OT: Best Pizza in CT

[HuskyHawk]

Dude, we’ve had that stuff over here for years already.

Was legit Neopolitan style. France is quite a bit closer to Naples than New Haven is.

 

[uconnphil2016]

i’m sure we all have our own personal top tens - but some posters are clearly a cut above

Thank you

 

[I Bleed Blue]

I had Bufalina in Guilford tonight for the first time after recommendations from this thread.

My friends and I split 4 pies plus the nutella pie for dessert. I loved everything about the place. All 5 pies were very, very good. I’ll definitely be back again soon.

Thank you Boneyard!

 

[Mano]

Was legit Neopolitan style. France is quite a bit closer to Naples than New Haven is.

 

[August_West]

Do you have a personal top ten posters or is there a Boneyard wide top ten? Either way congrats @FartMan69

Yup.

I’m #1

 

[August_West]

I had Bufalina in Guilford tonight for the first time after recommendations from this thread.

My friends and I split 4 pies plus the nutella pie for dessert. I loved everything about the place and all 5 pies were very, very good. I’ll definitely be back again soon.

Thank you Boneyard!

I hope you picked up the 8893 commemorative knee pads on way out. Collectors item.

 

[Guapo]

For the next time someone says “you can find good pizza anywhere”

 

[DarthGrumpy]

For the next time someone says “you can find good pizza anywhere”

Move out of the NJ/NYC/CT plus maybe Mass, RI, Maine (Otto is decent) and Philly on a good day and its very easy to find bad pizza.

 

[Robertelamin]

Where are the best Greek places (real pizza)?

 

[superjohn]

I hope you picked up the 8893 commemorative knee pads on way out. Collectors item.

 

[superjohn]

For the next time someone says “you can find good pizza anywhere”

 

[Robertelamin]

View attachment 44602

5 guys burgers and cries

 

[Mano]

Where are the best Greek places (real pizza)?

You’re really trying to get my goat huh Bob?

 

[Robertelamin]

You’re really trying to get my goat huh Bob?

Not really, let’s go car shopping this week. I’m thinking about an Opal.

 

[nelsonmuntz]

I just found out First and Last in Middletown closed over some pissing match with the town. That was the best of the First and Last's IMO, and Middletown reminds us why they are Middletown by picking a fight with one of the 5 successful businesses on Main Street.

 

[Kolumbo]

I just found out First and Last in Middletown closed over some pissing match with the town. That was the best of the First and Last's IMO, and Middletown reminds us why they are Middletown by picking a fight with one of the 5 successful businesses on Main Street.

The Plainville location is pretty good. Looks like F&L Middletown owed $140k in back rent going back to 2016. The new owner bought the business in 2016. That's all I've read but it seems this is on the owner.

 

[nelsonmuntz]

The Plainville location is pretty good. Looks like F&L Middletown owed $140k in back rent going back to 2016. The new owner bought the business in 2016. That's all I've read but it seems this is on the owner.

I am sure the owner was not completely innocent, but the city was a big part of the problem too. They are the landlord, but then they took away a lot of the parking for that location, meaning that F&L got to fight over limited street parking, which basically put it out of the banquet and party business. The city then refused to renegotiate the lease.

The city made a business decision not to renegotiate, and the owner made a business decision not to piss hundreds of thousands of dollars away on a location that could no longer be profitable at the current rent. Now Middletown has a vacant storefront on Main Street that can compete with all the other vacant storefronts on Main Street for the 2 businesses that may want to open downtown in any given year.

I thought MIddletown's was the best of the three that I had been to. I like the Hartford location better than Plainville, although both are good. First and last is a different take on pizza without going crazy.

 

[nelsonmuntz]

I haven't been to John's Best in Norwalk in 10+ years, but growing up, it was one of my family's "go to" dinner places, and the only one we went to for pizza. It was still excellent when i went around 2007 or so.

 

[Kolumbo]

Mama Luke's in Farmington was a Joey Garlics but I believe one of the partners split off and re-branded. Joey Garlics had pretty good think crust.

 

[Kolumbo]

I am sure the owner was not completely innocent, but the city was a big part of the problem too. They are the landlord, but then they took away a lot of the parking for that location, meaning that F&L got to fight over limited street parking, which basically put it out of the banquet and party business. The city then refused to renegotiate the lease.

The city made a business decision not to renegotiate, and the owner made a business decision not to piss hundreds of thousands of dollars away on a location that could no longer be profitable at the current rent. Now Middletown has a vacant storefront on Main Street that can compete with all the other vacant storefronts on Main Street for the 2 businesses that may want to open downtown in any given year.

I thought MIddletown's was the best of the three that I had been to. I like the Hartford location better than Plainville, although both are good. First and last is a different take on pizza without going crazy.

Not completely innocent? It sounds like both sides contributed to the demise but simply not paying rent at all is not trying to renegotiate in good faith. I'm not sure I'd be willing to "renegotiate" with a tenant who chose not to pay rent for over two years. We don't have a record of the conversations or the financials but as Thorogood said, "Now next Friday come I didn't get the rent, and out the door I went"

 

[Deepster]

I just found out First and Last in Middletown closed over some pissing match with the town. That was the best of the First and Last's IMO, and Middletown reminds us why they are Middletown by picking a fight with one of the 5 successful businesses on Main Street.

For me, you can’t beat the original on Maple Ave. My parents would send me there when it was only the room on the left with pots of sauce, pasta, sausage and meatballs behind the bar. The pizza came later on.

 

[mustafa]

Ace Memeti's new place, Nonna Pizza, in Plainville is really good.
They have many specialty pizzas but the Penne Vodka Pizza is really good.

 

[mauconnfan]

I just found out First and Last in Middletown closed over some pissing match with the town. That was the best of the First and Last's IMO, and Middletown reminds us why they are Middletown by picking a fight with one of the 5 successful businesses on Main Street.

In my eyes (and stomach) that was by far the worst of the 4 I've been to. PLainville the best original #2 and Avon #3 with Middletown a distant 4th. And thats the feeling of the Middletown people also they didn't like it the last few years it lost it's flavor and consistency. .Mondo's in Middletown the best there anyway excellent pie!

 

[mauconnfan]

Mama Luke's in Farmington was a Joey Garlics but I believe one of the partners split off and re-branded. Joey Garlics had pretty good think crust.

It was Rossini's prior to Joey Garlics and that's when it was at it's best. Rossini's sauce was so good you could get a "plain" with just parmesan sprinkled on it and it was a great pie.

Just so Deep and AW know I almost asked them to make me a Spooker

 

[Deepster]

At some point here we debated how good Cumberland Farms pizza was. Pres just gave it a 0.8 for what it’s worth.

Barstool Pizza Review - Cumberland Farms (Nantucket) Barstool Sports