As many have mentioned, there is some uncertainty regarding how much of a contribution some players will make, and most agree that the talent and potential is there. As much as we follow every development, watch games, and the videos on new recruits, we have to remember that Geno has seen and knows so much more.
I don't know for example how well Aubrey is progressing, because very little information has been given, but I bet Geno has a pretty good idea. With Amari I know she was pretty highly rated, and got too little playing time for me to make much of a judgement, but Geno saw her everyday in practice. He knows what her strengths and weaknesses are, what she needs to work on, and will follow her progress on those this summer.
For us, Amari is still largely untested like the incoming freshmen. Certainly her lack of playing time is not a positive sign, but hardly conclusive that she is a miss. Geno has made some positive comments about her being very skilled. One of the male practice players thought she was a great shooter and under the radar a bit. But if I remember, right Geno also questioned a lack of speed in her movements, and perhaps some other things, so to me it is a very mixed and inconclusive track record. Perhaps slightly reduced expectations compared to her coming in as a freshmen, but not by much.