- Joined
- Feb 6, 2015
- Messages
- 148
- Reaction Score
- 851
Andre is a first round lock after 1 day in the combine. He’s not coming back.
Right but we’re not comparing him to your normal NBA prospect. Shooting expectations for a non-center can’t get much lower than they are with Andre and with those numbers and a slightly more repeatable looking jumper that may be all it takes for one front office to take a chance
46.5 would be historic lol. Think ur off there. The world record is 47.1That seems really low - I might be misremembering but I had seen his vertical mentioned in high school as 46.5
But if he came back & got in a gym with Ray or Rip, he could go back next year and shoot 23/25….25 shots in an empty gym doesn't replace 3 years of data on the court. The combine is more for fans than teams, honestly.
His shot doesn't look any more repeatable than it did a year ago. It's completely broken. He might've tightened up his footwork a bit, but that's probably just because he's in an empty gym. He shoots like a t-rex. It would be one thing if that god-awful form went in, but it hasn't consistently. Still a non-shooter and a total form rebuild right now.
Are those shots harder or easier than free throws? More difficult, right? 64% from the line would not be something to brag about but let’s say he could shoot 72-75% from the line. Would that be good enough? I think so.I mean, short answer is yes. I think he needed to shoot better than 64% on open 3's to change minds. It's a small sample so I don't think anything he (or anyone else for that matter) did would significantly change minds. Teams aren't going to suddenly guard him closely as a result of this.
Which isn't a knock on Andre. I still think he's worthy of an early 2nd round pick, and I still think he should stay in the draft. I'm just not sure the combine is a big factor for a guy like him. We know he can shoot in an empty gym, we know he's gonna test off the charts athletically, the question teams have can only be answered in games
this tweet has the measurements for all of the big east guys. sanogo coming in a bit short at 6'7" but with a 7'3" wingspan.
Are those shots harder or easier than free throws? More difficult, right? 64% from the line would not be something to brag about but let’s say he could shoot 72-75% from the line. Would that be good enough? I think so.
I know nothing about this stuff but these don’t strike me as elite NBA numbers. Top 4 in one one not top 10 in another. If u mulitply that by 10 years of draftees in the nba there are 39/99 more athletic guysTo clarify, Jackson had a 39.5" max vert and a 30.5" standing vert.
Can see both on boards here:
![]()
All a GM needs to see is some slight improvement or willingness to work and a shot that isn’t totally defunct. Shooting 60% on open looks in an empty gym is not impressive at all, as you’ve covered, but it may be enough to make a GM take a chance on someone if they’re on the fence. That’s all25 shots in an empty gym doesn't replace 3 years of data on the court. The combine is more for fans than teams, honestly.
His shot doesn't look any more repeatable than it did a year ago. It's completely broken. He might've tightened up his footwork a bit, but that's probably just because he's in an empty gym. He shoots like a t-rex. It would be one thing if that god-awful form went in, but it hasn't consistently. Still a non-shooter and a total form rebuild right now.
Agree 100.16/25 is not good in an empty gym by D1 standards, let alone NBA standards. It's actually pretty bad. I could shoot 60% from deep from 3 alone in the gym in college, and I was a horrible D2 player who never played more than 5 minutes a game.
Ok, understand. Yet no one in the 64% isn't good enough camp has given us a #. B/c it is much easier to just say not good enough than to say 2 more shots out of 25 would be good b/c that is patently ridiculous. Also he is obviously not alone (you are exaggerating to try to make your point) and there are eyeballs watching that happen to bring the pressure of millions of dollars at stake. THAT MATTERS!16/25 is not good in an empty gym by D1 standards, let alone NBA standards. It's actually pretty bad. I could shoot 60% from deep from 3 alone in the gym in college, and I was a horrible D2 player who never played more than 5 minutes a game.
Ok, understand. Yet no one in the 64% isn't good enough camp has given us a #. B/c it is much easier to just say not good enough than to say 2 more shots out of 25 would be good b/c that is patently ridiculous. Also he is obviously not alone (you are exaggerating to try to make your point) and there are eyeballs watching that happen to bring the pressure of millions of dollars at stake. THAT MATTERS!
The NBA 3 is deeper than the college, Andre struggled shooting the college 3, this is a positive sign. I agree not an order winner, but its an order qualifier which is really what we are talking about. I mean are UConn fans really arguing AJ doesn't have the potential to make an impact on the NBA level?!
Understand, I agree Andre is not a good jump shooter and I don't expect him to make a high % of NBA 3's in games - at least not right away (ie. summer league would be very surprising if he shot better than college % from NBA three).There is no number, because it's a 25 shot sample on broken form. Show me the number on 1000 shots and we can talk. Better yet, show me live drills at max speed after a workout.
I don't think anyone is hoping Andre can't compete in the league. I see people setting realistic expectations for his draftability and role.
Solidifying my Grant Williams comparison. Go Adama!Sanogo being 6’7 makes it even more hilarious that he put Kalkbrenner in a body bag
This is not broken. If I’m a shot coach I see a ton of potential here … you get him to work on not starting from below his waist and he’ll improve immediately. An NBA team watching his interviews and knowing his work ethic would be crazy to not want to take a flyer on this kid.
Give us an example of someone out of the 80 players at the combine who’s shot you don’t see potential inThis is not broken. If I’m a shot coach I see a ton of potential here … you get him to work on not starting from below his waist and he’ll improve immediately. An NBA team watching his interviews and knowing his work ethic would be crazy to not want to take a flyer on this kid.
I guess they all suck as AJ was also in the top 4 in the 3-point star drill (also 16/25) as well as tied for 4th in the spot up shooting drill (16/25 again). AJ has been better than average in many skills. The surprise was the low standing vertical. The NBA certainly doesn't spend time to hype the combine. Finding the data is a twitter maze. Seems like a lost opportunity.
I guess they all suck as AJ was also in the top 4 in the 3-point star drill (also 16/25) as well as tied for 4th in the spot up shooting drill (16/25 again). AJ has been better than average in many skills. The surprise was the low standing vertical. The NBA certainly doesn't spend time to hype the combine. Finding the data is a twitter maze. Seems like a lost opportunity.
Your second paragraph is the point. Any scout that has seen Andre play knows he’s not a shooter. A small sample size in an empty gym is prob not going to have much effect on that. Similarly, any scout that’s watched him play is not stressing what his combine vertical measurement is.LOL! Exactly...I wonder which "great shooters" underperformed...maybe it isn't actually "easy" to make 80% on 3's in an empty gym (with a bunch of scouts and NBA executives watching)
And any scout that has seen AJ in-game knows that his leaping ability and athleticism is in the top 99% so that's not some big draft decision dealbreaker...
They prob don’t promote it cause a lot of it is crap & a formality. Individual workouts, game tape & interviews are prob a ridiculously weighted portion of these guys draft-abilityI guess they all suck as AJ was also in the top 4 in the 3-point star drill (also 16/25) as well as tied for 4th in the spot up shooting drill (16/25 again). AJ has been better than average in many skills. The surprise was the low standing vertical. The NBA certainly doesn't spend time to hype the combine. Finding the data is a twitter maze. Seems like a lost opportunity.
Some are acting like he’s got an unfixable shot. There have been plenty of recent cases of players that just could not figure it out or have struggled to figure it out (Fultz, Simmons the most famous). All I’m saying is I think he’s starting from a place that’s a heck of a lot better than where the Ball brothers were and the kid is a workaholic.Give us an example of someone out of the 80 players at the combine who’s shot you don’t see potential in