The QB Issue | Page 9 | The Boneyard

The QB Issue

Who should start at QB going forward?

  • Evers

    Votes: 104 43.7%
  • Fagnano

    Votes: 78 32.8%
  • Mcdonald

    Votes: 3 1.3%
  • Welliver

    Votes: 53 22.3%

  • Total voters
    238
Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
27,476
Reaction Score
68,832
Evers looked very inaccurate even when he had time to throw. Fagnano did miss a couple of wide open guy but he showed more consistency than Evers. This has the feeling of whoever starts, the back up should get a series, and if he earns it two.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
20,927
Reaction Score
46,803
Evers looked very inaccurate even when he had time to throw. Fagnano did miss a couple of wide open guy but he showed more consistency than Evers. This has the feeling of whoever starts, the back up should get a series, and if he earns it two.
Everyone gave up on Fagnano after 6 quarters, but there were terrible drops in that NC State game last year and he did beat out Roberson. The crazy thing is starting a worse guy cause he was paid NIL to come here.
 

Exit 4

This space for rent
Joined
Feb 3, 2012
Messages
10,592
Reaction Score
39,539
I would give the Duke start to Fagnano. Lets see if he can build on his performance. Lets see if he can take another 1/2 step forward next week. Smooth things out a bit more.

I would tell Evers that he is still part of the plan, just want him to be fully healthy. And I would tell them both that Evers is probably going to get a start or two during our 6 game homestand provided he is practicing well. Evers has to practice well or no dice on possible starts. Fagnano would have to be playing three steps better before I consider never letting Evers see the field again.

Is this messy? I don't think so. Toughen up kids. Fagnano starts next week, Evers will get another go at some point in September.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
1,424
Reaction Score
5,710
Everyone gave up on Fagnano after 6 quarters despite his beating out Roberson (which everyone attributed to his being from the OC's old school). Now everyone wants to give up on Evers after 2.5 quarters despite his beating out Fagnano (which people are now attributing to being NIL). I don't care who starts, so long as they're the person whom the coaches/team believe gives themselves the best chance to win.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
20,927
Reaction Score
46,803
Everyone gave up on Fagnano after 6 quarters despite his beating out Roberson (which everyone attributed to his being from the OC's old school). Now everyone wants to give up on Evers after 2.5 quarters despite his beating out Fagnano (which people are now attributing to being NIL). I don't care who starts, so long as they're the person whom the coaches/team believe gives themselves the best chance to win.
Only difference is we got a full season out of Roberson and could tell he wasn't the answer.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
27,158
Reaction Score
35,831
Everyone gave up on Fagnano after 6 quarters despite his beating out Roberson (which everyone attributed to his being from the OC's old school). Now everyone wants to give up on Evers after 2.5 quarters despite his beating out Fagnano (which people are now attributing to being NIL). I don't care who starts, so long as they're the person whom the coaches/team believe gives themselves the best chance to win.

Probably because they compared Evers to Mike Vick and destroyed every ounce of credibility with respect to the process. Mora also basically said that we would start him because we signed him from the portal and paid him.

Ringing endorsement.
 
Joined
Jan 16, 2014
Messages
836
Reaction Score
2,386
Only difference is we got a full season out of Roberson and could tell he wasn't the answer.
Hopefully we don't have to see it, but I have seen people saying stuff about us losing him to K State and if we do have problems at QB, he will be made out to be the Patick Mahomes by some here.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
20,927
Reaction Score
46,803
Probably because they compared Evers to Mike Vick and destroyed every ounce of credibility with respect to the process. Mora also basically said that we would start him because we signed him from the portal and paid him.

Ringing endorsement.
Yeah we are not assuming he got the nod cause of NIL. We were basically told you don't bring a guy in like that to not start. Evers could be great, but not giving Fagnano a start this week would only reinforce the NIL argument into the equation.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
27,158
Reaction Score
35,831
Yeah we are not assuming he got the nod cause of NIL. We were basically told you don't bring a guy in like that to not start. Evers could be great, but not giving Fagnano a start this week would only reinforce the NIL argument into the equation.

He has to play Fagnano. If not. Guillotine.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
27,158
Reaction Score
35,831
I’m actually shocked that people are reversing course on their thoughts of Joe. If mora had named Joe the starter to start the yr the yard would have burned to the ground. Good showing by Joe today

Probably not. This is revisionist history.

People were more upset merely because we were starting a guy based on high school film and writing him a check,l.
 
Joined
Oct 12, 2013
Messages
424
Reaction Score
2,419
If Evers is healthy, I’d like to see him start. Joe has the perfect temperament (just based on what the coaches say) to come off the bench if needed.
As impressive as his numbers were, most of his stats were YAC. And, he missed some wide open guys downfield. He under threw the guy who made the one handed grab for a TD. So, happy for him and he played well, but not convinced he’s the number one.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
27,158
Reaction Score
35,831
Everyone gave up on Fagnano after 6 quarters despite his beating out Roberson (which everyone attributed to his being from the OC's old school). Now everyone wants to give up on Evers after 2.5 quarters despite his beating out Fagnano (which people are now attributing to being NIL). I don't care who starts, so long as they're the person whom the coaches/team believe gives themselves the best chance to win.

I think Fagnano got hurt during the NC State game. Maybe early on.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
27,158
Reaction Score
35,831
If Evers is healthy, I’d like to see him start. Joe has the perfect temperament (just based on what the coaches say) to come off the bench if needed.
As impressive as his numbers were, most of his stats were YAC. And, he missed some wide open guys downfield. He under threw the guy who made the one handed grab for a TD. So, happy for him and he played well, but not convinced he’s the number one.

Delete your account,
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
8,403
Reaction Score
16,299
Fagnano has to start and it's not a close call. It gives Evers another week to recover from a big hit and another week to adjust to the system. I wouldn't even script any special plays for him. He sits unless Joe can't go and if Joe struggles Nick is back for the next game. And if Fagnano keeps winning he keeps playing. Nick will get another shot but my gut says don't argue with winning.
 
Joined
Sep 30, 2011
Messages
1,554
Reaction Score
3,654
Everyone gave up on Fagnano after 6 quarters, but there were terrible drops in that NC State game last year and he did beat out Roberson. The crazy thing is starting a worse guy cause he was paid NIL to come here.
Tucker beat out Roberson in the spring. Not exactly hard to do lol.
 
Joined
Sep 24, 2011
Messages
206
Reaction Score
1,111
Not a Joe F fan. Was not happy about the possibility of him starting. Especially not with talent brought in (Evers) and the two freshman in McDonald and Welliver.

But he’s proven capable, had a great game yesterday. I think you continue Fagnano, and make sure Evers gets his reps in practice and maybe a possession or two in the game (pending right scenario).

if Joe struggles or is hurt, which let’s face it, as UConn QB’s go is highly likely, then Evers gets his chance.
Joe has looked the best in the spring game, the scrimmage, the Maryland game and was near perfect yesterday. You go with the hot hand and based on overall performance since the spring, he gives us the best chance to win against Duke, no question.
 
Joined
Sep 24, 2011
Messages
206
Reaction Score
1,111
We won't win the Duke game, the Wake game or Syracuse so it almost doesn't matter who we start.
Please expand on that comment after seeing how after yesterday, we can see the upgrade in talent on this team and what they are capable of and why would you not think they can’t build off this momentum and compete, if not win those 3 games?

And by the way, Air Force is ranked 70 and struggled with Merrimack….and ranked similarly to the 3 teams you mentioned.

I’m listening
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
22,549
Reaction Score
7,422
You start Joe after yesterday. The kid performed big time, so he earned the start.

Evers will get his chance if Joe is unable to perform.
This. It amazes me we’re having this conversation. If you want to debate who will be starting in 3 weeks go for it, but barring injury there is not going to be a question about who starts next week.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
110
Guests online
1,134
Total visitors
1,244

Forum statistics

Threads
158,759
Messages
4,167,415
Members
10,039
Latest member
NAN24


.
Top Bottom