A couple of points. If you want to blame Ollie for anything, it is the roster turnover over the past few years. We have had to rely on transfers, grad transfer, jucos,... Having roster turnover is not good for team chemistry or offensive and defensive flow. Kentucky, although using much higher rated players, has high roster turnover and they usually struggle to start every year as Caliper tries to mold them into a team. Any coach, including Geno, would have difficulty coaching a team with the amount of roster turnover the men have had this year and last year. All that said, for UConn to get back to be relevant in basketball again, we need to bring in and develop high school recruits with the occasional grad transfer to fill a need.
Players back from the previous season (excluding early season injuries):
2017/2018: 2 (6-2)
2016/2017: 4 (16-17)
2015/2016: 7 (25-11)
2014/2015: 6 (20-15)
2013/2014: 8 (32-8)
2012/2013: 6 (20-10)
Two other glaring problems have been the lack of big men with decent hands and point guard development.
I am encouraged with the big men being brought in like Carlton, Diarra, Whaley, Polley, and for next year, Kisunas. These bigs seem to have decent hands and I think they can be developed. David O is a one year plug in who is limited and Cobb can be a decent contributor for 2 years.
Point guard has been especially problematic over the past few years with no consistency or mentorship. The problem seemed to be settled when we brought Gilbert in as he was supposed to be a sophomore this year, paired with Adams a junior. If Gilbert comes back this year, Adams comes back next year, and with Akinjo coming in, the PG succession and mentoring seems to be back in place. (A couple of big ifs there.)
Here is the recent history of UConn point guards that I posted in another thread that shows the recent lack of consistency.
(In bold are the season in which UConn went to the elite 8 or better. W/L record are listed for PG transition years.)
2017/2018: Gilbert
2016/2017: Adams (16-17)
2015/2016: Gibbs (25-11)
2014/2015: Boatright (20-15)
2013/2014: Napier
2012/2013: Napier
2011/2012: Napier (20-14)
2010/2011: Walker
2009/2010: Walker (18-16)
2008/2009: Price
2007/2008: Price
2006/2007: Price (17-14)
2005/2006: Williams
2004/2005: Williams (23-8)
2003/2004: Brown
2002/2003: Brown
2001/2002: Brown
2000/2001: Brown (20-12)
1999/2000: El-Amin
1998/1999: El-Amin
1997/1998: El-Amin (32-5)
1996/1997: Moore (18-15)
1995/1996: Sheffer (32-3)
1994/1995: Ollie
1993/1994: Ollie
1992/1993: Ollie (15-13)
1991/1992: Smith
1990/1991: Smith (20-11)
1989/1990: George
1988/1989: George
1987/1988: George
1986/1987: George (9-19)