The Official 2025 New York Mets thread

[storrsroars]

I'm assuming if the Mets lose one more game, they will be the most expensive payroll in any US sport to not make the postseason? Is that correct?

And that's w/o the luxury tax.

 

[dvegas]

The Mess performance over the last couple of months is exactly why some people aren't sports fans

 

[Deepster]

I feel like throwing up.

 

[navery12]

I'm assuming if the Mets lose one more game, they will be the most expensive payroll in any US sport to not make the postseason? Is that correct?

And that's w/o the luxury tax.

No, 2023 Mets had a higher payroll and missed the playoffs

 

[navery12]

Down to the last day of the season again, not feeling optimistic that we're relying on the Brewers

 

[husky8273]

crazy collapse since June.

 

[navery12]

Unfathomable collapse. Have a feeling the team is going to look a lot different next year

 

[dvegas]

11/3/25 is just around the corner. I'm putting 2025 Mets in a category with the 2007 Mets, "would you rather have your son or daughter drop dead suddenly?"

 

[Alum86]

Absolute total collapse. And the Reds lose today. Sickening. No runs. Just another lay down loss.

 

[Hunt for 7]

I am a Yankee fan and deepster really trolled me earlier this year, but I will only say this…..we may not have the Yankee mystique anymore and maybe those ghosts never left the old stadium.

But it is October and the Yankees are playing like they usually do in October. The Mets…not so much…….

 

[Deepster]

I am a Yankee fan and deepster really trolled me earlier this year, but I will only say this…..we may not have the Yankee mystique anymore and maybe those ghosts never left the old stadium.

But it is October and the Yankees are playing like they usually do in October. The Mets…not so much…….

Are you going to show back up when Judge goes 2 for 20 with 16 strikeouts?

 

[HooperScooper]

I can't even imagine what it's like to be a Mets fan and a Jets fan. That's some hell you need to deal with.

 

[FanInNC]

I am a Yankee fan and deepster really trolled me earlier this year, but I will only say this…..we may not have the Yankee mystique anymore and maybe those ghosts never left the old stadium.

But it is October and the Yankees are playing like they usually do in October. The Mets…not so much…….

Aaron Boone has never won a season series against the Mets.

 

[FanInNC]

welp. The freaking marlins seal our fate. Feels like 2007 all over again.

I’m trying not to knee jerk react here, but Mendy has to go, right? The low basketball IQ errors and lack of urgency this team had at times - not covering home on a pass ball, not covering third on a stolen base attempt when the pitcher stepped off … these things happening in the most important games of the year! That’s on coaching to me. Pete talked about after the game today that this team didn’t pick each other up enough. The staff sets the tone. They set the standard. If that’s an issue that’s a culture problem and the coach sets the culture.

It wasn’t long ago our “pitching lab” was lauded as this model that was the envy of the league. Our pitching is a joke. What happened??

We have a glut of guys who are redundant on the roster (Baty, Vientos, Mauricio, Acuna, McNeil, Marte) all either corner or middle infielders or can’t even play the fiend effectively - please trade away most of them. Make a decision on a 3B and shop the rest. Personally I hope we trade Nimmo in a way. We need better defense in the OF. Soto is obviously a stud bat, he’s fine the OF but he’s not a gold glover. We can’t afford multiple average to sub average OFers. Same on the infield. Vientos can’t field. McNeil is great for versatility but I’d prefer us get a plus glove at 2B. Help our pitching out.

McNeil doesn’t hit for power and now doesn’t hit for average. He doesn’t walk a ton. I appreciate him and Nimmo as life long Mets but it’s time to move on.

Figure out how to bring Pete back. Lindor and Soto and Alvy are a nice core. McLean is a great piece on the staff. Diaz has been nails. But it’s open season for everyone else IMO. Torrens and Taylor are very nice defensive bench pieces.

What a massive disappointment.

 

[navery12]

welp. The freaking marlins seal our fate. Feels like 2007 all over again.

I’m trying not to knee jerk react here, but Mendy has to go, right? The low basketball IQ errors and lack of urgency this team had at times - not covering home on a pass ball, not covering third on a stolen base attempt when the pitcher stepped off … these things happening in the most important games of the year! That’s on coaching to me. Pete talked about after the game today that this team didn’t pick each other up enough. The staff sets the tone. They set the standard. If that’s an issue that’s a culture problem and the coach sets the culture.

It wasn’t long ago our “pitching lab” was lauded as this model that was the envy of the league. Our pitching is a joke. What happened??

We have a glut of guys who are redundant on the roster (Baty, Vientos, Mauricio, Acuna, McNeil, Marte) all either corner or middle infielders or can’t even play the fiend effectively - please trade away most of them. Make a decision on a 3B and shop the rest. Personally I hope we trade Nimmo in a way. We need better defense in the OF. Soto is obviously a stud bat, he’s fine the OF but he’s not a gold glover. We can’t afford multiple average to sub average OFers. Same on the infield. Vientos can’t field. McNeil is great for versatility but I’d prefer us get a plus glove at 2B. Help our pitching out.

McNeil doesn’t hit for power and now doesn’t hit for average. He doesn’t walk a ton. I appreciate him and Nimmo as life long Mets but it’s time to move on.

Figure out how to bring Pete back. Lindor and Soto and Alvy are a nice core. McLean is a great piece on the staff. Diaz has been nails. But it’s open season for everyone else IMO. Torrens and Taylor are very nice defensive bench pieces.

What a massive disappointment.

Agree with most of what you said, but no interest in trading Nimmo away. Definitely need to improve the lineup around him but he's above average in LF. Baty will be the starting 3B next year and Vientos the Dan Hurley, agree you can't have him in the field anymore. Acuna and Mauricio will definitely be moved, hopefully McNeil too.

Have a bad feeling Pete and Edwin Diaz are both gone. Pete already opted out and Diaz is a lock to do the same. I'd re-sign both but that might be a tough task.

Pitching staff is where the questions are for me. They have Senga, Manaea, Holmes, Peterson, McLean, Scott, Sproat all under contract, and Tong at some point too. Need to add an ace but also probably need to trade a few guys away as well. And the bullpen is down to Raley and Minter, gonna need a bunch of additions there

 

[DoctorWho85]

Hefner and Chavez need to answer some serious questions why both pitching And hitting have regressed to AA ball outside of the guys from the minors. I think Hefner has run his course and it's time to move on

 

[ShakyTheMohel]

I am a Yankee fan and deepster really trolled me earlier this year, but I will only say this…..we may not have the Yankee mystique anymore and maybe those ghosts never left the old stadium.

But it is October and the Yankees are playing like they usually do in October. The Mets…not so much…….

I actually feel a bit for Mets fans. I really didn’t expect them to crash like this. I liked Soto on the Yankees and he finished strong for the Mets. They have an owner that is doing everything he can to deliver a winner…which I wish the Yankees had. I think it’s a matter of time that this team with that owner win a championship.

 

[Alum86]

welp. The freaking marlins seal our fate. Feels like 2007 all over again.

I’m trying not to knee jerk react here, but Mendy has to go, right? The low basketball IQ errors and lack of urgency this team had at times - not covering home on a pass ball, not covering third on a stolen base attempt when the pitcher stepped off … these things happening in the most important games of the year! That’s on coaching to me. Pete talked about after the game today that this team didn’t pick each other up enough. The staff sets the tone. They set the standard. If that’s an issue that’s a culture problem and the coach sets the culture.

It wasn’t long ago our “pitching lab” was lauded as this model that was the envy of the league. Our pitching is a joke. What happened??

We have a glut of guys who are redundant on the roster (Baty, Vientos, Mauricio, Acuna, McNeil, Marte) all either corner or middle infielders or can’t even play the fiend effectively - please trade away most of them. Make a decision on a 3B and shop the rest. Personally I hope we trade Nimmo in a way. We need better defense in the OF. Soto is obviously a stud bat, he’s fine the OF but he’s not a gold glover. We can’t afford multiple average to sub average OFers. Same on the infield. Vientos can’t field. McNeil is great for versatility but I’d prefer us get a plus glove at 2B. Help our pitching out.

McNeil doesn’t hit for power and now doesn’t hit for average. He doesn’t walk a ton. I appreciate him and Nimmo as life long Mets but it’s time to move on.

Figure out how to bring Pete back. Lindor and Soto and Alvy are a nice core. McLean is a great piece on the staff. Diaz has been nails. But it’s open season for everyone else IMO. Torrens and Taylor are very nice defensive bench pieces.

What a massive disappointment.

Good post. I vehemently disagree about Lumpy (Alonso). Let his ass walk. So, so many 0-4 games. Soto was great. Vientos has to go, McNeil too. Alvarez is young (still) but he is so fragile.
Diaz cost us more games than a nail down closer should. But who else do we have.
The pitching was a dumpster fire. Too much to comment on.

I digress…. I am a Mets and Dolphins fan. So like Deepster, it’s been a while since our pro teams have won. I never in my wildest dreams, however, thought as a 22 year old kid in ‘86 our Huskies would eventually have 6 BB nattys and a D1 football team.
We have that.

 

[FanInNC]

Agree with most of what you said, but no interest in trading Nimmo away. Definitely need to improve the lineup around him but he's above average in LF. Baty will be the starting 3B next year and Vientos the Dan Hurley, agree you can't have him in the field anymore. Acuna and Mauricio will definitely be moved, hopefully McNeil too.

Have a bad feeling Pete and Edwin Diaz are both gone. Pete already opted out and Diaz is a lock to do the same. I'd re-sign both but that might be a tough task.

Pitching staff is where the questions are for me. They have Senga, Manaea, Holmes, Peterson, McLean, Scott, Sproat all under contract, and Tong at some point too. Need to add an ace but also probably need to trade a few guys away as well. And the bullpen is down to Raley and Minter, gonna need a bunch of additions there

Fair enough on Nimmo. I guess I’m frustrated and also look at him as a guy on the decline in the field. He used to play CF now is more appropriately placed in Left, has good enough range but not a great arm and he’ll be 33 next year. Just seems like we’ve seen his best days and it’ll be a Marte situation before long so if you could get value for him now maybe make a move.

The pitching is definitely where Stearns will need to earn his paycheck. Numbers wise you have :
Senga
Manaea
Holmes
Peterson
McLean
Sproat
Tong
Scott

That’s 8 arms right there who have at some point shown you enough to feel good. BUT Senga is incredibly fragile. Manaea was great for one season and has not been that dude for any other season of his career. Peterson was an all star but crashed hard. Seems he’s more of a 4/5 guy. McLean you feel great about. Sproat was solid but not overly dominant, he feels like a back end guy until proven otherwise. Tong flashes high end potential but he’s not quite ready. And Scott is coming off an injury and really shouldn’t be counted on.

We need a front end guy. Idk who that is but we need someone to anchor this staff and take some pressure off of the young arms.

 

[FanInNC]

Good post. I vehemently disagree about Lumpy (Alonso). Let his ass walk. So, so many 0-4 games. Soto was great. Vientos has to go, McNeil too. Alvarez is young (still) but he is so fragile.
Diaz cost us more games than a nail down closer should. But who else do we have.
The pitching was a dumpster fire. Too much to comment on.

I digress…. I am a Mets and Dolphins fan. So like Deepster, it’s been a while since our pro teams have won. I never in my wildest dreams, however, thought as a 22 year old kid in ‘86 our Huskies would eventually have 6 BB nattys and a D1 football team.
We have that.

Last year I may have agreed with you. But Pete led our team in batting average this year! He also hasn’t missed a game in 2 years. There is something to be said for that. He can be super streaky and get lost at times, but he can carry you for a week also.

He’s actually a pretty solid glove I think. He’s prone to misplay a towering foul ball where he has to run backwards or sometimes sail a throw to the pitcher or catcher but he picks the ball nicely and has made some nice stops on some scorchers. I personally don’t get the Pete hate I see sometimes in comment sections.

 

[navery12]

Good post. I vehemently disagree about Lumpy (Alonso). Let his ass walk. So, so many 0-4 games. Soto was great. Vientos has to go, McNeil too. Alvarez is young (still) but he is so fragile.
Diaz cost us more games than a nail down closer should. But who else do we have.
The pitching was a dumpster fire. Too much to comment on.

I digress…. I am a Mets and Dolphins fan. So like Deepster, it’s been a while since our pro teams have won. I never in my wildest dreams, however, thought as a 22 year old kid in ‘86 our Huskies would eventually have 6 BB nattys and a D1 football team.
We have that.

Pete might have been streaky, but he was still the best offensive 1B in baseball this year. If he wants an absurd contract again and gets it sure, let him walk. But you also have to be ready to accept a huge step back from an already weak lineup as a result. There's no better option waiting. If Pete walks you're looking at Mark Vientos as your everyday 1B.

Diaz is a free agent so you may get your wish there as well and see what it's actually like to have an inconsistent closer. He had a 1.68 ERA and there were only 3 guys with fewer blown saves in the top 20 closers this year

 

[DoctorWho85]

I actually feel a bit for Mets fans. I really didn’t expect them to crash like this. I liked Soto on the Yankees and he finished strong for the Mets. They have an owner that is doing everything he can to deliver a winner…which I wish the Yankees had. I think it’s a matter of time that this team with that owner win a championship.

On paper Stearns made great decisions in signing (outside of Mullins) and trades. I did not expect everyone to basically regress to minor league level the moment they hit the Mets roster. I know it happens, but it's still frustrating.

 

[Deepster]

Just a weird year. When you think about all the moves that paid off last year (Manaea, Iglesias, Winker, etc) and how so many of them flopped this year (Helsley, Manaea, Mullins). Hefner went from a genius to having the worst staff in the league. Mendy had the midas touch with all his moves last year and nothing worked this year. No chemistry or vibes. An amazingly unbelievable record of what, 0-60 when trailing after 8 innings?!

So many areas to address, but....
1) Signing Diaz is priority #1.
2) Paying Alonso is priority #2. A fair deal that rewards him for what he's done can hopefully be reached. Sure, he has his flaws but we need him behind Soto and he's played 162 for 2 years straight now. He's a Met through and through and I'd like to see him finish out his prime here. I did NOT enjoy seeing deGrom pitch against us....don't want the same with Pete.
3) Of Baty, Vientos, Mauricio, Acuna, I can't believe I'm saying this but I think Baty is the only guy I care about coming back.

 

[Alum86]

Last year I may have agreed with you. But Pete led our team in batting average this year! He also hasn’t missed a game in 2 years. There is something to be said for that. He can be super streaky and get lost at times, but he can carry you for a week also.

He’s actually a pretty solid glove I think. He’s prone to misplay a towering foul ball where he has to run backwards or sometimes sail a throw to the pitcher or catcher but he picks the ball nicely and has made some nice stops on some scorchers. I personally don’t get the Pete hate I see sometimes in comment sections.

He would get lost for weeks at a time.
I have no issue with his D.

 

[FanInNC]

He would get lost for weeks at a time.
I have no issue with his D.

I guess I don’t know the list of available 1B who are better than Pete. I don’t think there are a plethora of guys out there who are on his level and can be had. He is streaky and can be ice cold, but the end of the day he had a higher average than anyone on our team and was 2nd to only Soto in OPS, 2nd in the league in RBI and had 80 extra base hits.

He is a lock to 35-40 home runs every year. Thats hard to replace. When you see a guy every day for multiple years you see all his warts and poor stretches but I think maybe it can be taken for granted what he brings to the table.

I think about the years of Lucas Duda, James Looney, Ike Davis, Dom Smith, Wilmer Flores, Tony Clark, Todd Zeile, Butch Husky, Rico Brogna…I don’t want to go back to something like that. Pete has his flaws but he is worlds better than what we’ve had over the last 20 years.

If there’s a John Olereud or Carlos Delgado floating around out there for less money than Pete then ok, I’m all for it. I just don’t know who that option is with Guerrero re-upping with Toronto.