2023 Giants | Page 7 | The Boneyard

2023 Giants

HeGotGame said:
Per PFF Commanders OL rank is 13th in the league (prior to last week). I will let you guess where the Giants are ranked. Again, bad comparison, situations are not equal, in fact they are drastically different. Using Sam Howell's sacks number without seeing it as indictment on Howell is very telling and clearly based on not watching the games. There is a reason why Washington's sack numbers are so high but their pressure rate % is relatively low. Oh and Howell is the 23rd graded QB on PFF and Jones is 21st.

On Sept 23rd I posted that Jones has been bad. No one could say otherwise, but if you think he is the sole reason they are 1-5 then you are more lost than I thought. Giants have so many issues, QB play is one, but its the only one other than Darnay Holmes you ever mention. Its odd.

Oh, and obviously Holmes stinks, but again, it such an odd thing to stick too when the defense this year and last had a 100 larger problems then a back up nickel corner.
Expand ...
My Holmes takes were like 90% last season when he was on the field a lot more, so yeah it is a bit of a strawman argument at the moment by you.

Again, I NEVER said that DJ was the sole reason. I have been consistently critical of the defense, especially tackling, as well as the horrid offensive line. But, when I say anything bad about Jones you and Mau act as if I just spit in your face.

Also, that PFF rank is quite the outlier. By virtually every other metric he is with Mac Jones, Zach Wilson and Garoppolo at the bottom of the league.
 
CardiacAndre7 said:
My Holmes takes were like 90% last season when he was on the field a lot more, so yeah it is a bit of a strawman argument at the moment by you.

Again, I NEVER said that DJ was the sole reason. I have been consistently critical of the defense, especially tackling, as well as the horrid offensive line. But, when I say anything bad about Jones you and Mau act as if I just spit in your face.

Also, that PFF rank is quite the outlier. By virtually every other metric he is with Mac Jones, Zach Wilson and Garoppolo at the bottom of the league.
Expand ...
34 out of your 41 posts since the start of the season have been about Jones being bad, only 1 this year on Holmes (good work). So to say you have an agenda and only rant about one thing is pretty accurate.

You even went so far as to post about Sam Howell outta nowhere in an attempt to compare their performances, obviously this was quickly shown to be a horrible take and just a ridiculously poor attempt to prove the oline isn't that big of an issue with this offense. News flash, it is. I'd kill to see Jones with the 13th ranked line, a pro bowl WR, and a running back who actually can stay on the field. He won a playoff game with a heck of a lot less.

I don't care if you like Jones or not but I do take issue with your continued inability to understand that there is a lot more going on with this football team than Jones. Your post about Tyrod was expected and humorous because you probably thought it was accurate.
 
HeGotGame said:
34 out of your 41 posts since the start of the season have been about Jones being bad, only 1 this year on Holmes (good work). So to say you have an agenda and only rant about one thing is pretty accurate.

You even went so far as to post about Sam Howell outta nowhere in an attempt to compare their performances, obviously this was quickly shown to be a horrible take and just a ridiculously poor attempt to prove the oline isn't that big of an issue with this offense. News flash, it is. I'd kill to see Jones with the 13th ranked line, a pro bowl WR, and a running back who actually can stay on the field. He won a playoff game with a heck of a lot less.

I don't care if you like Jones or not but I do take issue with your continued inability to understand that there is a lot more going on with this football team than Jones. Your post about Tyrod was expected and humorous because you probably thought it was accurate.
Expand ...
My god man. You’re saying a lot with no substance and being altogether unethical in the argument. “News flash” LMAO. I have said time and time again the line is atrocious. How can I get that across more? Should I use more adjectives? Terrible, awful, disgusting, abhorrent. There you go.

Don’t change goalposts on the Darnay thing, stick to your guns. You exaggerated hysterically. And 34/41 is in the same boat.

And that 13th rank you’re referring to was before week 4, so certainly seems out of date. Going into the season I saw they were 27th.

I guess you said (not going to look back) almost 3 weeks ago Danny hasn’t played well, then he out up 2 more stinkers. He couldn’t lead 1 scoring drive against a team that gave up 50 to the Bills the week before.

Maybe we’ll see how Tyrod plays this week.
 
CardiacAndre7 said:
My god man. You’re saying a lot with no substance and being altogether unethical in the argument. “News flash” LMAO. I have said time and time again the line is atrocious. How can I get that across more? Should I use more adjectives? Terrible, awful, disgusting, abhorrent. There you go.

Don’t change goalposts on the Darnay thing, stick to your guns. You exaggerated hysterically. And 34/41 is in the same boat.

And that 13th rank you’re referring to was before week 4, so certainly seems out of date. Going into the season I saw they were 27th.

I guess you said (not going to look back) almost 3 weeks ago Danny hasn’t played well, then he out up 2 more stinkers. He couldn’t lead 1 scoring drive against a team that gave up 50 to the Bills the week before.

Maybe we’ll see how Tyrod plays this week.
Expand ...
It's not an exaggeration, you can look for yourself. Again, it's funny you go to Jones on that Miami game and fail to mention Waller's dropped TD, or dropped 3rd down pass, or the running game or anything else but Jones.

Yea, you're right that Washington rank was before week 4. week 5 they gave up ZERO sacks. But sure that preseason rank seems something we should use instead.

Again, the all started with how ridiculously stupid and pointless the Howell take was. And it was. I am glad you seem to at least understand that now.

Just like the people who thought the offense would look better with Glennon in 2021 my guess is you will be equally disappointed with Tyrod.
 
HeGotGame said:
It's not an exaggeration, you can look for yourself. Again, it's funny you go to Jones on that Miami game and fail to mention Waller's dropped TD, or dropped 3rd down pass, or the running game or anything else but Jones.

Yea, you're right that Washington rank was before week 4. week 5 they gave up ZERO sacks. But sure that preseason rank seems something we should use instead.

Again, the all started with how ridiculously stupid and pointless the Howell take was. And it was. I am glad you seem to at least understand that now.

Just like the people who thought the offense would look better with Glennon in 2021 my guess is you will be equally disappointed with Tyrod.
Expand ...
0 offensive touchdowns in the first half of games. You blame everything else besides Jones, boss. You can deflect all you want, that’s terrible.

Is Howell playing better than Jones this year, yes or no? Please answer a single question directly, don’t beat around the bush, don’t bring up their lines or pressure rate. In a vacuum, who has made more winning plays?
 
CardiacAndre7 said:
0 offensive touchdowns in the first half of games. You blame everything else besides Jones, boss. You can deflect all you want, that’s terrible.

Is Howell playing better than Jones this year, yes or no? Please answer a single question directly, don’t beat around the bush, don’t bring up their lines or pressure rate. In a vacuum, who has made more winning plays?
Expand ...
your inability to understand simple posts is truely incredible. Basketball, football, doesn't matter.

And I'll take PFFs rating over yours.

My god my kids have less tunnel vision then you.
 
.-.
HeGotGame said:
your inability to understand simple posts is truely incredible. Basketball, football, doesn't matter.

And I'll take PFFs rating over yours.

My god my kids have less tunnel vision then you.
Expand ...
You still can’t do it, simply amazing. And you resort to being an because you can’t answer a simple question.

All good, enough of this childish back and forth. Go Giants.
 
CardiacAndre7 said:
You still can’t do it, simply amazing. And you resort to being an because you can’t answer a simple question.

All good, enough of this childish back and forth. Go Giants.
Expand ...
If you are too slow to understand or unable to read that I have said jones has been bad than I don't know what to say anymore, he has been. It's not hard to comprehend. That's why I need to resort to being an ass because you're so dense.

Even though he's been bad I will cal out stupidly when I see it as I did with your Howell sack comparison.

And FYI If I could chose an outcome for this season at this point it's 1-16 and get Caleb Williams.
 
HeGotGame said:
If you are too slow to understand or unable to read that I have said jones has been bad than I don't know what to say anymore, he has been. It's not hard to comprehend. That's why I need to resort to being an ass because you're so dense.

Even though he's been bad I will cal out stupidly when I see it as I did with your Howell sack comparison.

And FYI If I could chose an outcome for this season at this point it's 1-16 and get Caleb Williams.
Expand ...
I asked 1 question.
 
CardiacAndre7 said:
Well, we are talking about Jones…So i’m gonna post about him. You haven’t said one negative word about him yet, so I wanted to make sure we were watching the same games.


The Commanders have a terrible O line too. I was equating the play of the QBs behind said lines. Would you say Howell has played better or worse than DJ this season?

Also, i’m confused on if you are defending Darnay? Weird mountain to die on if so.
Expand ...
Howell's OL is not as bad as the Giants', which means a fair number of Howell's sacks are his own fault. He holds the ball too long, doesn't look for the hot outlet enough, and doesn't throw it away enough.

That said, Howell's sacks are not wholly on him alone. Situation dictates as well (i.e. score quarter, down, and yardage).

The defense (with that Dline) was supposed to carry Washington while Howell got his feet wet, but has given up 30 points in 4 of 5 games. If Washington has to play catch-up, they have to reevalute the running game, which means defenses can pin their ears back. This is how a defense (Chicago) that rarely blitzes and had two sacks going into last Thursday, now has seven.

I still can't believe at rotten egg of a performance vs Chicago. The score wasn't as bad, but Denver played better vs Miami, considering expectations vs. outcome.
 
During the 2011 season, Pro Football Focus graded the Giants offensive line dead-last in pass blocking overall.

All Eli did was take home home Super Bowl MVP.
 
Gmen have at least an 8 point advantage based on uni choice alone tonight ... unfortunately, that's not going to be close to enough
 
.-.
Saquon has been terrible but whether that was Tyrod or the coaching that is inexcusable to not come out with points there.
 
Seemed like Tyrod audibled to a run there which is inexcusable. He's looked very good otherwise but that's a huge mistake that can't happen
 
Well bad teams are stupid teams, defense looks very good figured the D would get off to slow start this season but the offense sucks ass. Let’s see how this how this 2nd half goes.
 
.-.
navery12 said:
Seemed like Tyrod audibled to a run there which is inexcusable. He's looked very good otherwise but that's a huge mistake that can't happen
Expand ...
Put it on Daboll, he was being a jackarse with the clock earlier in that drive.
 
Trying to get way too cute. Saquon is gashing their D if he’s too tired you can’t trust Breida to get half a yard?
 
CardiacAndre7 said:
Daboll/Kafka have got to be the 2 dumbest playcallers in the league.
Expand ...
It’s also zero situational awareness and no guts. Hello you have Saquon gashing the Bills run the the football.
 
If Kafka is still calling plays, he should be out of a job yesterday. If it’s Daboll, he needs to sit this out. Genuinely atrocious.
 
.-.
Wasn't expecting Giants to score from the 1 which is sad but that's such a blatant pass interference, you have to call it.
 
Did they say the Giants have gone over 200 minutes without scoring an offense touchdown?
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,543
Messages
4,581,602
Members
10,491
Latest member
7774Forever


Top Bottom