I mean, if "dat place smells LOL" appeals to your sense of humor over and over, knock yourself out.
Just having lived in both places, grew up in NJ to be fair, it's just always irked me.
ConnHusk, you're fighting a losing battle. I assume most people know that they are stereotyping, but don't care. As a NJ resident for my whole life except for 4 years in Connecticut, and 2 childhood years each in the Chicago suburbs and Brooklyn, I've given up defending NJ. I also make fun of other states, but inside I realize that every state has great and horrible places. Interesting choice to show Branch Brook. I spent plenty of time in Branch Brook Park, and while the Cherry Blossoms are lovely, it wouldn't sway me to live in Newark.
That being said, South Orange is a very nice town (that's why they wanted to change their name to South Mountain Village), regardless of being so close to East Orange/Irvington/Newark, which are pretty tough places. But forgetting about whether NJ or South Orange in particular are nice, I don't know why a kid would ever choose Seton Hall over a myriad of other choices. It's typically where NJ Catholic school kids go when their parents won't let them go away and/or they didn't get into ND, G'Town, BC, Holy Cross, Villanova, Providence, maybe even Fordham, etc. And the public school kids go there if they want to stay in state but didn't get into any of the decent state school options. I'm obviously stereotyping (and their law school is now solid, which pains me to say), but it's just not the kind of college experience that I'd want as a big time college athlete. Even in the AAC we shouldn't lose out to Seton Hall unless a kid is from NJ and wants his friends and family at every game.