CL82
NCAA Men’s Basketball National Champions - Again!
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2011
- Messages
- 59,340
- Reaction Score
- 221,437
Why not?It won’t happen and it shouldn’t happe
Why not?It won’t happen and it shouldn’t happe
I think the genius rep came from interviews with the players. Numerous times they raved about Charlton's creativity.Quarterback passed for 214/game. Passed 484 plays ran 496. Total offense 346/game. These are season averages. So I’m not exactly sure where the idea that Carlton is some kind of offensive genius came from. His offense the year he was OC at Maine was pretty pedestrian by current standards. They won a bunch of games to be sure, but they certainly wouldn’t be confused with the greatest show on turf. And I think the offense they are currently running is pretty pedestrian too. If it is because Zion can’t make plays, that is a problem. If it is because the OC really isn’t that creative, we have a different problem.
Why does every OC have to be a genius?I think the genius rep came from interviews with the players. Numerous times they raved about Charlton's creativity.
It doesn't seem fair to judge him yet, but I think if there is any time we need to see creativity, it would be now...lol.
I get what you are saying, and I agree to a point. But seriously, nobody can get open? Never? There. is no design to throw long or medium passes, it seems. Or the quarterback can’t can’t do it. I mean I saw Zergiotis throw several long tds. As a true freshman behind Swiss cheese olines. I had zero expectation of beating Michigan. But throwing for 24 yards ? Yikes. Longest completion is 7 yards by Millen late? The offense is so bad it makes out defensive backfield seem solid. Maybe it is time to get away from a playbook Zion feels comfortable and go with one we need to move the football.Why does every OC have to be a genius?
It comes down to players. I like UConn’s offensive design, much better than what we saw previous two years where it felt like they were just calling plays and had no philosophy. Issue with Charlton’s offense is no one can get open verticallyx and the QB is young.
I have blamed coaches enough over 10 years. Comes down to players. Coaches gotta be more creative here, Ut end of day get open and make a play.
Can the WRs throw a block once in a while on those WR screens?
Bada-boom!Some facts just sound right this one dozen.
Our wide receivers should watch MIchigan's wr downfield blocking and hopefully learn from it. About as good as it gets.Why does every OC have to be a genius?
It comes down to players. I like UConn’s offensive design, much better than what we saw previous two years where it felt like they were just calling plays and had no philosophy. Issue with Charlton’s offense is no one can get open verticallyx and the QB is young.
I have blamed coaches enough over 10 years. Comes down to players. Coaches gotta be more creative here, Ut end of day get open and make a play.
Can the WRs throw a block once in a while on those WR screens?
Um....I didn't say he had to be a genius...I was just answering why he has the genius reputation.Why does every OC have to be a genius?
It comes down to players. I like UConn’s offensive design, much better than what we saw previous two years where it felt like they were just calling plays and had no philosophy. Issue with Charlton’s offense is no one can get open verticallyx and the QB is young.
I have blamed coaches enough over 10 years. Comes down to players. Coaches gotta be more creative here, Ut end of day get open and make a play.
Can the WRs throw a block once in a while on those WR screens?
I have to say, not exactly. We are asking wide receivers to catch footballs. The idea is not so much they will break open every time. The idea is you take pressure off the box because they have to cover, because if they do get lazy and cheat, then our second class WRs are perfectly capable of catching a deep pass. The same goes with the mid-range passing. Simply using your TEs to block and release and move 12 yards down field behind the LBs forces them to back off the LOS and hold. A few passes behind the LBs does wonders. They simply have to account for a possible releasing TE. This is hugely effective in a play action. None of these things were done, and they are perfectly executable. Where I do agree is Zion can’t throw in small windows. So, what’s “open” is a function of QB accuracy and ability to put the ball where it must be when there is small separation. Final thought on this point. I am amazed how none of the guys were taught any back shoulder techniques. When you can’t beat man coverage, underthrowing to the back shoulder can work wonders.I don't get wanting the staff to ask players to execute plays they don't think the players are capable of executing. It would be like asking the basketball team, on a night they are getting blown out and can't get anything going inside, having Sanogo start chucking up threes just because nothing else is working.
I have to say, not exactly. We are asking wide receivers to catch footballs. The idea is not so much they will break open every time. The idea is you take pressure off the box because they have to cover, because if they do get lazy and cheat, then our second class WRs are perfectly capable of catching a deep pass. The same goes with the mid-range passing. Simply using your TEs to block and release and move 12 yards down field behind the LBs forces them to back off the LOS and hold. A few passes behind the LBs does wonders. They simply have to account for a possible releasing TE. This is hugely effective in a play action. None of these things were done, and they are perfectly executable. Where I do agree is Zion can’t throw in small windows. So, what’s “open” is a function of QB accuracy and ability to put the ball where it must be when there is small separation. Final thought on this point. I am amazed how none of the guys were taught any back shoulder techniques. When you can’t beat man coverage, underthrowing to the back shoulder can work wonders.
I agree. Multiple times, the bigger wide receivers from Michigan sealed off the UConn defenders from even making a play on Michigan receiver who just caught the ball and ran outside. Unfortunately, I believe that Fitzgerald was one of the better blockers and he just got injured.Our wide receivers should watch MIchigan's wr downfield blocking and hopefully learn from it. About as good as it gets.
No one is doubting that to have an effective offense you have to be able to throw the ball down the field at least somewhat. You are assuming that our unwillingness to do so is based on something other than knowing our personnel isn't good enough to execute it. I believe that the more rational assumption is that the coaches have tried it in practice and know we aren't good enough to do it.
Let's see. The coaches determine that players (even with good scheme) can't execute down field passes so that's off the table.No one is doubting that to have an effective offense you have to be able to throw the ball down the field at least somewhat. You are assuming that our unwillingness to do so is based on something other than knowing our personnel isn't good enough to execute it. I believe that the more rational assumption is that the coaches have tried it in practice and know we aren't good enough to do it.
I hear that’s what the ladies say.Kid has good size.
The problem is that the TE’s on the field right now aren’t effective and they lost their best blocking TE to injury before the season. We can’t catch a break with all of these injuries.I have to say, not exactly. We are asking wide receivers to catch footballs. The idea is not so much they will break open every time. The idea is you take pressure off the box because they have to cover, because if they do get lazy and cheat, then our second class WRs are perfectly capable of catching a deep pass. The same goes with the mid-range passing. Simply using your TEs to block and release and move 12 yards down field behind the LBs forces them to back off the LOS and hold. A few passes behind the LBs does wonders. They simply have to account for a possible releasing TE. This is hugely effective in a play action. None of these things were done, and they are perfectly executable. Where I do agree is Zion can’t throw in small windows. So, what’s “open” is a function of QB accuracy and ability to put the ball where it must be when there is small separation. Final thought on this point. I am amazed how none of the guys were taught any back shoulder techniques. When you can’t beat man coverage, underthrowing to the back shoulder can work wonders.
If we are going to run Ohio State’s offense from cica 1965 it will be a looong season.I agree with this. The coaches know better than anyone on this board 1) what plays win games and 2) what plays our team can execute.
Um....I didn't say he had to be a genius...I was just answering why he has the genius reputation.
But...I think you are letting Charlton off the hook too easy. He has to either figure out a way to coach up players to "get open and make a play"...or he has to design plays that succeed despite the team's deficiencies.
I am not saying Charlton sucks because they aren't passing for 300 yards a game. But I do think it's fair to question him when they only pass for 24 yards.
Circumstances are extreme....and he needs time...but it's fair to
I am inclined to agree, but reread your last sentence and realize what a staggering statement that actually is.No one is doubting that to have an effective offense you have to be able to throw the ball down the field at least somewhat. You are assuming that our unwillingness to do so is based on something other than knowing our personnel isn't good enough to execute it. I believe that the more rational assumption is that the coaches have tried it in practice and know we aren't good enough to do it.
Actually it is anticipation and timing ... as well as accuracy. Being open is time dependent and very transient. First the WR is covered, he makes a certain move that the QB expects, and then for a split second the WR is open. Then the window closes. That is a complicated physics problem as well as a problem for the QB to have confidence that the WB will deliver what is expected and the throw has to be initiated often when the WR is still covered, bookkeeping that he will deliver the move at the prcise moment that the QB's arm starts forward causing the ball to arrive at precisely the right moment.Where I do agree is Zion can’t throw in small windows. So, what’s “open” is a function of QB accuracy and ability to put the ball where it must be when there is small separation.
Excellent "knowledge of the game" post!! Thank you.The passing game is not Charlton's fault right now. You must give him a pass based upon injuries to WRs, starting QB, and even starting RB as well as the strength of schedule. The fact of the matter is that the Michigans and NC St.s of the world are going to man cover. And their 4 star DBs are going to lock down UConn's third string WRs 80% of the time. Giving not an inch to deliver a ball. 15% of the time that they are open momentarily ZT will be either sacked or hurried from the pocket, leaving a whopping 5% of the time our FRESHMAN QB has to comfortably deliver a well-timed accurate throw. He has not converted much in his 5% but what can you expect. With a lack of run game against the big boys those safeties will hawk in the intermediate game too. No design from Charlton is going to alleviate any of those issues right now. Maybe when we have everyone back or against lower level comp.
I am inclined to agree, but reread your last sentence and realize what a staggering statement that actually is.