Key tweets, and it's all gone to Hell.

[TGW93]

This is probably my dream scenario, we don’t have to leave the big east which we all love as a basketball conference, and we gain a decent and consistent football schedule. We also could possibly have yearly matchups with duke on the hardwood which would be good for visibility and recruiting. I don’t know how realistic something like this would ever be.

It's a plausible outcome - especially since it lets ND remain independent in FB (which I think remains their sole objective).

Eighteen basketball schools under the Big East brand - a powerhouse league and tourney at MSG.

The football-playing schools could have a football-specific conference called the Atlantic Coast Conference - all football money from that conference is segregated from the Big East. Add a few other schools to the football conference - Army, Navy, Temple, USF, James Madison, ECU (e.g., schools "in-footprint") - and as long as it has access to a playoff spot (even if the access is shared with ND) it could thrive.

 

[UConnJim]

Conference championships have absolutely nothing to do with the selection of schools to join the P5 conferences. What championship did Rutgers win to get it into the Big Ten? UConn won the big east conference, twice, and yet we were left on the island of misfit toys, known as the American Athletic Conference.

Getting a call up from the G5 to P5 has been almost solely based on football performance. Six G5 schools have gotten the call up to the P5: TCU, Utah, Cincy, Houston, UCF, and BYU. All of the schools were doing very well in football before they were called up. Here were their records in the 4 years before they moved conferences and number of Top 25 final poll rankings:

TCU: 47-5 (4 Top 25 finishes)
Utah: 42-10. (3)
Cincy: 42-9 (3)
UCF: 37-12. (2) 5 years ago they were 13-0.
Houston: 27-20 (1)
BYU: 35-16. (2)

The Big East was a BCS conference, not a G5 conference. Rutgers was mediocre in football, but they showed their commitment to football by expanding their stadium before they got the Big 10 invite, they were an AAU university, and they brought NYC and NJ cable boxes.

 

[CL82]

Rutgers was mediocre in football, but they showed their commitment to football by expanding their stadium before they got the Big 10 invite, they were an AAU university, and they brought NYC and NJ cable boxes.

You kind of make my point for me here. Rutgers didn’t have on the field success, but “showed commitment” and was located in the right spot. He seem to be looking at the last round of expansion and defining, all conference realignment by it. Practically speaking, football success hasn’t been the engine that drives it cable boxes has been. In the future, that will change from cable boxes, to “potential online subscribers”. Conference realignment isn’t about making conference is better, it’s about making conference’s richer.

 

[TheCatsLair]

You kind of make my point for me here. Rutgers didn’t have on the field success, but “showed commitment” and was located in the right spot. He seem to be looking at the last round of expansion and defining, all conference realignment by it. Practically speaking, football success hasn’t been the engine that drives it cable boxes has been. In the future, that will change from cable boxes, to “potential online subscribers”. Conference realignment isn’t about making conference is better, it’s about making conference’s richer.

But there are different levels. On-field success is important for non-power conferences schools but schools jumping from one power conference to another are already in the club and far more often than not are given the benefit of the doubt based on "potential" something non-BCS/G5 rarely given.

 

[Ldandy]

It's a plausible outcome - especially since it lets ND remain independent in FB (which I think remains their sole objective).

Eighteen basketball schools under the Big East brand - a powerhouse league and tourney at MSG.

The football-playing schools could have a football-specific conference called the Atlantic Coast Conference - all football money from that conference is segregated from the Big East. Add a few other schools to the football conference - Army, Navy, Temple, USF, James Madison, ECU (e.g., schools "in-footprint") - and as long as it has access to a playoff spot (even if the access is shared with ND) it could thrive.

Let me get this straight. You're good with the idea of a hybrid sports conference comprised of basketball only Catholic Schools and FBS Level Football Schools? A conference that would allow ND to fully benefit while giving next to nothing of value back? Where have I seen this before? UConn Fans don't walk, run from this. Tell your AD and president to call Yormak everyday until he either says yes or puts a restraining order on your entire leadership.

 

[CL82]

But there are different levels. On-field success is important for non-power conferences schools but schools jumping from one power conference to another are already in the club and far more often than not are given the benefit of the doubt based on "potential" something non-BCS/G5 rarely given.

I’m not convinced that it matters much. You have to be in the club, have to play D1 football, but the value of on the field success is probably limited to brand recognition.

 

[hoopsfan22]

I’m not convinced that it matters much. You have to be in the club, have to play D1 football, but the value of on the field success is probably limited to brand recognition.

That's been my argument. The B1G has been a loser conference for almost my entire (relatively short) life and still rakes in the big bucks. I think the last time I saw a team win anything on national TV was Ohio State's championship a decade ago, and before that who knows. They didn't bring on Rutgers and Maryland because of their storied football success or to provide cannon fodder for Penn State on the eastern flank of the conference. They were brought in for a share of the 30 million potential viewers in the I-95 corridor from NYC metro on down to the DC metro. The most recent additions from California bring an 18 million person metro area. The B1G is going after the population centers because that equals viewers which equals dollars. Big schools with big brands and big alumni bases and big population centers - that's the current strategy in a nutshell.

 

[Jbirdp5]

Let me get this straight. You're good with the idea of a hybrid sports conference comprised of basketball only Catholic Schools and FBS Level Football Schools? A conference that would allow ND to fully benefit while giving next to nothing of value back? Where have I seen this before? UConn Fans don't walk, run from this. Tell your AD and president to call Yormak everyday until he either says yes or puts a restraining order on your entire leadership.

Geographical outliers rarely do well in their conferences. The big 12 sounds good til our players are flying all over the south weekly.

 

[billybud]

Every year. the B1G has some of the most watched games on TV....that is the value...

 

[businesslawyer]

Let me get this straight. You're good with the idea of a hybrid sports conference comprised of basketball only Catholic Schools and FBS Level Football Schools? A conference that would allow ND to fully benefit while giving next to nothing of value back? Where have I seen this before? UConn Fans don't walk, run from this. Tell your AD and president to call Yormak everyday until he either says yes or puts a restraining order on your entire leadership.

Your point makes sense from a PSU perspective, not a UConn perspective. Would I prefer a P5 conference with no hoops onlies? Of course I would. Would a take a hybrid ACC/Big East over where we are now with football without a conference and hoops dependent on the Big East not being cut out when one day big time football leaves the NCAA? Also of course I would.

 

[billybud]

Geographical outliers rarely do well in their conferences. The big 12 sounds good til our players are flying all over the south weekly.

Well, come on down...to Tallahassee, Clemson, GT, UNC, NC State, Wake, Miami etc...

But you are right about ACC outliers...Cuse and BC .

 

[CL82]

Your point makes sense from a PSU perspective, not a UConn perspective. Would I prefer a P5 conference with no hoops onlies? Of course I would. Would a take a hybrid ACC/Big East over where we are now with football without a conference and hoops dependent on the Big East not being cut out when one day big time football leaves the NCAA? Also of course I would.

I agree, in theory. In practice, the interests of the basketball only’s and the football playing schools, maybe to divergent for any union of them to have stability.

 

[businesslawyer]

I agree, in theory. In practice, the interests of the basketball only’s and the football playing schools, maybe to divergent for any union of them to have stability.

I agree with that. But if the union comes apart, at least we’re now associated with other P5 football schools.

 

[Ldandy]

I agree, in theory. In practice, the interests of the basketball only’s and the football playing schools, maybe to divergent for any union of them to have stability.

This.

The fundamental issue that hastened the demise of the original Big East would exist in this league, but potentially be even greater due to the economic pressures of the current media landscape. The needs of a school attempting to operate a successful FBS Football Program are far different than those seeking to operate an FCS Program or none at all.

For any conference to work long term the programs in it need to view it as mutually beneficial as well as feeling collectively stronger together than apart. Is Marquette going to care if UConn Football is struggling to retain coaches, recruit decent players, or put fans in the stands? As long as it doesn't tank the basketball team they could not care less if UConn can't keep the lights on in the stadium.

 

[Husky25]

If Big time "college" football breaks from the NCAA, is it really college football anymore? Will players be beholden to APR requirements? If not, will it be worth it for these institutions to sponsor such non-curricular activities? Will it force the NFL to follow the NBA and provide a G League of sorts? If so, who gets the media money? 'Cause the networks have already demonstrated that there is not enough to go around.

If Herbst was correct about anything, it was that athletics are the front porch of an institution. State schools in SEC country need athletics to drive enrollment and maintain the façade of a worthwhile education, but without football and all else being equal, what is the appeal of the University of Alabama for a Texas kid that has how many other local options that are better or offer more prestige?

 

[billybud]

If athletes become employees...they should also be students...if not, what you end up with are university sponsored and branded teams.

I read somewhere that the majority of "fans" of most major college teams never attended school there. They pick a team for their allegance.

 

[Kolumbo]

This.

The fundamental issue that hastened the demise of the original Big East would exist in this league, but potentially be even greater due to the economic pressures of the current media landscape. The needs of a school attempting to operate a successful FBS Football Program are far different than those seeking to operate an FCS Program or none at all.

For any conference to work long term the programs in it need to view it as mutually beneficial as well as feeling collectively stronger together than apart. Is Marquette going to care if UConn Football is struggling to retain coaches, recruit decent players, or put fans in the stands? As long as it doesn't tank the basketball team they could not care less if UConn can't keep the lights on in the stadium.

I don't think their interests would be so different. Play in a great conference and make money. The Catholic 7 left because the Big East was becoming a weaker basketball conference given the new additions. A merger of sorts with Duke, Wake et al is an entirely different kind of conference, altogether.

 

[CL82]

I don't think their interests would be so different. Play in a great conference and make money. The Catholic 7 left because the Big East was becoming a weaker basketball conference given the new additions. A merger of sorts with Duke, Wake et al is an entirely different kind of conference, altogether.

The Catholic 7 left because they were tired of making pennies on the dollar compared to their full sport compatriots. They also realize that once the new admissions came in, football schools would have a majority, and they felt like they couldn’t control their own destiny anymore. I based that on conversations I’ve had with people who are “quasi-insiders” at other schools.

 

[Kolumbo]

The Catholic 7 left because they were tired of making pennies on the dollar compared to their full sport compatriots. They also realize that once the new admissions came in, football schools would have a majority, and they felt like they couldn’t control their own destiny anymore. I based that on conversations I’ve had with people who are “quasi-insiders” at other schools.

They will always make less than football schools but would probably make more if they add the ACC schools.

 

[CL82]

They will always make less than football schools but would probably make more if they add the ACC schools.

I don’t disagree, but they have an institutional bias about football schools. That was one of the big hesitancies with allowing Connecticut to join the conference.

 

[Drew]

If athletes become employees...they should also be students...if not, what you end up with are university sponsored and branded teams.

I read somewhere that the majority of "fans" of most major college teams never attended school there. They pick a team for their allegance.

This wouldn’t surprise me at all. I picked Nebraska growing up to be a fan of as my mom played volleyball there. Didn’t wind up going there but still am a die hard fan and go to a game every year

 

[Ldandy]

I don't think their interests would be so different. Play in a great conference and make money. The Catholic 7 left because the Big East was becoming a weaker basketball conference given the new additions. A merger of sorts with Duke, Wake et al is an entirely different kind of conference, altogether.

I could be misremembering, but I thought that one of the key issues was the football schools pushing for the addition of members like TCU and Boise State after The ESPN led raids. Under the before mentioned proposal, the division among schools would remain. On one side you have schools that need to protect their FBS Football Programs. On the other side you have schools that don't have this concern and don't want to be dictated to by the programs that do.

I'll put this out there one more time and then I'll drop it. I understand that there are those here who love the current Big East and hate the idea of UConn playing in a "distant conference." You've had success so why change? You change because history has a nasty way of repeating itself. A hybrid conference with ND as the perpetual leech will suffer the same fate as BE1. It might not happen the same way, but it will eventually happen.

Be active with your administration. Remind them consistently that UConn is too prominent of a university and an athletic department to be relegated to second tier status. Let them know that you know football independence for any school not named ND is a death sentence long term. Tell your leaders that they need to position the school for P5 Expansion without exception. UConn cannot maintain long term athletic excellence on G5 Money. Yormark is on record stating that he wants to play Big 12 Games in the NY Metro Area. Buy him a ****g map with Storrs circled in red marker on it.

 

[Kolumbo]

I could be misremembering, but I thought that one of the key issues was the football schools pushing for the addition of members like TCU and Boise State after The ESPN led raids. Under the before mentioned proposal, the division among schools would remain. On one side you have schools that need to protect their FBS Football Programs. On the other side you have schools that don't have this concern and don't want to be dictated to by the programs that do.

I'll put this out there one more time and then I'll drop it. I understand that there are those here who love the current Big East and hate the idea of UConn playing in a "distant conference." You've had success so why change? You change because history has a nasty way of repeating itself. A hybrid conference with ND as the perpetual leech will suffer the same fate as BE1. It might not happen the same way, but it will eventually happen.

Be active with your administration. Remind them consistently that UConn is too prominent of a university and an athletic department to be relegated to second tier status. Let them know that you know football independence for any school not named ND is a death sentence long term. Tell your leaders that they need to position the school for P5 Expansion without exception. UConn cannot maintain long term athletic excellence on G5 Money. Yormark is on record stating that he wants to play Big 12 Games in the NY Metro Area. Buy him a ****g map with Storrs circled in red marker on it.

You can put it out there 100 more times and we get it. The administration gets it. But the bottom line is there are at least a dozen other programs ahead of UConn in line for the Big 12, from the PAC, AAC, MW, heck even the Sun Belt. We can't force them to like our football program. The Big 12 should invite UConn & Temple. Or Memphis & Tulane, or USF & ECU. So many options. If not the Big 12, then nothing but independence at this point. There are no rumors whatsoever involving UConn. I hope it changes, but hope is a dangerous thing.

 

[Sole]

I could be misremembering, but I thought that one of the key issues was the football schools pushing for the addition of members like TCU and Boise State after The ESPN led raids. Under the before mentioned proposal, the division among schools would remain. On one side you have schools that need to protect their FBS Football Programs. On the other side you have schools that don't have this concern and don't want to be dictated to by the programs that do.

I'll put this out there one more time and then I'll drop it. I understand that there are those here who love the current Big East and hate the idea of UConn playing in a "distant conference." You've had success so why change? You change because history has a nasty way of repeating itself. A hybrid conference with ND as the perpetual leech will suffer the same fate as BE1. It might not happen the same way, but it will eventually happen.

Be active with your administration. Remind them consistently that UConn is too prominent of a university and an athletic department to be relegated to second tier status. Let them know that you know football independence for any school not named ND is a death sentence long term. Tell your leaders that they need to position the school for P5 Expansion without exception. UConn cannot maintain long term athletic excellence on G5 Money. Yormark is on record stating that he wants to play Big 12 Games in the NY Metro Area. Buy him a ****g map with Storrs circled in red marker on it.

Its not g5 money…the next big east tv contract will be alot more any g5 conference ..and I’ve been hearing uconn can’t survive unless we join a p5 league for 12 years…when is going to happen 5 more years?…10 more years?

 

[CL82]

I could be misremembering, but I thought that one of the key issues was the football schools pushing for the addition of members like TCU and Boise State after The ESPN led raids. Under the before mentioned proposal, the division among schools would remain. On one side you have schools that need to protect their FBS Football Programs. On the other side you have schools that don't have this concern and don't want to be dictated to by the programs that do.

I'll put this out there one more time and then I'll drop it. I understand that there are those here who love the current Big East and hate the idea of UConn playing in a "distant conference." You've had success so why change? You change because history has a nasty way of repeating itself. A hybrid conference with ND as the perpetual leech will suffer the same fate as BE1. It might not happen the same way, but it will eventually happen.

Be active with your administration. Remind them consistently that UConn is too prominent of a university and an athletic department to be relegated to second tier status. Let them know that you know football independence for any school not named ND is a death sentence long term. Tell your leaders that they need to position the school for P5 Expansion without exception. UConn cannot maintain long term athletic excellence on G5 Money. Yormark is on record stating that he wants to play Big 12 Games in the NY Metro Area. Buy him a ****g map with Storrs circled in red marker on it.

Is Storrs in the New York metro area?

 

[CL82]

You can put it out there 100 more times and we get it. The administration gets it. But the bottom line is there are at least a dozen other programs ahead of UConn in line for the Big 12, from the PAC, AAC, MW, heck even the Sun Belt. We can't force them to like our football program. The Big 12 should invite UConn & Temple. Or Memphis & Tulane, or USF & ECU. So many options. If not the Big 12, then nothing but independence at this point. There are no rumors whatsoever involving UConn. I hope it changes, but hope is a dangerous thing.

Oh there have been rumors involving UConn. In any event, a lot of times there has been very little discussion of conference realignment moves until they actually happen. Currently, I think we are a longshot to get a P5 invite, but but that doesn't mean it won't happen.

 

[Ldandy]

Its not g5 money…the next big east tv contract will be alot more any g5 conference ..and I’ve been hearing uconn can’t survive unless we join a p5 league for 12 years…when is going to happen 5 more years?…10 more years?

What do you honestly think that deal will bring? 8-10 tops. You may be happy to be in The Big East instead of The AAC, but the the ink on your AD’s books is blood red.

Winning is an intoxicating elixir but it’s not a cure. Independent football is not sustainable. Even the most ardent Big East or bust fans have to realize that.

 

[Sole]

I think leaving the big east will hurt our basketball..right now we are the brand in the the north east..in a northeastern conference… we leave to a southern conference and we will be a Northeast team in a southern conference…recruit’s wanting to play in a southern conference will want to go to a southern school

 

[Ldandy]

Is Storrs in the New York metro area?

Relative to the rest of the Big 12 they are. Their Commissioner speaks openly about wanting access to the area. UConn is one of the only attainable programs that could give them a beach head in the Northeast. I hope that your entire administration is selling their off to anyone who will listen. The school is too valuable of a product to be left out forever.

 

[jostar1]