The Official 2025 New York Mets thread | Page 7 | The Boneyard

The Official 2025 New York Mets thread

I can see 2 of 3 in Chicago...then 1-2 against the Marlins to close it out. That feels on brand for this team.

It's maddening because when things are clicking this team has a ceiling as high as pretty much anyone out there. But good gracious the floor is deep down in the basement for this team too.

Inconsistency has plagued this team in all aspects. Hitting - we get super hot and lead all of baseball for 2 or 3 weeks, then have a 2 or 3 week stretch where we are the worst hitting team in the sport. No middle ground. Alonso is white hot, then he looks lost. Alvarez spends half the season flailing away at everything, then turns it on. Lindor is burning hot, ice cold, then hot again. Nimmo is solid then goes on about the worst streak of his career. Vientos is horrible, then flashes dominance, now fades away again.

Then pitching is the same, best ERA in the majors after maybe a month or so in, Senga tops in baseball...no he's in the minors. Peterson is an All Star first half, 5+ ERA second half. Manaea dominates for 2 innings, get shelled in the 3rd. Defense can be sparkling, we've seen Pete make some great plays at 1st, Lindor flash gold glove ability, Taylor or Cedric make stellar plays...then Siri and Cedric take horrible angles to balls, drop balls, Lindor has catchable balls glance off his glove, Pete throws the ball away on routine tosses...just wildly inconsistent.

I'd be stunned if Mendoza is back next year if we miss the playoffs. Someone has to take the fall and a month or 2 ago I wasn't really questioning him at all, today I can't say that anymore. Some of his decisions with the staff and bullpen management leave me wondering what we are doing.
 
I also think the fact that Helsley, Rogers and Mullins have all stunk hasn't helped. In fact, that may have been the tipping point that drove this team fully into the ditch. Helsley especially. He has 16 ER allowed in 17 IP....and that doesn't count any inherited runners that have scored. He was supposed to form the best 1-2 punch in baseball with Diaz.
 
I also think the fact that Helsley, Rogers and Mullins have all stunk hasn't helped. In fact, that may have been the tipping point that drove this team fully into the ditch. Helsley especially. He has 16 ER allowed in 17 IP....and that doesn't count any inherited runners that have scored. He was supposed to form the best 1-2 punch in baseball with Diaz.
Helsley and Mullins definitely, but are we really saying Tyler Rogers has sucked? He has a 2.25 ERA in 24 innings since the trade
 
Weather report for Chicago this weekend is not looking good. They cpuld have the same mess they did last year. No ones fault but their own 😢
 
Weather report for Chicago this weekend is not looking good. They cpuld have the same mess they did last year. No ones fault but their own 😢
Week, not weekend. I hate autocorrect and the 5 minute limit to edit
 
Helsley and Mullins definitely, but are we really saying Tyler Rogers has sucked? He has a 2.25 ERA in 24 innings since the trade
Eh, I'm lumping him in. He isn't a strikeout guy. He comes in and gets outs most of the time but he's not overpowering and isn't any better than Garrett or Stanek in my head. Not worth trading Drew Gilbert, Tidwell and Butto, is he?
 
Peterson turned in a tom glavine like showing.

Lindor leads off with a dinger and the vibes are good and then Peterson is averse to throwing a strike. And why didn’t Alvarez throw on the stolen base by the catcher????
 
Eh, I'm lumping him in. He isn't a strikeout guy. He comes in and gets outs most of the time but he's not overpowering and isn't any better than Garrett or Stanek in my head. Not worth trading Drew Gilbert, Tidwell and Butto, is he?
I think all 3 of those guys are replacement level players who were off the 40 man roster this winter anyway, so I still make that trade every time
 
This team is going to kill me. For real.

One thing rarely talked about in this entire thread is how good Diaz has been all season long. He was filthy last night in the biggest save situation of the season so far. He's pitched 3 of the last 4 though and we aren't going to have him tonight.
 
I can see 2 of 3 in Chicago...then 1-2 against the Marlins to close it out. That feels on brand for this team.

It's maddening because when things are clicking this team has a ceiling as high as pretty much anyone out there. But good gracious the floor is deep down in the basement for this team too.

Inconsistency has plagued this team in all aspects. Hitting - we get super hot and lead all of baseball for 2 or 3 weeks, then have a 2 or 3 week stretch where we are the worst hitting team in the sport. No middle ground. Alonso is white hot, then he looks lost. Alvarez spends half the season flailing away at everything, then turns it on. Lindor is burning hot, ice cold, then hot again. Nimmo is solid then goes on about the worst streak of his career. Vientos is horrible, then flashes dominance, now fades away again.

Then pitching is the same, best ERA in the majors after maybe a month or so in, Senga tops in baseball...no he's in the minors. Peterson is an All Star first half, 5+ ERA second half. Manaea dominates for 2 innings, get shelled in the 3rd. Defense can be sparkling, we've seen Pete make some great plays at 1st, Lindor flash gold glove ability, Taylor or Cedric make stellar plays...then Siri and Cedric take horrible angles to balls, drop balls, Lindor has catchable balls glance off his glove, Pete throws the ball away on routine tosses...just wildly inconsistent.

I'd be stunned if Mendoza is back next year if we miss the playoffs. Someone has to take the fall and a month or 2 ago I wasn't really questioning him at all, today I can't say that anymore. Some of his decisions with the staff and bullpen management leave me wondering what we are doing.
Theres like a 2 game stretch every week in a half where they look like they are the most unbeatable team in the MLB, then the next 8 games they look like they can't even beat the rockies.
 

Online statistics

Members online
281
Guests online
2,946
Total visitors
3,227

Forum statistics

Threads
164,377
Messages
4,393,740
Members
10,207
Latest member
ImJustACoug


.
..
Top Bottom