- Joined
- Jan 5, 2016
- Messages
- 5,305
- Reaction Score
- 28,416
wise, as always, UcMiami. The fact, FanHame, is that all statistics about assault are a guess, and I agree with UcMiami that we shouldn't inculpate Baylor as having a higher rape culture just because of discovery.I am not defending either Baylor or Kim her, but people need to realize that the sexual assault numbers at Baylor are not out of line with numbers reported by conscientious colleges and universities around the country. There is a real problem on college campuses everywhere. That does not let Baylor off the hook for the absolutely outrageous way they handled their cases, nor Kim for failing to recognize that the situation at Baylor is way out of line with issues at other institutions, and that the national spotlight is well deserved and that she should be having to field those questions on the recruiting trail. And if she is punching any off her recruits parents ... well, I suspect she isn't taking her own advice! And neither should her audience.
The issue in discovery about rape culture (and we need to appreciate that there is one sexual assault of men for every 3 of women, so that needs to be acknowledged as well) is heavily conditioned by reporting: both reporting by the victim to the university and then the university's assessment of that reported incident and its own report in turn. So, absolutely, we can't say for certain that anyone's number of actual assaults are higher than other schools.
The link below was much discussed on the BY earlier, because UConn (along with Brown) led the nation in reporting assaults. But even here, interpreting what the data means--assuming it accurately reflects something--is messy. Some universities have much larger graduate student populations and I wonder whether sexual assault is as prevalent within that population. If not, it skews the statistics about percentage of assaults and therefore of reported assaults.
And of course, some college cultures are more activist than others, and those student populations are more emboldened to report their assaults.
These colleges have the most reports of rape
Whatever one says about the incident of sexual assaults, however, Kim's remarks were a terrible setback to the cause of reporting and therefore of prevention. She absolutely needs to apologize and reframe what she means, because she defended the indefensible.
Last edited: