random CT slice places. Not all of them mind you. But I’ve been very disappointed in some random CT slices. Can’t say I’ve felt the same in NYC. YMMV.
Expand ...

I have similar experience, and I think its got to do with the style of pie. Abeetz with the char is meant to be eaten hot and right out of the oven. (and it is great).

While your typical roma style NY/NJ slice place pie is actually better after its been cooked, cooled, and reheated (as served in most slice places) There’s just some kind of magic alchemy that takes place when that type of pie sits and cools, and then gets reheated again. I lived in Bergen county NJ once, and there was a place with pies that were absolutely fantastic the next day cold out of the fridge. A whole different taste than the night before, and both were great.
 
Any thoughts on NL? Back in the day, Campus and Central were good. Others not. Ocean was popular w the HS crowd (near home), but it was soft and gooey.
 
sledog said:
Any thoughts on NL? Back in the day, Campus and Central were good. Others not. Ocean was popular w the HS crowd (near home), but it was soft and gooey.
Expand ...
Scroll back a page beginning @ post #8542
 
I’ll be coaching a math competition in New Haven this weekend and pizza is on the menu for lunch. What are the odds the pie is true New Haven style?
 
HCCForever said:
I have no complaints about Pepe's from Mohegan Sun and I have grabbed clam pies from there multiple times.
Expand ...
Yes!!! That was our plan all the time. Picking ponies for hours at the old Racebook (before Fanduel moved in), drinking for free while eating the white clam pies from Pepe's.
 
Last edited:
.-.


-> The 3,502-square-foot building with 22-foot vaulted ceilings will allow them to create a new, fully renovated modern space for patrons to enjoy with a full bar and three to four TVs, according to Michael Nuzzo.

“Our Madison location has a bar, and we've always wanted to add one to another location,” he added. “The current Clinton location is an older piece of property and didn't really have the room or the capacity and we can only put so much of our own money into a place we don't own.”

The new space will also include new dining room sets and kitchen equipment that were recently purchased, outdoor seating and more staff and bartenders. The menu will likely be the same, with the addition of a few new twists to their beloved thin crust pizzas and a few added appetizers and entrées, according to Michael Nuzzo.<-
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Online statistics

Members online
221
Guests online
8,177
Total visitors
8,398
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
166,509
Messages
4,482,526
Members
10,358
Latest member
wynela


Top Bottom