OT: Best Pizza in CT

[storrsroars]

You can go to the 7-Eleven near you any day of the week and get those.

But are those "veteran-owned", because it makes all the difference in taste!

 

[Hans Sprungfeld]

But are those "veteran-owned", because it makes all the difference in taste!

And here I thought it was the "authentic crispy shell."

Just remember: nobody can eat just one.

 

[WrenchFan69]

Finally had Sally's, completing the New Haven Trinity. Must say Modern is far and away my favorite, followed by Pepe's, with Sally's third. All great

 

[8893]

Finally had Sally's, completing the New Haven Trinity. Must say Modern is far and away my favorite, followed by Pepe's, with Sally's third. All great

What did you get at each?

 

[elmcityboy]

View attachment 72308Has anyone tried the pizza from Atticus Market in New Haven? They don’t make pizza every day and I think they only sell 50 pies when they do. An acquaintance told me he had a spectacular pie from Atticus. Lots of chatter in CT pizza circles about them. I pulled this pic from their website….

came back here to say that i finally got pizza from the new atticus spot on orange street the other day. it was phenomenal -- easily the best of the new-school spots in town. reminded me a lot of sally's. the crust was the highlight, as you would expect from a bread bakery -- i am kind of amazed at what they can do with a small gas-fired oven.

it was also relatively quick (20-minute wait) and the location couldn't be nicer. ate outside on one of the picnic tables after biking around east rock. highly recommend.

 

[RIP Wendys]

Thinking about dabbling in a DIY brick oven for pizza in the backyard. Any of our Pizza connoisseurs got recs for building it out? Not looking for major production rates, just an option to cook up some high quality homemade za's.

 

[methodology]

Thinking about dabbling in a DIY brick oven for pizza in the backyard. Any of our Pizza connoisseurs got recs for building it out? Not looking for major production rates, just an option to cook up some high quality homemade za's.

Make sure you use firebricks for the floor and have good insulation

 

[RIP Wendys]

Make sure you use firebricks for the floor and have good insulation

That's a great point... saw a video and they just bought random bricks and some pavers... seemed simple but I wasn't sure what types of chemicals/wear & tear would happen when exposed to high heat

 

[8893]

That's a great point... saw a video and they just bought random bricks and some pavers... seemed simple but I wasn't sure what types of chemicals/wear & tear would happen when exposed to high heat

Residential Ovens — Tuscany Fire

www.tuscanyfire.com

 

[karstenkibbe]

came back here to say that i finally got pizza from the new atticus spot on orange street the other day. it was phenomenal -- easily the best of the new-school spots in town. reminded me a lot of sally's. the crust was the highlight, as you would expect from a bread bakery -- i am kind of amazed at what they can do with a small gas-fired oven.

it was also relatively quick (20-minute wait) and the location couldn't be nicer. ate outside on one of the picnic tables after biking around east rock. highly recommend.

Ok so I would consider that a rave review. Now I really need to get my arse over there.

 

[elmcityboy]

Ok so I would consider that a rave review. Now I really need to get my arse over there.

i would say so. i have relatively high standards for pizza and had lofty expectations for atticus based on what i had heard. def met expectations.

my phone takes terrible pictures but here is a shot of the plain w- cheese:

 

[August_West]

i would say so. i have relatively high standards for pizza and had lofty expectations for atticus based on what i had heard. def met expectations.

my phone takes terrible pictures but here is a shot of the plain w- cheese:

View attachment 75963

Picture/handle

 

[elmcityboy]

Picture/handle

it could have been even more "new haven" if my girlfriend hadn't peeled the label off of the foxon park bottle in the background.

 

[WrenchFan69]

What did you get at each?

Tomato sauce + mozz. Standard as they come

 

[WrenchFan69]

i would say so. i have relatively high standards for pizza and had lofty expectations for atticus based on what i had heard. def met expectations.

my phone takes terrible pictures but here is a shot of the plain w- cheese:

View attachment 75963

My buddy's wife started baking at Atticus recently. She's immensely talented. They make incredible stuff outside the pizza, too

 

[superjohn]

Tomato sauce + mozz. Standard as they come

Still the best and I agree with your rankings. Once upon a time I thought Sally's was the best but no more.

 

[superjohn]

i would say so. i have relatively high standards for pizza and had lofty expectations for atticus based on what i had heard. def met expectations.

my phone takes terrible pictures but here is a shot of the plain w- cheese:

View attachment 75963

What's the story with this place, is it a restaurant or just a market that serves up pizzas? I'll be back in CT. in a month and want to try a new place. I've done Modern, Pepe's, Sally's, Zuppardi's, Roseland, Abate's.

That looks like a good pie. How is John and Marie's? Any other places worth trying?

 

[methodology]

Tomato sauce + mozz. Standard as they come

Did you get well done at modern?

 

[Husky Alien]

i would say so. i have relatively high standards for pizza and had lofty expectations for atticus based on what i had heard. def met expectations.

my phone takes terrible pictures but here is a shot of the plain w- cheese:

View attachment 75963

To me, that is a perfect pie.

 

[Fishy]

I cannot believe that after 11 years and 6,000 replies, you guys still have not told me what is the best pizza in Connecticut.

 

[8893]

What's the story with this place, is it a restaurant or just a market that serves up pizzas? I'll be back in CT. in a month and want to try a new place. I've done Modern, Pepe's, Sally's, Zuppardi's, Roseland, Abate's.

That looks like a good pie.

Atticus has had a cafe and bookstore on Chapel Street in New Haven for decades, adjoining the Yale British Art Museum. They recently took over the old site of Romeo & Joe’s on Orange Street and turned it into Atticus Market, which has prepared foods, select groceries and gifts, and some picnic tables out front. That’s where they sell the pizza, and I believe they only do it Thursdays through Saturdays, until they run out (around 50 pies a night).

I’ve been there for breakfast and lunch but haven’t been able to make the pizza timing work yet despite good intentions.

You might also consider trying Zeneli, Bufalina, One6Three or better yet grab takeout from Olde World and bring it to 12%.

 

[superjohn]

Atticus has had a cafe and bookstore on Chapel Street in New Haven for decades, adjoining the Yale British Art Museum. They recently took over the old site of Romeo & Joe’s on Orange Street and turned it into Atticus Market, which has prepared foods, select groceries and gifts, and some picnic tables out front. That’s where they sell the pizza, and I believe they only do it Thursdays through Saturdays, until they run out (around 50 pies a night).

I’ve been there for breakfast and lunch but haven’t been able to make the pizza timing work yet despite good intentions.

You might also consider trying Zeneli, Bufalina, One6Three or better yet grab takeout from Olde World and bring it to 12%.

Thanks. Olde World takeout and 12% sounds like a plan, two birds one stone.

Zeneli looks good but I can get good Neopolitan out here and I don't love the style like I do New Haven style.

 

[Huskybass]

Thanks. Olde World takeout and 12% sounds like a plan, two birds one stone.

Zeneli looks good but I can get good Neopolitan out here and I don't love the style like I do New Haven style.

Olde World is excellent. I had them make me a sampler pie that was all mozzarella, and 1/4 bacon, 1/4 Sausage and 1/4 meatball. It was superb. I've been back a handful of times since and it is consistently great.

 

[August_West]

I cannot believe that after 11 years and 6,000 replies, you guys still have not told me what is the best pizza in Connecticut.

any toddler can put sauce and cheese on bread.

 

[elmcityboy]

What's the story with this place, is it a restaurant or just a market that serves up pizzas? I'll be back in CT. in a month and want to try a new place. I've done Modern, Pepe's, Sally's, Zuppardi's, Roseland, Abate's.

That looks like a good pie. How is John and Marie's? Any other places worth trying?

@8893 covered it. the same family also runs chabaso, the bakery on james st that distributes ciabatta and baguettes around the region. they definitely know bread.

believe it or not, i have actually never had john and marie's. i have heard good things, though. olde world is on my list for sure. i also like brick oven on howe st as a late-night/drunk option. next door is a solid new-school spot, as well. i have some friends that swear by little rendevous in meriden, but i haven't been able to try it myself.