The thing we criticize is his in game coaching and records, because it’s the same thing every year. Everything else he’s done well at, agreed. Vastly surpassed everyone’s OOC expectations.
No one came in here with NC expectations for this year. I’d assume, most came in here saying finish top 3 in the big east, and/or a second game win in the BET, and win a first round game in the NCAAT.
It also doesn’t help that we started 14-0 and were playing so great. That changed expectations. People defending Hurley and our current rank, use our OOC record to mock the people criticizing Hurley. People criticizing Hurley use our OOC record to justify the expectations for this years BE.
A certain number of fans compare him to Calhoun. He is not Calhoun. He will never be Calhoun. There will never be another Calhoun. If people are crazy enough to compare the two and have that as your bar you will never be happy.
Hurley is a good coach, any suggestion otherwise is foolish. Is he a great coach? At the moment, no, and time will tell what he becomes.
If you're hung up on losing to St. John's get over it, UNC lost to almost 200 Kenpom ranked Pitt at home last year and went to the title game. Houston lost to ECU and Tulsa their final four year. Teams have bad losses. Its how you respond which matters.
Winning in March will be the only way to get the DH detractors to shut up, and we have proven we can win games against non BE teams and proven we can win neutral site tournaments. These are the games you play in the NCAAT.
You want to sit around and have a dump in your pants all season, so be it, there are plenty of people who will join you with soiled pants, I will enjoy the wins, recognize what this team is capable and keep planning on playing deep into March.