- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 6,050
- Reaction Score
- 19,069
TasteofUConn said:To me, last night's result was a combination of 3 things: 1. Cavs are gassed. Too many minutes for the key guys. Dellavedova was in hospital 40 hours prior to game time. Never a promising sign. For the first game, they looked like the less energetic team. 2 overtime games, a hard fought game 3, and an extremely short bench will do that to you. Somebody needs to figure out where LBJ's minutes, per game per day, rank all time over the first 4 games of a finals. One data point. In 85, Magic played 34, 41, 39, 43 over the 1st 4 games, and each of those games was played on 3 days rest. LBJ has played 46, 51, 46, 41 and those games were played on 3 days rest, 2, and 2. Magic's minutes per day averages to 15.7 minutes per day. LBJ's is 23 minutes per day, or a rate of about 50% greater than what Magic played. Unlike games 1-3, last night LBJ was taking plays off. I can't imagine the level of exhaustion he must feel, but it must be intense..
You are clearly passionate and you make some good observations in your arguments - the first two minutes of the 4Q were indeed a disaster, and LBJ could have easily had 12 or more assists with better shooting from his teammates yesterday (and maybe if they knocked those down and kept it closer, he wouldn't have taken plays off). He can clearly be forgiven for wearing down one night in the middle of a long series when he's lifted a team full of ragamuffins to the brink of a title, and if the Cavs win this thing - or even if it goes 7, G4 will be completely forgotten by everyone (except maybe by Iguadola's family). But you're an intelligent guy, so I have to wonder...
Why Magic in 1985? Seems odd to pick that one out at random, especially when you'd want to compare LBJ to Jordan for the GOAT debate (or Iverson in the sense of being a one-man wrecking crew). Magic is also better known for 1987 and the junior sky hook in G4, so that's the series I'd look at first. Well, 1985 of course is known for the Boston Massacre in G1 and how the Lakers overcame that to win the series. So everyone's minutes were reduced due to the historically large blowout (the Lakers also won G3 by 25). It should be obvious that something is unusual looking at his minute totals (only 34 minutes - injured? Foul trouble? Blowout?). The NBA has also been using a Tuesday-Thursday-Sunday format since at least 1988 (to avoid the ratings pitfalls on Friday and Saturday nights), so this "per day" stuff wouldn't effect any series since then, but it does for Magic in 1985. It feels like a data point you crafted specifically to compare to Magic in 1985 to make LBJ look like he's some sort of superhero.
To get more meaningful data points, I recalled four series that had an overtime game in the first four games and dominant players in their prime, and found seven guys who have played more than LBJ's 184 minutes (46 mpg) in the first four games of a series. Jordan, Barkley and Dan Majerle in 1993 (with a 2OT G3), Iverson and Kobe jn 2001 (OT G1), Kobe again in 2004 (OT G2) and Robert Horry in 1994 (who got to stand around on offense a lot and probably shouldn't count). Barkley was the most with 194 (46-46-56-46), Iverson had 192 (52-47-47-46), etc, This is what superstars do in the finals. They get little rest and have to play through fatigue. It's part of the job description.
I kind of wonder how you might have acted to the flu game if you were a Jordan fanatic.