I’ve withheld commenting on this for a while, mostly because this thing is way too nuanced to really break down, but this is my quick and dirty take.
I do not hate the AAC as much as most do, but without a major shift in the P5 power structure, I just don’t see any way that the College Sports Overlords ever truly legitimize this conference. In addition, does anyone ever envision a time where all the schools in this conference are dedicated to staying and building it? UCF, USF, Houston, Memphis, and Cincy are all looking for the first boat off this island and I doubt that changes anytime soon. It’s hard to really get behind the AAC when you know the only good things about it could leave at any moment.
In a perfect world, the AAC continues to grow/evolve and we play a role in that but I just can’t see that being the case long-term. The NBE isn’t a perfect answer either, but there’s a comfort/familiarity that just works for us in so many areas. I absolutely love UConn Football, but we’ve watched the devaluation of the basketball program go on too long. Imagining what Dan Hurley can do selling the UConn brand in the Big East is incredibly exciting. This may be just dumb speculation, but if not, this is a move we have to make.