Sorry Billy, football and the American are not why UConn bball struggled for years. I know many prefer this narrative...but it's nonsense. Kevin Ollie is why UConn bball struggled. Not sure why it's hard to see this and just root for UConn to have good sports in good situations across the board.
Having seton hall and providence fans at the xL (I guess i'll take your word those fans were bolstering bball attendance in the old BE) is not worth knee capping football. It's actually not worth much of anything.
And yes, there have been some bball only teams that have experienced some success in recent years, but this is a much harder path than the teams that have P3/4/5 football because...money.
Also I wouldn't buy stock in Villanova post Jay Wright, or ever want to be Loyola Chicago. We'll see how Gonzaga does in an NIL world where USC can offer Few seven million a year. We'll also see if Wright stays retired.
Every Big East Basketball Program to leave the Big East has entered an immediate period of decline. Every one of them. BC is dead. Pitt is Dead. Syracuse is holding on from its HOF coach and its ability to recruit nationally but its in decline. Lousiville went 13-19 last year.
The Big East became the preeminent conference in college basketball because its geographically overlaid with the biggest hot bed of basketball talent in the country; the i95 corridor from Boston to the DMV.
Recruits want to play against other top talent, to be on tv, to be prepared for the NBA and to have family be able to travel to see them play in person.
When you lose games against SHU, SJU, Nova and PC and start playing in Texas, you stop recruiting kids from New Jersey, NYC and Philly.
No more Ben Gordon. No More Taliek Brown. No More Kemba Walker. No More Shabazz Napier. No More Kevin Freeman.
Ollie is half the puzzle. There's no doubt. But to dismiss the impact of leaving the conference is to ignore heaps of evidence.