East Catholic McGuirl

[polycom]

There would have been 50 posts on this board about how KO was incompetent to recruit such a low ranked player. And now he's incompetent because he didn't.
Spectacular.

This is true because he has proven himself many times over to not have an eye for talent so why would we trust him at the time? This thread is more about the frustrations of that proving itself again.

 

[businesslawyer]

KO probably saw him play and thought, hey, he’s not that good.

Because he’s not.

He’s had one good game for K State.

Surely Fishy you understand how this board is supposed to work. Once we don't like someone every act they ever did and judgment they ever made has to be wrong. And if it isn't let's just make stuff up and say it is.

 

[Ant3411]

So who gets cut from the #8 recruiting class in country to get someone who had to redshirt his freshman year at K state

A. Vance Jackson
B. Juwan Durham
C. Alterique Gilbert
D. Christian Vital
E. Mamadou Diarra

McGuirl is not a redshirt freshman. He is a true freshman. You are comparing him to the wrong recruiting class.