OT: Best Pizza in CT

[Husky25]

yeah i’m never getting another one but it’s really good.

I've got about a couple dozen lbs. to go. On an aggressive schedule, that would put my goal somewhere mid-October. Alas, I've been stalled for a few weeks and we are on the precipice of a vacation, football season, followed by the Holidays. Maybe I'll treat myself when the UConn Men earn a bid to the NCAA tournament.

 

[tentoes4rings]

No mozzarella, just a little grated parmesan on top.

Went to Sally’s tonight with extended family. As a group we had four pies. A traditional cheese with mozz, bacon and onion, mushroom and the no mozzarella with a little parmesan on top. While good, I didn’t feel the first 3 were extra special compared to other great pizza places. The no mozzarella though was outstanding, it’s definitely the pie to get from Sally’s in my opinion.

 

[upstater]

Went to Sally’s tonight with extended family. As a group we had four pies. A traditional cheese with mozz, bacon and onion, mushroom and the no mozzarella with a little parmesan on top. While good, I didn’t feel the first 3 were extra special compared to other great pizza places. The no mozzarella though was outstanding, it’s definitely the pie to get from Sally’s in my opinion.

Next time I would recommend sausage from them--they do a good job with it.

 

[Balker]

Big new opening in New Haven today. Zeneli’s opened up right across from Pepe’s and is definitely ready to challenge the Wooster big boys. 30 seat restaurant with small bar, wood fired oven, Neapolitan style. Casual but more upscale and trendy than the retro vibe they have on the rest of Wooster. Really solid opening day pizzas.

 

[Mazhude]

Big new opening in New Haven today. Zeneli’s opened up right across from Pepe’s and is definitely ready to challenge the Wooster big boys. 30 seat restaurant with small bar, wood fired oven, Neapolitan style. Casual but more upscale and trendy than the retro vibe they have on the rest of Wooster. Really solid opening day pizzas.

Neapolitan Brothers Take On Wooster Square Pizza

This restaurant will open early in the morning to serve cappuccinos, croissants, and other breakfast goodies, then transition to pizza and booze in the evening... they have ordered a special, wood-fired pizza oven from Naples to stock their new New Haven kitchen. Each pizza will only take 90 seconds to cook in such an oven.
Their pies will be Neapolitan-style, they said, longer, more rectangular than round, and served as “personal pies” for individual consumption.

 

[Mazhude]

Neapolitan Brothers Take On Wooster Square Pizza

This restaurant will open early in the morning to serve cappuccinos, croissants, and other breakfast goodies, then transition to pizza and booze in the evening... they have ordered a special, wood-fired pizza oven from Naples to stock their new New Haven kitchen. Each pizza will only take 90 seconds to cook in such an oven.
Their pies will be Neapolitan-style, they said, longer, more rectangular than round, and served as “personal pies” for individual consumption.

So, in the old Cavaliere's space. I haven't been yet, but second-hand reports indicate a good Neapolitan pie, softer crust than New Haven apizza, slices available.

 

[Mazhude]

Sinatra, Sally’s Apizza and J. Press

“Ah, the apizza,” (pronounced ah-BEETS), said Sinatra, giving me a knowing wink...

 

[upstater]

Neapolitan Brothers Take On Wooster Square Pizza

This restaurant will open early in the morning to serve cappuccinos, croissants, and other breakfast goodies, then transition to pizza and booze in the evening... they have ordered a special, wood-fired pizza oven from Naples to stock their new New Haven kitchen. Each pizza will only take 90 seconds to cook in such an oven.
Their pies will be Neapolitan-style, they said, longer, more rectangular than round, and served as “personal pies” for individual consumption.

Sounds to me like something up here in Buffalo called Pi-Craft. Competes with Blaze. I'd be skeptical of this one minute pizza.

 

[huskymedic]

So, in the old Cavaliere's space. I haven't been yet, but second-hand reports indicate a good Neapolitan pie, softer crust than New Haven apizza, slices available.

New pizzeria opens on Wooster Street

On a street known for its historic pizza, a new spot called Zeneli just opened its doors but how will they compete with staples like Sally’s and Pepe’s?

www.wtnh.com

 

[storrsroars]

Sounds to me like something up here in Buffalo called Pi-Craft. Competes with Blaze. I'd be skeptical of this one minute pizza.

Neapolitan pizza is NOT assembly line pizza. Well-made brick wood-fired ovens reach >800F and can literally fully cook a pizza in under 2 minutes. Pretty much all good Neapolitan-style pizza places do this.

 

[superjohn]

Big new opening in New Haven today. Zeneli’s opened up right across from Pepe’s and is definitely ready to challenge the Wooster big boys. 30 seat restaurant with small bar, wood fired oven, Neapolitan style. Casual but more upscale and trendy than the retro vibe they have on the rest of Wooster. Really solid opening day pizzas.

Bold move opening a pizza place on Wooster street, especially wood fired. Coal fired>>wood fired.

New Haven is ridiculous, every other storefront is a pizza place.

 

[superjohn]

Sounds to me like something up here in Buffalo called Pi-Craft. Competes with Blaze. I'd be skeptical of this one minute pizza.

Lol, you've never heard of Neapolitan pizza?!??

You can calmly see yourself out of the pizza thread.

 

[August_West]

Bold move opening a pizza place on Wooster street, especially wood fired. Coal fired>>wood fired.

New Haven is ridiculous, every other storefront is a pizza place.

Wooster ST such a tourist trap now that it probably may be smart just from foot traffic overflow

 

[methodology]

Neapolitan pizza is NOT assembly line pizza. Well-made brick wood-fired ovens reach >800F and can literally fully cook a pizza in under 2 minutes. Pretty much all good Neapolitan-style pizza places do this.

Yes they get extremely hot upwards of 1200 degrees but pizza should be cooked at about 660 degrees.

Old timer who worked at de legna helped my buddy build a $20k wood fired pizza oven in his backyard this summer and gave us those instructions. You also measure the heat by pointing the gun at the floor of the oven not the coals

 

[storrsroars]

Wooster ST such a tourist trap now that it probably may be smart just from foot traffic overflow

I don't know what it's like in NH or CT these days regarding brick oven pizza, but here in Pgh, I can't get excited over any new Neopolitan place. There are so many already and they're pretty much interchangeable. Our most interesting pizza additions in past 2-3 years have been a couple of "upscale" Detroit-style stands and a Roman street pizza place.

 

[storrsroars]

Yes they get extremely hot upwards of 1200 degrees but pizza should be cooked at about 660 degrees.

Old timer who worked at de legna helped my buddy build a $20k wood fired pizza oven in his backyard this summer and gave us those instructions. You also measure the heat by pointing the gun at the floor of the oven not the coals

Ask any "old timer" how to properly make a pizza and you'll get an answer that their way is the only way.

 

[superjohn]

I don't know what it's like in NH or CT these days regarding brick oven pizza, but here in Pgh, I can't get excited over any new Neopolitan place. There are so many already and they're pretty much interchangeable. Our most interesting pizza additions in past 2-3 years have been a couple of "upscale" Detroit-style stands and a Roman street pizza place.

They don't do much for me either. Usually the exact same menu, the pies are typically overpriced, and they usually seem to get soggy in the middle. Excellent ingredients but a personal pie for 18 bucks and they still can't seem to cook it perfectly.

 

[UConnDad]

They don't do much for me either. Usually the exact same menu, the pies are typically overpriced, and they usually seem to get soggy in the middle. Excellent ingredients but a personal pie for 18 bucks and they still can't seem to cook it perfectly.

There's still a lot of dough in a pizza!

 

[upstater]

Lol, you've never heard of Neapolitan pizza?!??

You can calmly see yourself out of the pizza thread.

Every pizza I've ever had there was round. Every one. And I lived there for 1 1/2 years.

But yeah, I didn't know they did it in 60 seconds. Any pizza place I ate at when I lived in Napoli we waited for 20-30 minutes

 

[storrsroars]

Every pizza I've ever had there was round. Every one. And I lived there for 1 1/2 years.

But yeah, I didn't know they did it in 60 seconds. Any pizza place I ate at when I lived in Napoli we waited for 20-30 minutes

Well you'll wait 20-30 minutes at any Neopolitan place in US as well. The cooking is really fast, but the making is slower than a NY style pizza.

 

[huskymedic]

Each pizza will only take 90 seconds to cook in such an oven.

I'd be skeptical of this one minute pizza.

Well-made brick wood-fired ovens reach >800F and can literally fully cook a pizza in under 2 minutes.

But yeah, I didn't know they did it in 60 seconds

 

[superjohn]

Every pizza I've ever had there was round. Every one. And I lived there for 1 1/2 years.

But yeah, I didn't know they did it in 60 seconds. Any pizza place I ate at when I lived in Napoli we waited for 20-30 minutes

Don't understand your round comment. Yes, pies in Napoli and D.O.C certified pizzas in the states are round and they take about 90 seconds. I also ate pizza in Napoli, it's good but no New Haven.

Why did you live in Napoli? I really enjoyed it there.

 

[8893]

Big new opening in New Haven today. Zeneli’s opened up right across from Pepe’s and is definitely ready to challenge the Wooster big boys. 30 seat restaurant with small bar, wood fired oven, Neapolitan style. Casual but more upscale and trendy than the retro vibe they have on the rest of Wooster. Really solid opening day pizzas.

Neapolitan Brothers Take On Wooster Square Pizza

This restaurant will open early in the morning to serve cappuccinos, croissants, and other breakfast goodies, then transition to pizza and booze in the evening... they have ordered a special, wood-fired pizza oven from Naples to stock their new New Haven kitchen. Each pizza will only take 90 seconds to cook in such an oven.
Their pies will be Neapolitan-style, they said, longer, more rectangular than round, and served as “personal pies” for individual consumption.

So, in the old Cavaliere's space. I haven't been yet, but second-hand reports indicate a good Neapolitan pie, softer crust than New Haven apizza, slices available.

Just had lunch there. Very good pie and good guys (btw, they are Albanian, not Italian, but they lived in Naples). I asked the one making the pies what his signature pie was so I could try to get the best representation of their style and he recommended the Margherita Verace, a red pie with sauce from San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozz, basil and evoo. Good, chewy crust, but a bit too floppy and lacking in char to warrant a top grade. Like Bufalina, it is more similar to the pizza I had in Italy than New Haven-style apizza is, but it is not as good as Bufalina. No shame in that, though; I think it's better than Strega in Branford, Krust in Middletown or Otto in Chester, all of which are variations on that same theme. I would place it on par with Next Door.

Only personal pizzas; no slices. Apps and pastas that I did not sample. Owner offered me an espresso on the house, which was a nice touch.

I will be back.

 

[upstater]

View attachment 45261

Vera Pizza says 60-90 seconds

Maybe you should take your argument up with them

 

[8893]

Here is the menu:

 

[upstater]

Don't understand your round comment. Yes, pies in Napoli and D.O.C certified pizzas in the states are round and they take about 90 seconds. I also ate pizza in Napoli, it's good but no New Haven.

Why did you live in Napoli? I really enjoyed it there.

I was there with George Mason for a semester, then went north to U. Padova for a semester (no American affiliation, just enrolled in the school for Stranieri [strangers]) then I came back to Napoli to live with friends I met the previous fall, and I worked (various jobs). My family and I went back and stayed with them just last summer. I became a Maradona/Napoli fan (this was back in 1989-1991) and have always been (they even just signed some of my favorite players).

By the way, the article above says it won't be a round pizza but an oval personal one. That's what reminded me of Pi-Craft. In Napoli, I only ever had round. But, I have to admit, we never talked about how much time it took to make it, nor did we have pizza threads on the Napoli Calcio website (which obviously didn't exist).

 

[superjohn]

Good, chewy crust, but a bit too floppy and lacking in char to warrant a top grade.
View attachment 45262

That's how they all are.

 

[8893]

That's how they all are.

Not Bufalina.

 

[uconnphil2016]

Had a plain pie from Little Rendezvous last night. They were great once again. A small step below the sallys of the world, but a closer drive for me than new haven. Highly recommended if you’re in Hartford area and want a New Haven esque pie

 

[Balker]

Just had lunch there. Very good pie and good guys (btw, they are Albanian, not Italian, but they lived in Naples). I asked the one making the pies what his signature pie was so I could try to get the best representation of their style and he recommended the Margherita Verace, a red pie with sauce from San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozz, basil and evoo. Good, chewy crust, but a bit too floppy and lacking in char to warrant a top grade. Like Bufalina, it is more similar to the pizza I had in Italy than New Haven-style apizza is, but it is not as good as Bufalina. No shame in that, though; I think it's better than Strega in Branford, Krust in Middletown or Otto in Chester, all of which are variations on that same theme. I would place it on par with Next Door.

Only personal pizzas; no slices. Apps and pastas that I did not sample. Owner offered me an espresso on the house, which was a nice touch.

I will be back.
View attachment 45262

Totally agreed on the crust not having enough stability through to the middle. I got a the same pie and had them add sausage to it, which exacerbated the issue. But otherwise, very fine pizza. Great dough flavor and sauce. I requested well done and it still din't have much char to it, but it not bad at all. Definitely up there, and could maybe improve with a bit more time.

Hoping to make it back to try another pie and some pasta soon. Fortunately (or unfortunately) my office is on Chapel near the State St corner, so I'll probably be there pretty regularly.