OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 288 | The Boneyard

OT: Best Pizza in CT

husky8273 said:
no tables available at new Sally's in Wethersfield today between 4-8pm
Expand ...
It was like that for a few weeks when the Sally's in Woburn, MA opened. But then about 4-5 weeks after they opened we went online on a Wednesday and got a reservation for 7:00 pm that Saturday. And when we were there all the tables weren't taken. So I think the madness will die down very shortly. Especially after some people get turned off by the prices Sally's charges.
 
HooperScooper said:
It was like that for a few weeks when the Sally's in Woburn, MA opened. But then about 4-5 weeks after they opened we went online on a Wednesday and got a reservation for 7:00 pm that Saturday. And when we were there all the tables weren't taken. So I think the madness will die down very shortly. Especially after some people get turned off by the prices Sally's charges.
Expand ...
How was it??
 
Rocktheworld said:
How was it??
Expand ...
Pretty good. Crust was definitely apizza. I like Pepe's better though. They don't put very much cheese on their pizzas when we went twice to the Sally's in Woburn. Haven't been to the New Haven one in forever so I can't tell you if it was the same. My son the pizza connoisseur has though and he said it was definitely similar to the New Haven Sally's and he likes it better than Pepe's.

Curious to hear people's reactions to the Sally's in Wethersfield. As good as New Haven Sally's?

I still think their prices at Sally's are out of whack. Pepe's is already at the high end of pricing for pizza. No need to be 15%-20% more than Pepe's. Just seems like price gouging.
 
Hoophound said:
Went to Pepe’s in Danbury last night. It was pretty good but nothing special. Did the tomato pie with mozzarella and the Italian salad. The crust was crisp and lightly charred but there was too little sauce and I actually needed to put salt on it. I’m not a salt person, but a little salt really helped bring out the tomato flavor. It was meh but the texture was just right. It has me wondering if I just don’t like Pepe’s much anymore because the feel and appearance were there. The flavor was just underwhelming.

We were heading north from White Plains and I really regretted not going to Pizza Post in Greenwich instead.

I am looking forward to getting pizza in Vermont this week. I think Piecasso in Stowe produces an outstanding NY Style Pizza and I’m certain I’ll be happier with it than I was at Pepe’s. If you ever get the opportunity, give it a try.
Expand ...
Saying you're leaving CT to get better pizza in VT is a joke.
 
.-.
Deepster said:
Chicago deep dish from Northern California?

You’re in the wrong thread, bubie.
Expand ...
Nah, I'm not. High-quality Chicago deep dish definitely exists in NorCal. I have had Deep-dish from two places in that area, and it definitely compares well.

On the other angle, I am off-topic... and pictures don't tell the story, but none of the pics I've seen in CT don't look nearly as goodas Chitown deep-dish.

One of these days, I'll get to CT and try the real CT deal.
 
AidanFan20 said:
Nah, I'm not. High-quality Chicago deep dish definitely exists in NorCal. I have had Deep-dish from two places in that area, and it definitely compares well.

On the other angle, I am off-topic... and pictures don't tell the story, but none of the pics I've seen in CT don't look nearly as goodas Chitown deep-dish.

One of these days, I'll get to CT and try the real CT deal.
Expand ...
When you finally have a great New Haven style pizza, you will realize how silly your comments look to many of us.
 
Huskybass said:
When you finally have a great New Haven style pizza, you will realize how silly your comments look to many of us.
Expand ...
It’s one step above saying Papa John’s is decent.
 
I admit to being old but $35 for pizza? That is a good entree price at some very decent restaurants.
 
jibsey said:
I admit to being old but $35 for pizza? That is a good entree price at some very decent restaurants.
Expand ...
I don’t think I’ve seen that price anywhere in either of the affluent large cities I’ve lived in. Unless it was some gimmick pizza with like gold leaf on it, or some crazy 30” pizza or something. Kind of befuddling report.
 
.-.
huskyjawz said:
Saying you're leaving CT to get better pizza in VT is a joke.
Expand ...

I didn’t say I was leaving CT in search of better pizza. I said I wasn’t impressed with Pepe’s Danbury and wished I went to Pizza Post instead (also in CT)

Piecasso in Stowe is excellent NY Style pizza. It is widely considered the best in the state and it is in fact, every bit as good as most very good pizza joints in CT. It isn’t Modern or Sally’s, but it isn’t trying to be. I definitely think it’s better than Pepe’s in Danbury.
 
Rocktheworld said:
I don’t think I’ve seen that price anywhere in either of the affluent large cities I’ve lived in. Unless it was some gimmick pizza with like gold leaf on it, or some crazy 30” pizza or something. Kind of befuddling report.
Expand ...
Sally's costs you $40 for a large pepperoni out the door.
 
HooperScooper said:
Exactly $40.52 with tax for an 18" large with pepperoni in New Haven. So much for pizza being peasant food. :)
Expand ...
It's insanity. In my experience the pizza isn't what it used to be either. It's crazy they charge nearly $14 more than Modern and get away with it.
 
My wife had to do some work in New Haven Friday and took her team out for lunch they selected Bar Pizza. So she bought me a tomato pie. Can’t really rank it fairly when it lands 4-5 hours later even after heating in the oven. But it was only ok nothing to go crazy over. Not enough sauce and while I like thin a lot not sure on paper thin. But again guessing much better in person.
 
mauconnfan said:
My wife had to do some work in New Haven Friday and took her team out for lunch they selected Bar Pizza. So she bought me a tomato pie. Can’t really rank it fairly when it lands 4-5 hours later even after heating in the oven. But it was only ok nothing to go crazy over. Not enough sauce and while I like thin a lot not sure on paper thin. But again guessing much better in person.
Expand ...

Do you like Red Rose in Springfield? (I’m assuming you’ve been). I think it’s very good. Again, not New Haven style, but delicious. Hoping to get there the weekend of the Wake football game. Missed it on the way up.
 
.-.
Hoophound said:
I didn’t say I was leaving CT in search of better pizza. I said I wasn’t impressed with Pepe’s Danbury and wished I went to Pizza Post instead (also in CT)

Piecasso in Stowe is excellent NY Style pizza. It is widely considered the best in the state and it is in fact, every bit as good as most very good pizza joints in CT. It isn’t Modern or Sally’s, but it isn’t trying to be. I definitely think it’s better than Pepe’s in Danbury.
Expand ...
My brother's lived in Fayston VT for fifteen years and has me bring Pepe's up for Xmas every year because the pizza up there is a joke (his words) as is all of the food (Italian, Chinese, etc) compared to CT. Flatbread pizza is what goes for pizza up there. All that being said, I guess you found a decent place in Stowe.
 
huskyjawz said:
My brother's lived in Fayston VT for fifteen years and has me bring Pepe's up for Xmas every year because the pizza up there is a joke (his words) as is all of the food (Italian, Chinese, etc) compared to CT. Flatbread pizza is what goes for pizza up there. All that being said, I guess you found a decent place in Stowe.
Expand ...
Nothing good in Burlington? Honestly, if you decide to live in the boonies of VT you can't really complain that there's no good pizza or any ethnic food. I'm sure there are some good root vegetables up that way. :)
 
Hoophound said:
Do you like Red Rose in Springfield? (I’m assuming you’ve been). I think it’s very good. Again, not New Haven style, but delicious. Hoping to get there the weekend of the Wake football game. Missed it on the way up.
Expand ...

Red Rose good call @Hoophound and add their family salad to your order as well, house dressing is excellent. Yeah the Rose is one of very few decent pizza places in Western Mass for sure. Certainly not New Haven but having lived up here for 34 years easy to like. Since they built the bar area about the time MGM tried to buy them it’s one of my favorite places to go with my wife and buddies. Hope you get to swing in that weekend!
 
Recently had Rossini's in East Hampton, CT again. I gotta think it's the best pizza east of the river. Very affordable too - a large pepperoni pie was gigantic and $22.50ish all in
 
huskyjawz said:
My brother's lived in Fayston VT for fifteen years and has me bring Pepe's up for Xmas every year because the pizza up there is a joke (his words) as is all of the food (Italian, Chinese, etc) compared to CT. Flatbread pizza is what goes for pizza up there. All that being said, I guess you found a decent place in Stowe.
Expand ...

Fayston is nice, but there isn’t much there. Piecasso in Stowe is great, Positive Pie has 3 northern VT locations. It’s also excellent. Juniors in Williston is very good, as is their Italian food. Salute in Stowe is an excellent Italian joint. Burlington and the surrounding area is foodie heaven. So many great places, but again, you’ve gotta try to find them. The Internet is a must when you are in a new place.

People need to know what’s around. In Florida I’ve got 3 pizza places with 2.5 miles of my house that are incredible. That doesn’t even include a place about 4 miles away that Portnoy gave a 7.8 or an amazing wood fired place that does Pizza Napoletana with an old Italian recipe that I consider absolutely fantastic. All are owned by former NY/NJ restaurant owners, yet people say Florida is a pizza wasteland. It isn’t, but it’s hard to get off a plane someplace you aren’t familiar with and know where to get a great pizza, especially by your own definition of what’s good. There’s a pizza place every quarter mile, most aren’t very good just like in CT.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0435.jpeg
    IMG_0435.jpeg
    45.4 KB · Views: 128
Last edited:
.-.
WrenchFan69 said:
Recently had Rossini's in East Hampton, CT again. I gotta think it's the best pizza east of the river. Very affordable too - a large pepperoni pie was gigantic and $22.50ish all in
Expand ...
I haven't been to Rossini's in decades but do remember it being very good.

Best pizza east of the CT River? Harry's in Glastonbury WAS great, but they went out of business a few years ago. Square Peg is pretty good, but they struggle with cooking an otherwise really good pizza evenly. I can think of a bunch of good pizza places east of the river, but I'm not sure I'd tag any of them as great.
 
Huskybass said:
I haven't been to Rossini's in decades but do remember it being very good.

Best pizza east of the CT River? Harry's in Glastonbury WAS great, but they went out of business a few years ago. Square Peg is pretty good, but they struggle with cooking an otherwise really good pizza evenly. I can think of a bunch of good pizza places east of the river, but I'm not sure I'd tag any of them as great.
Expand ...
Brick & Basil in Norwich was making really quite good pizza out of their truck but they recently moved into a restaurant space? Haven't been lately and idk if it's the same. Old Mystic General Store actually made really solid pizza but closed. Sassano in Glastonbury was very good but changed owners and I haven't been back to try it since; I've heard it's not as good. Camille's in Tolland is good and I like Willington Pizza, but Rossini's clears both imo.
 
Huskybass said:
I haven't been to Rossini's in decades but do remember it being very good.

Best pizza east of the CT River? Harry's in Glastonbury WAS great, but they went out of business a few years ago. Square Peg is pretty good, but they struggle with cooking an otherwise really good pizza evenly. I can think of a bunch of good pizza places east of the river, but I'm not sure I'd tag any of them as great.
Expand ...
Pepe's in Manchester is better than Rossini's. I've had Rossini's a few times because we have some family in East Hampton. It's pretty good but nothing too great.
 
WrenchFan69 said:
Brick & Basil in Norwich was making really quite good pizza out of their truck but they recently moved into a restaurant space? Haven't been lately and idk if it's the same. Old Mystic General Store actually made really solid pizza but closed. Sassano in Glastonbury was very good but changed owners and I haven't been back to try it since; I've heard it's not as good. Camille's in Tolland is good and I like Willington Pizza, but Rossini's clears both imo.
Expand ...
Willy pizza has fallen off a cliff from what I remember as a student at UConn. I went back last fall after a Gampel game and was disgusted (and partially offended) by the pizzas I got; and my standards for acceptable/edible pizza are hilariously low at least compared to the snobs in this thread
 
Last edited:
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,184
Messages
4,556,015
Members
10,441
Latest member
Virginiafan


Top Bottom