You're talking about, at the very least, four different issues.
- Talent identification
- Talent acquisition
- Talent retention
- Talent development
All four can be filed under "recruiting" if you want a discussion that lacks for nuance. If you want something a little deeper, though, you can break the recruiting process up into its constituent parts and see some areas in which KO & staff have been pretty good (talent ID), and others in which they've been not so good (talent development especially).
Here are our incoming players by year (note that I consider transfers to be functionally part of the class during which they played their first season at the school) under KO:
2013-14: Kentan (4-star), Samuel (high 3-star), Brimah (3-star), Kromah (highly regarded grad transfer)
- Not a great class, but one that had three guys contribute meaningfully to a national champion. None really lived up to their long-term potential, though.
2014-15: Hamilton (5-star), Purvis (5-star transfer), Sam Cassell (high-3-star JuCo transfer), Lubin (2-star)
- There are as many 5-stars in this class as the rest of the AAC has had, combined, in its existence. One left after two years even though he was about to be handed the keys to the program, and the other freely admits he underachieved in college. For some reason.
2015-16: Adams (borderline 5-star), Enoch (4-star), Miller (highly sought-after grad transfer), Gibbs (highly sought-after grad transfer)
- Miller & Gibbs were two of the three most-recruited grad transfers that spring. Adams was a top 30 player, and Enoch top 80. This is probably the best recruiting class any AAC team has had even though we missed on two guys (Abdul-Malik Abu & Bonzie Colson) we should've locked in.
Nonetheless, Miller & Gibbs were good in their year here. Enoch never developed and transferred after two years, and Adams has not progressed as hoped.
2016-17: Gilbert (borderline 5-star), Durham (high 4-star), Jackson (4-star), Diarra (low-4/high-3 star depending on service you use), Vital (high 3-star), Larrier (high-4-star transfer)
- Or maybe this is the best incoming class in conference? Consensus top 10 nationally, but Durham & Jackson both transferred, Larrier, Gilbert & Diarra have nursed injuries, while Vital has been destructively inconsistent. Bad luck for sure, but it also seems like a theme is developing with regard to player development and retention.
Very good teams want the guys who are leaving UConn. Is that a talent issue or a development issue?
2017-18: Carlton (high 3-star), Polley (high 3-star), Whaley (3-star), Cobb (JuCo), Williams (JuCo), Anderson (grad transfer), Onuorah (grad transfer)
- None of these guys were particularly high-rated, and a few of them were clear "oh crap, we had a bunch of transfers this spring." As a class it's not up to the quality of previous UConn classes under either Ollie or Calhoun, but in comparison to the rest of the AAC it's above average.
2018-19: Wilson (4-star), Akinjo (4-star), Kisunas (high 3-star), Matthews (high 3-star)
- This is not a "great" class in the sense that 2016/17 should've been, but it's exactly the type of class that could/should be the lifeblood of a program looking to re-establish itself as a second-weekend/top 25 team: three pretty clear 4-year players, including one (Matthews) with big "sleeper" potential because of his length and shooting, and one guy at the top of the class (Wilson) who has raw athletic talent just waiting to be harnessed.
If UConn gets classes like this each of the next 5 seasons, we should have no problem climbing up to the top of the AAC. But we had classes better than this in 2014, 2015 & 2016, and here we are just waiting for WSU, Cincy, SMU and Temple to drop the hammer.
So if superior talent acquisition leads to results like this, what does that tell you about how we got here? And what does it tell you about where we're headed?
----------------------------
"Recruiting" has not been the issue(*), and will continue to not be the issue regardless of who the head coach is. The issue is making the guys we're able to land 1) play like a team, and 2) better as individuals. Both those are issues with talent development, and are compounded by our catastrophic issues with talent retention (Jackson, Durham, Enoch, MAL, Ali, Jackson, arguably Abu, Diallo and Mathis as well).
(*)Of course our recruiting hasn't been good enough to make us a top-10 team, but we're not freaking out b/c we can't break into the top 10. We're freaking out because we're about to have back-to-back losing seasons for the first time in 30 years. There's no reason, given our recruiting over the last 4 seasons, that should be the case.