Mr. French
Tremendous Individual
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2012
- Messages
- 3,574
- Reaction Score
- 13,958
Agree with all the back and forth points.
I think obviously some people feel that the individual greatness of a player like Donyell or Ray overcomes what Kemba/Bazz/whoever did.
I def respect that, and that's along the lines of "who's the best 5 players we've had, bottom line" maybe Bazz or Kemba don't get in, but imo their accomplishments are such that they HAVE to be in the top 5.
It's sort of how I am with Rip...love him, he's accomplished and individually great, so he's a no brainer top 5, but based on "greatness" or other criteria, he'd be the first Top 5 guy to be discussed about being replaced, because I don't think he was singularly as spectacular as Ray or others...but even that, my own opinion, gives me pause and internal debate.
I love this topic and the varying opinions that can be had. Carmelo basically pulled a Kemba, but do u think there's a Cuse fan alive that wouldn't have him top 2 in program history?
I think obviously some people feel that the individual greatness of a player like Donyell or Ray overcomes what Kemba/Bazz/whoever did.
I def respect that, and that's along the lines of "who's the best 5 players we've had, bottom line" maybe Bazz or Kemba don't get in, but imo their accomplishments are such that they HAVE to be in the top 5.
It's sort of how I am with Rip...love him, he's accomplished and individually great, so he's a no brainer top 5, but based on "greatness" or other criteria, he'd be the first Top 5 guy to be discussed about being replaced, because I don't think he was singularly as spectacular as Ray or others...but even that, my own opinion, gives me pause and internal debate.
I love this topic and the varying opinions that can be had. Carmelo basically pulled a Kemba, but do u think there's a Cuse fan alive that wouldn't have him top 2 in program history?
