Mir in transfer portal | Page 4 | The Boneyard

Mir in transfer portal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dillon77 said:
I watched her during the ND-Georgia game just after Thanksgiving. She had an insane number of steals (8?), in contributing to Olivia Mile's worst day in college (thus far). Mikayla is still very instinctive on defense with good burst speed, which helps her dart into passing lanes. On offense, she's still a drive-first player. Solid contributor on that UGA team.
Expand ...
Mikayla Coombs checks every box you would want from a basketball player except one. She just isn't a good shooter. But she is most definitely one of the toughest on ball defenders I've seen.
 
Cornell Lt said:
Mir would fit nicely on Seton Hall's team
Expand ...
MilfordHusky said:
Does anyone know who were Mir’s finalists? I see possible destinations as Maryland, Vandy, and Seton Hall.
Expand ...
Hard to believe Maryland would be interested as they are such an offense dominant team. I think she would find herself in basically the same quandary as she faced here. I think Arizona would be a perfect place for her. Az is a defensive minded team that plays everyone! So sorry to see her go!

I have to believe she may have been let down by coaches/mentors in the past who may not (it appears) have pushed her to go beyond her incredible athleticism and develop an offensive game beyond layups and put backs. Perhaps a cautionary tale for other athletically gifted players who may be tempted to rely on their physical dominance in high school rather than developing a more well-rounded game for when that will not be enough. Not saying that is definitely true in Muir’s case, but it seems likely to me.

Speaking of which, I’m very happy to see Ayana P improving her outside shot and free throws. If she can become a good outside shooter and an 80%+ free throw shooter, she is going to be a very scary player!

Anyway, farewell and best of luck, Mir. I will miss you!
 
Maybe Mir is actually helping the team by opening up a roster spot for another transfer player next year.
The 5th year of eligibility rule due to covid, and the fact that many UConn players enter the draft instead of returning puts UConn at a disadvantage.
Incoming transfers who are upper classmen would help fill some needs if Geno feels it's necessary.

IMO folks are jumping to conclusions that it's only about playing time when a 5th year scholarship and a red shirt year of eligibility may also be involved if Mir transfers now.
AFAIK Mir herself hasn't said that it's about PT at all.
Why should student athletes need to explain that academic scholarship funds are an important consideration when transferring schools because paying for extra years of college is an expensive & personal financial matter?
Not every student wants to load up on future college loans if it's not necessary.
 
Last edited:
.-.
Centerstream said:
Geno develops his bench by playing the players that earn their playing time. I think this (transferring) may say more about a player's dedication than Geno. Every player that comes here knows what Geno is like and what is expected. If they don't really have what it takes, they leave. As has been stated, she had multiple opportunities, along with others, and yet here we are.
Expand ...
I disagree
 
Sorry I am all thumbs today. While she certainly was the best to leave the program it was more than ten years ago.
 
There seems to be a disconnect somewhere. Either kids have unrealistic expectations on their own or the coaches created them.

Everyone always says, what makes UConn women's basketball great is that star players come UConn and check their egos because winning national championships is the important thing to them. Truly admirable. However, when you stop winning national championships, there's a lot less reason to subdue your personal goals and interests.
 
MilfordHusky said:
I’m disappointed but not surprised. She wants to play, and UConn wasn’t a good fit. She is behind Caroline at the SF and would be behind Ice and Ayanna at the PF.

I hope she lands in a good spot, where she is happy, gets a good education, and can contribute on the court. Best wishes to Mir!

I’ve seen 4 recruits in the DMV over the past 7 or so years: De’Janae, Mir, Saylor, and (gulp) Azzi. I sure hope Azzi doesn’t go anywhere!!!
Expand ...
We need you to stop recruiting them to UConn… you don’t have a good eye.
 
I was a Mir fan from the beginning. Sadly, to many players at the right time. And circumstance made to transfer take place. Covid, rules changes, extra year of eligibility and no departures.

Prior to Anna leaving I honestly thought that Mir was going to enter the portal first. I always have said that others were going to leave. Even
Saylor transferring wasn’t a shock.

Let’s hope that things chill out for now. The team cannot afford to loose another player.
 
.-.
LoboDays said:
I didn’t see much difference between her face and anyone else’s on this team right now.

Not tall enough to play post. Can’t shoot well enough to play guard. Looks lost (in the 5 seconds) when she’s in the floor. She played well enough to be recruited by a program that brings in the best of the best……but now, she is next to useless? I think there may be more going on here.

Expand ...

It’s not easy to play for Geno… these ladies are scared to miss a defensive assignment or a layup. Easy for Geno to say “I told you she’s not ready”. They offered her a scholarship for what they saw not what they can turn the player into. It’s too much pressure… from Geno and probably on Geno since he hasn’t won anything in 5 years
 
A lot of the players that don’t fit in at UConn usually comes down to BBall IQ. In high school and AAU the player can succeed purely because that are just more athletic than the competition. In college, and particularly at UConn, you need to really understand the game and the intricacy's of the offense and defense. That where a lot of players struggle and fall by the wayside.
 
.-.
pvdoggy said:
This is the part I do not understand about Uconn recruiting. It is probably not the case but it certainly feels like among the top programs in wbb, Uconn seems to have had a relatively high number of transfers in the last 5-6 years compared to other programs.
Expand ...
Some can’t take Geno style… and that’s fine
 
DaddyChoc said:
It’s not easy to play for Geno… these ladies are scared to miss a defensive assignment or a layup. Easy for Geno to say “I told you she’s not ready”. They offered her a scholarship for what they saw not what they can turn the player into. It’s too much pressure… from Geno and probably on Geno since he hasn’t won anything in 5 years
Expand ...
Except for the select 5, just like every other D1 program.
 
.-.
oldude said:
Mir played only 8 total minutes this season, so it’s difficult to evaluate her performance without seeing her at practice...
Expand ...
This.

Unless those on here are watching practice every day, it is just not on to offer generalizations on a player's talents - shooting, ball handling, etc... Those who have played at the high school and college levels know how difficult it is to play in those exceptionally rare occasions when called upon. Every whistle means a turn to look at the scorer's table. Every shot carries, "If I miss this, I'm out." Same for a missed rebound, or turnover. There is no settling into the game. Hence, those of us who watch games only, cannot accurately judge the true capabilities of this player. I was impressed with her for whatever brief opportunity coach afforded her - she certainly gave max effort. But off that sample size?

I suppose the inexorable need to validate everything coach does drives a lot of this, but, for me, it's just wrong. Horses for courses.

Her reasons for this are her own - full stop. I join those on here wishing her the best. Hopefully time will afford her the opportunity to make whatever her dreams for her college experience was to be come true.
 
Gabby was very different from Mir. In fact, Gabby was unique in our program. She was nearly an Olympian in the high jump at age 15 or so. Jay Bilas called her the best player in America. She's much stronger than Mir. She made more super-human plays than anyone except maybe Maya. Gabby is improving her jump shot and doing very well in Europe. I expect her to have a breakout season in the WNBA.
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,349
Messages
4,566,527
Members
10,469
Latest member
xxBlueChips


Top Bottom