I don't see how 'm being "unfair" to her. I did not criticize her. I merely pointed out that it's somewhat unusual for a prospect of her caliber (HG #6) to limit her final group to a pretty small geographic area. What's "unfair" about that?
Related. If she stays at home at Cincy, it MAY be an indicator of the school's increased prestige in joining a P-4 conference.
If she commits today, I would not expect her choice to be Illinois, but then I am often wrong in guessing what a 17-year-old will choose. If you are a tOSU (CBus??) or Cincy fan, good luck. I like what I have seen of her.