Upon review, Zimmerman did have an angle as the ball was coming across the box. If Zimmerman had gotten a foot on the ball a fraction of a second sooner...Yes, it's a penalty but I don't think it was as egregious. Zimmerman kinda has to go for the ball there which he did.No, no there's not. Maybe a stupid argument it wasn't a penalty. But definitely not a solid argument.
No, no there's not. Maybe a stupid argument it wasn't a penalty. But definitely not a solid argument.
Zimmerman: "The ball gets down to the end line, I see it get cut back and at that point, I’m dropping down and on the way to step out and clear the ball, I don’t see Bale coming across," Zimmerman said after the match. "I think it was one of those where he probably just puts his leg, not for the ball, but to try to get in the way of me hitting the ball. So I kind of went through him and I think I still got the ball, but it was a clever move. I wish I would have seen him out of the corner of my eye when trying to clear the ball, but it was instinctive. It was quick. And I’m a little bit frustrated by that. But sometimes those plays happen."
It wasn't so much a bait as a flop. But there sure are plenty of world class floppers in these games.This is correct. An MLS guy gets baited by a world class player. That's why it's good to have world class players.
We all knew Bale was going to be a deciding factor for Wales and a bad match up for Zimmerman and Ream.
It's disappointing, not shocking.
This is correct. An MLS guy gets baited by a world class player. That's why it's good to have world class players.
We all knew Bale was going to be a deciding factor for Wales and a bad match up for Zimmerman and Ream.
It's disappointing, not shocking.
Is first to the ball relevant here? He took Bale out.Zimmerman was actually first to the ball but Bale slid across and his leg came over the top of Zimmerman's. I think Zimmerman got jobbed.
View attachment 81014
I thought it was marginal. I agree with Cobi Jones. Would've been a weak PK, legs got tangled.What a massive bummer for Canada. Really outplayed Belgium in almost all facets but scoring. The early missed PK was a killer.
Also mystified at how that VAR review late in the first half did not result in a PK. Replay showed clear trip by defender.
Yes, but that's a penaltyZimmerman: "The ball gets down to the end line, I see it get cut back and at that point, I’m dropping down and on the way to step out and clear the ball, I don’t see Bale coming across," Zimmerman said after the match. "I think it was one of those where he probably just puts his leg, not for the ball, but to try to get in the way of me hitting the ball. So I kind of went through him and I think I still got the ball, but it was a clever move. I wish I would have seen him out of the corner of my eye when trying to clear the ball, but it was instinctive. It was quick. And I’m a little bit frustrated by that. But sometimes those plays happen."
Zimmerman went through Bale without playing the ball, or to play the ball. Doesn't really matter you can't slide through another player. It's a clear penalty and should have been top of mind to an experienced defender.Is first to the ball relevant here? He took Bale out.
I think it is. He actually kicked the ball. The fact that Bale decided to flop on Zimmerman's leg as Zimmerman is kicking the ball shouldn't result in penalty. What do they expect him to do, defy the laws of physics and freeze instantaneously?Is first to the ball relevant here? He took Bale out.
Oooph. That was an awful call. I'll bet Shane Battier is proud.Yes, but that's a penalty
Reminds me a little of Koulibaly's foul on Messi in Champions League. It resulted in a PK. KK had his head down about to clear the ball when Messi ran to his side and dropped his leg in front of the ball. Koulibaly contacts his leg, and Messi goes down. PK
It's universally considered a PK though and there are plenty examples of it. You have to stay clear of contact. Not to mention Zimmerman came through Bale. This is why i say getting to the ball is irrelevant when you go through another player. He took him out.I think it is. He actually kicked the ball. The fact that Bale decided to flop on Zimmerman's leg as Zimmerman is kicking the ball shouldn't result in penalty. What do they expect him to do, defy the laws of physics and freeze instantaneously?
Oooph. That was an awful call. I'll bet Shane Battier is proud.
This is my biggest issue. There are times when the defender has little choice but to chance a risky tackle. This was not one of those times. Should've just played it straight up. It's the decision making that was fatal here.Zimmerman got caught out and made a reaction play that he should have had the good sense not to make. Even if Bale gets the ball cleanly, he still has options to block or prevent a scoring chance.
It's an extremely fast game. I watch the video and I see Bale flopping. I understand the way the players play the game and that plays a large part as to why many Americans hate the game. Far too much crying and writhing on the ground. If someone like Bales chooses to initiate contact, I prefer "play on." Not gonna happen, but that's my take.It's universally considered a PK though and there are plenty examples of it. You have to stay clear of contact. Not to mention Zimmerman came through Bale. This is why i say getting to the ball is irrelevant when you go through another player. He took him out.