- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 34,460
- Reaction Score
- 101,780
Was there a chance 77-74 wasn't posting on the dates he was in jail and in court?

Another classic mau zinger. If you could just reallocate the time you spend obsessing about me and put it into basic thinking skills, there's a chance that in only a few short months you could pass for a regular below average human.Was there a chance 77-74 wasn't posting on the dates he was in jail and in court?![]()
Another classic mau zinger. If you could just reallocate the time you spend obsessing about me and put it into basic thinking skills, there's a chance that in only a few short months you could pass for a regular below average human.
I like that you made this a question. It's like "I'm Ron Burgandy?".LOL couldn't have imagined you'd come up with such a creative comeback?
Elements of truth in "maturation" HAG (humility -see things as they really are) (acceptance - life on life terms) (gratitude -count blessings instead of losses)It is but the thinking is starting to change.
What if addiction is actually not a progressive disease like cancer or something ( like the 12 step programs tout) but is actually a learning disability?
What if all these years where we claimed " acceptance " was the key that the acceptance was actually maturation?
Elements of truth in "maturation" HAG (humility -see things as they really are) (acceptance - life on life terms) (gratitude -count blessings instead of losses)
Alcoholism = 3 fold disease: Spiritual (I am not God, need a higher power) Mental/emotional and Physical. Addiction is the physical part which goes away
after detox in a few days. Mental/emotional = obsession leads to picking up a drink or drug which sets of a chain reaction of obsessive (More) compulsive (pick it up)
behavior. Only a miracle of relief of the obsession will stop an alcoholic from drinking. Teenage alcoholics have never gone through the teen maturity that the average
person does and so has to go back and learn how to live life that they never learned. Growth stops when chemicals are taken to alter conscience. But "once an alcoholic
always an alcoholic" (never be able to safely ingest alcohol again = allergy of mind and body)
It doesn't claim to be based in science. It believes that the disease of alcoholism is physical, mental/emotional and spiritual. It cooperates with the scientific community as well as churches
It doesn't claim to be based in science. It believes that the disease of alcoholism is physical, mental/emotional and spiritual. It cooperates with the scientific community as well as churches
and psychology. It is a fellowship. It has no opinions on outside groups or methods.
AA receives $0 health care dollars. Insurance companies began to require a 12 step component in treatment simply because it was to their financial advantage because it increased the chances of success.
There are changes in the brain of a n alcoholic that remain without drinking and won't exist in me if I went on a month long bender. This gives some scientific credence to that once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic concept you dislike.
I don't know if this is personal to you or if you are responding on behalf of empiricism. What I know is that when I look at people who were a mess and are now happy and productive, a 12 step program is involved the vast, vast majority of the time
AA receives $0 health care dollars. Insurance companies began to require a 12 step component in treatment simply because it was to their financial advantage because it increased the chances of success.
There are changes in the brain of a n alcoholic that remain without drinking and won't exist in me if I went on a month long bender. This gives some scientific credence to that once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic concept you dislike.
I don't know if this is personal to you or if you are responding on behalf of empiricism. What I know is that when I look at people who were a mess and are now happy and productive, a 12 step program is involved the vast, vast majority of the time
My take is that it is proven to be the Best way for long term success. It has a track record. It is to be commended for that. It has most likely saved millions of lives. There is no arguing with success. But it may not be the "only way" . And maybe what Tdrink was getting at (or maybe not, I dont want to put words in his mouth) is that there are some that espouse it as the "only way" from within the rooms (despite what the "official stance" may be....Ive seen it) and from outside.
@8893 consider me inspired.
It is not personal to me, so I won't press it. There is no doubt it works for some people so it's effectiveness is never supposed to be questioned.
The horse had a good track record of moving people and goods around prior to the invention of the internal combustion engine. Arguing for gas powered engines is not arguing against horses or denying their track record of success.
August, you advocate for harm reduction policies. Those fly generally in the face of the 12 step all or nothing approach.
So many emotional ties to this issue from so many people that it makes rational discussions extremely difficult. Best for me to step away from the topic.
The horse had a good track record of moving people and goods around prior to the invention of the internal combustion engine. Arguing for gas powered engines is not arguing against horses or denying their track record of success.
August, you advocate for harm reduction policies. Those fly generally in the face of the 12 step all or nothing approach.
So many emotional ties to this issue from so many people that it makes rational discussions extremely difficult. Best for me to step away from the topic.
It doesn't claim to be based in science. It believes that the disease of alcoholism is physical, mental/emotional and spiritual. It cooperates with the scientific community as well as churches
and psychology. It is a fellowship. It has no opinions on outside groups or methods.
Yes I'm a major advocate for harm reduction. What " harm reduction " amounts to for me is getting people to not die or not go to jail in the interim before they are ready for a different way of life.
I believe AA/ NA program is a valuable asset to those in need and provides a long term path.
Where I differ with that is with the " hes not ready yet" or the " gotta hit your bottom first" . Yes that is one way, but some peoples bottoms are death or jail. Harm reduction is a bridge between active, destructive use and long term recovery.
Ive always said that AA/NA steps are really mostly a set of life principles that EVERYONE can benefit from applying.
If you remove the early steps that everyone freaks out about ( admitting higher power, admitting powerlessness) which a are specific to your addiction, what are you left with?
Making a searching and fearless moral inventory of yourself? Right on. Who wouldn't benefit from honest introspection?
Making amends to people you've wronged? You dont have to be an addict to have wronged people . A clear conscience is a wonderful thing. For anyone.
Bettering yourself and the world by being in service to others?
Sure. sign me up. I'm an an idealist. I've always believed that.
Commie.Yes I'm a major advocate for harm reduction. What " harm reduction " amounts to for me is getting people to not die or not go to jail in the interim before they are ready for a different way of life.
I believe AA/ NA program is a valuable asset to those in need and provides a long term path.
Where I differ with that is with the " hes not ready yet" or the " gotta hit your bottom first" . Yes that is one way, but some peoples bottoms are death or jail. Harm reduction is a bridge between active, destructive use and long term recovery.
Ive always said that AA/NA steps are really mostly a set of life principles that EVERYONE can benefit from applying.
If you remove the early steps that everyone freaks out about ( admitting higher power, admitting powerlessness) which a are specific to your addiction, what are you left with?
Making a searching and fearless moral inventory of yourself? Right on. Who wouldn't benefit from honest introspection?
Making amends to people you've wronged? You dont have to be an addict to have wronged people . A clear conscience is a wonderful thing. For anyone.
Bettering yourself and the world by being in service to others?
Sure. sign me up. I'm an an idealist. I've always believed that.
I agree with most of what you say. There may be a day where our knowledge of neural pathways changes everything.The crux of the article I keep referring to is that the Europeans now treat alcoholism by having heavy drinkers take a pill before they start drinking. The pill overrides the neural pathways that get "pleasure" (sense of normalcy) from alcohol. Within a couple of days the person no longer has the desire to drink. Whether or not there is relapse the harm reduction is almost immediate and at a very low relative cost. But it's implementation has been objected.
I see alcoholism as the "hijacking" of neural pathways. I think it is a mental illness much like depression. The brain has the capability to be "normal" but is stuck in a loop. I don't believe it is a progressive disease. And I don't believe that people should be told they have to bottom out and that they can never touch a drop or they will end up on a bender. .
I agree with most of what you say. There may be a day where our knowledge of neural pathways changes everything.
But I think it is a progressive disease. It follows a pattern, gets worse, etc.
And making amends? I think you are underestimating the level of narcissism that develops from addiction. That is different than a typical depressed person.
If you read this thread, you know I'm not for waiting for people to hit their bottom. There was a pretty intense conversation a few pages back. We agree on that too
Thanks for this post. There is all kinds of help for the suffering alcoholic/addict. On the matter of "bottom". The 12th step is about carrying the message (of hope) to the alcoholic who still suffers. "Bottoms" can be raised by revealing what alcoholism really is and how there can be hope. At the beginning of nearly every meeting a reading from chapter 5 of the Book "Alcoholics Anonymous" is read. This passage is called "How it Works". It begins with the words "Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed are path". Unfortunately for the suffering alcoholic, they are there own worst enemy. They often do not have the words "I need help" in their vocabulary. By attending meetings they can see that they are not alone, that there is a way out if they keep an open mind.I agree with most of what you say. There may be a day where our knowledge of neural pathways changes everything.
But I think it is a progressive disease. It follows a pattern, gets worse, etc.
And making amends? I think you are underestimating the level of narcissism that develops from addiction. That is different than a typical depressed person.
If you read this thread, you know I'm not for waiting for people to hit their bottom. There was a pretty intense conversation a few pages back. We agree on that too