OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 159 | The Boneyard

OT: Best Pizza in CT

Is it time to get rid of the pizza thread?

  • Yes. It's past it's useful time here.

    Votes: 10 14.1%
  • No. I can't live without it.

    Votes: 50 70.4%
  • Move it to another board.

    Votes: 11 15.5%

  • Total voters
    71
I always order our Modern pies "well done, light mozz" for the best char and least sag.

I do bacon on our clam pies.

Red pie with artichoke hearts and eggplant is probably our most common order there. Always great.

Red pie with meatballs and tomato is another fave.

Sausage is always excellent there, too.
Never thought of "light mozz."
I do tell them to "burn it," and always enjoy turning the box vertically and then like a diamond to tap the sides and collect all the flavorful burnt dust before the box gets pitched or recycled.
 
Going to Modern tonight for the first time in over 10 years. Toppings suggestions? Figure we’ll get one white clam for sure, what else would you guys say they excel at?
Always a sausage pie.
 
I always order our Modern pies "well done, light mozz" for the best char and least sag.

I do bacon on our clam pies.

Red pie with artichoke hearts and eggplant is probably our most common order there. Always great.

Red pie with meatballs and tomato is another fave.

Sausage is always excellent there, too.
So we opted for a white clam pie and a bacon, meatball. Forgot to order light mozz and well done, which would have made a really good experience perfect. For my money, Modern it cooked correctly might be the best of the Big 3.
 
So we opted for a white clam pie and a bacon, meatball. Forgot to order light mozz and well done, which would have made a really good experience perfect. For my money, Modern it cooked correctly might be the best of the Big 3.
I think it's become my favorite too. I've had pies at all three that when firing on all cylinders are about as good as it gets. My last trip to Pepe's was great with Sally's being a letdown. Modern has fired on all cylinders the last few times I went and I just reallt like the place. Crowded but don't really have to wait, pitchers of Foxon Park soda, prices are excellent, old school joint feel without even trying to capture it, and the owner is a good dude.
 
Modern did not disappoint. Absolutely delicious. As 8893 said, light Mozz and well done is the way to go. We are truly fortunate to have Pepe's, Modern, Sally's and Bufalina within striking distance on any given night. The bacon and meatball we got was virtually perfect once we allowed it to sit for a few minutes. In the middle of one bite, I literally thought to myself " F@&k, this is incredible" and I am not prone to swearing.
 
I think it's become my favorite too. I've had pies at all three that when firing on all cylinders are about as good as it gets. My last trip to Pepe's was great with Sally's being a letdown. Modern has fired on all cylinders the last few times I went and I just reallt like the place. Crowded but don't really have to wait, pitchers of Foxon Park soda, prices are excellent, old school joint feel without even trying to capture it, and the owner is a good dude.

They are definitely the most consistent. My recommendation to people when they ask. But when Sally's is on I lean towards them
 
Well, since pizza and cheese go hand in hand and these guys supply many of the area pizza artisans...


>>All told, Liuzzi won five national awards — including 1st place wins for its ultra-rich Ricotta di Bufala and smoked Burrata cheeses, 2nd place for its Burrata and 3rd place for both its Filoncino (fior di latte fresh mozzarella) and Smoked Mozzarella cheeses.

Calabro won four national awards, including 1st place for its creamy Hand-Dipped Ricotta and three 2nd place wins for its Ricotta di Bufala, Bocconcini (bite-sized) Fresh Mozzarella and Old Fashioned Fresh Mozzarella cheeses.<<
 
Modern did not disappoint. Absolutely delicious. As 8893 said, light Mozz and well done is the way to go. We are truly fortunate to have Pepe's, Modern, Sally's and Bufalina within striking distance on any given night. The bacon and meatball we got was virtually perfect once we allowed it to sit for a few minutes. In the middle of one bite, I literally thought to myself " F@&k, this is incredible" and I am not prone to swearing.
How has Zuppardis been lately? Anybody been recently? My favorite, but haven't been able to make it there since last summer.
 
How has Zuppardis been lately? Anybody been recently? My favorite, but haven't been able to make it there since last summer.
Funny you should ask. I just had Zuppardi’s from The Hops Conpany in Derby. Not the same as the original Zupp’a I’m sure but consistently good. I still need to try the original. Has anyone discussed Da Legna yet?
 
Well, since pizza and cheese go hand in hand and these guys supply many of the area pizza artisans...


>>All told, Liuzzi won five national awards — including 1st place wins for its ultra-rich Ricotta di Bufala and smoked Burrata cheeses, 2nd place for its Burrata and 3rd place for both its Filoncino (fior di latte fresh mozzarella) and Smoked Mozzarella cheeses.

Calabro won four national awards, including 1st place for its creamy Hand-Dipped Ricotta and three 2nd place wins for its Ricotta di Bufala, Bocconcini (bite-sized) Fresh Mozzarella and Old Fashioned Fresh Mozzarella cheeses.<<

That leads to the discussion about how to grade them all. Do you look at the specialty pies across the nation? Or do you hold the "gold standard" as a straight cheese pie like El Pres does and decide who does that best? He says the straight cheese pie is the 40 yard dash. It's a universal score.

This place has a white clam pie. This one has a red potato pie. This one has a meat lovers. This one has buffalo chicken.

I feel like the watermark is the cheese pizza. Period.
 
That leads to the discussion about how to grade them all. Do you look at the specialty pies across the nation? Or do you hold the "gold standard" as a straight cheese pie like El Pres does and decide who does that best? He says the straight cheese pie is the 40 yard dash. It's a universal score.

This place has a white clam pie. This one has a red potato pie. This one has a meat lovers. This one has buffalo chicken.

I feel like the watermark is the cheese pizza. Period.


One one hand, I agree. That's why multiple pies are a must. I HAVE to get bacon and onion and/or White Clam when I go to Pepe's. They are both that good. The comparison thing should be apples to apples, but some signiture toppings are always in order as well.
 
That leads to the discussion about how to grade them all. Do you look at the specialty pies across the nation? Or do you hold the "gold standard" as a straight cheese pie like El Pres does and decide who does that best? He says the straight cheese pie is the 40 yard dash. It's a universal score.

This place has a white clam pie. This one has a red potato pie. This one has a meat lovers. This one has buffalo chicken.

I feel like the watermark is the cheese pizza. Period.
I see arguments for both. Either measuring just on cheese pizza, or identifying the one pie that place specializes in and judging off that. If I’m going to Pepe’s; it’s gotta be clam, if it’s Modern, something with meat on it. Sally’s, the red pie with no mozz is the standout in my opinion,
 
>>Colin Caplan is a pizza guru. His deep love of his hometown, New Haven, Connecticut, has morphed into a deep love of all things pizza. Caplan’s so entrenched in the pizza scene of New Haven that he authored the book Pizza in New Haven in 2018 and co-produced a documentary called Pizza, A Love Story this year — both love letters to the brilliant pizza scene around Wooster Street in New Haven.

Today, Caplan runs food tours in New Haven through his Taste of New Haven tour company. He’s also the mind behind New Haven’s Apizza Feast, which is popping off September 13th this year. The festival celebrates the deep Italian-American heritage of the city, once the most densely populated Italian city in America, and the varied and delicious pies that community still produces.<<

 
>>Colin Caplan is a pizza guru. His deep love of his hometown, New Haven, Connecticut, has morphed into a deep love of all things pizza. Caplan’s so entrenched in the pizza scene of New Haven that he authored the book Pizza in New Haven in 2018 and co-produced a documentary called Pizza, A Love Story this year — both love letters to the brilliant pizza scene around Wooster Street in New Haven.

Today, Caplan runs food tours in New Haven through his Taste of New Haven tour company. He’s also the mind behind New Haven’s Apizza Feast, which is popping off September 13th this year. The festival celebrates the deep Italian-American heritage of the city, once the most densely populated Italian city in America, and the varied and delicious pies that community still produces.<<


Pizza with jalapeños?
Pizza from Boca Raton?

Uhhhh, hard pass.
 
That leads to the discussion about how to grade them all. Do you look at the specialty pies across the nation? Or do you hold the "gold standard" as a straight cheese pie like El Pres does and decide who does that best? He says the straight cheese pie is the 40 yard dash. It's a universal score.

This place has a white clam pie. This one has a red potato pie. This one has a meat lovers. This one has buffalo chicken.

I feel like the watermark is the cheese pizza. Period.
For a universal score, I can’t imagine a better standard—especially if you’re primarily using that standard to separate wheat from chaff. I’d assume there’s a good chance that any place that rates 8 or more on the plain scamozza pie scale has something(s) they even do better, so it would be a shame if people eliminated places at the margins on the basis of that scale alone.
 
Pizza from Boca Raton?

Uhhhh, hard pass.

Owner has deep CT roots/dough/pizza experience - comparable to pizza in CT/NY/NJ (even w/ Florida water).

>>Nick’s is best known for its specialty White Clam Pie. In addition to apizza, other regional specialties include Hummel hot dogs and East Haven, Connecticut Foxon Park sodas, crafted since 1922 in flavors such as White Birch and Gassosa. The menu also features a wide range of pastas, entrees, coal fired grinders and fresh salads. Standouts include House-made Ricotta Spinach Gnocchi, Linguine and Clams and a perfectly Grilled Skirt Steak with mushroom risotto and broccoli rabe.<<
 
Owner has deep CT roots/dough/pizza experience - comparable to pizza in CT/NY/NJ (even w/ Florida water).

>>Nick’s is best known for its specialty White Clam Pie. In addition to apizza, other regional specialties include Hummel hot dogs and East Haven, Connecticut Foxon Park sodas, crafted since 1922 in flavors such as White Birch and Gassosa. The menu also features a wide range of pastas, entrees, coal fired grinders and fresh salads. Standouts include House-made Ricotta Spinach Gnocchi, Linguine and Clams and a perfectly Grilled Skirt Steak with mushroom risotto and broccoli rabe.<<

Any legit pizza place carries foxon park if they don't leave immediately
 
Owner has deep CT roots/dough/pizza experience - comparable to pizza in CT/NY/NJ (even w/ Florida water).

>>Nick’s is best known for its specialty White Clam Pie. In addition to apizza, other regional specialties include Hummel hot dogs and East Haven, Connecticut Foxon Park sodas, crafted since 1922 in flavors such as White Birch and Gassosa. The menu also features a wide range of pastas, entrees, coal fired grinders and fresh salads. Standouts include House-made Ricotta Spinach Gnocchi, Linguine and Clams and a perfectly Grilled Skirt Steak with mushroom risotto and broccoli rabe.<<

Steaks
Pasta
Grinders
Risotto
Soda
Gnocchi

Go to another thread. I want the best pizza. Period.
 
Pizza with jalapeños?
Pizza from Boca Raton?

Uhhhh, hard pass.

I'm always delighted to hear about people evangelizing NH style pizza in different parts of the country. When I used to go to San Diego fairly regularly, URBN was a spot I'd try to hit every visit (they have Foxon Park). I'm becoming a fan of Detroit style like in the photo from Tony's, though I wouldn't compare it to the big three. And jalapenos... big fan of the stinger/hot oil Colony pie.

I think a talented pizzaiolo can probably make a pretty good version of a NH apizza anywhere with the right equipment. Wish someone would try it in Pittsburgh.

You can buy specific water additives these days to create a good facsimile of NH or NYC H2O. The issue is generally whether the public will like it as they're used to whatever they grew up with - and is often price sensitive. So I applaud all of those who can bring a good apizza to Boca Raton or wherever.

Also don't mind if the menu also includes other Italian dishes. But I personally draw the line at chicken wings. I've yet to have a mind-blowing pizza anywhere where wings was a major deal on the menu.
 
Last edited:
I need help, I'm going for pizza in Old Saybrook for lunch. Which spot is best?
 

Online statistics

Members online
116
Guests online
2,000
Total visitors
2,116

Forum statistics

Threads
163,961
Messages
4,376,774
Members
10,168
Latest member
CTFan142


.
..
Top Bottom