The Official 2024 NY Giants Thread

[navery12]

I'm very curious as to why Daboll is so opposed to extra points.

The math says you go for 2 when scoring down 14 because it increases your chance to win. 2 point conversion odds are above 50%, so theoretically you're slightly more likely than not to convert the first one, and then you only need 1 more TD to win instead of 2 scores. If you don't convert the first 2 point conversion its still more likely than not to convert the 2nd attempt.

That said I think it's safe to say at this point that the Giants offense is not good enough to convert on their 2 point attempts, and they should just be kicking the extra point

 

[husky8273]

Barkley 2nd leading rusher in the NFL.

 

[Husky25]

Defense is actually so sad to watch rn

I was about to say that, for once, the $40 million dollar beneficiary didn't have a major hand in losing the game for the Giants. Then I recalled that his fumble in the 1st quarter led directly to 7 points for the Commanders, and was pretty much the scoring difference in the game. Kudos to the Commanders who played through the whistle on a possible turnover.

Neither defense was lights out, but the Commanders were better in spots where they needed to be. Credit to the Giants for make adjustments and only allowing 6 points in the 2nd half, but they dug quite the hole in the 1st half helped by the PI right after the turnover, and allowing Washington to convert the 3rd and Mile on the drive right before halftime. Both lapses led to touchdowns.

The question about kicking is a good one. The 1st XP (33 yards) and 31 yd FG notwithstanding, the only thing I can think of is that the Giants don't have much faith in their 3rd kicker of the season. I would have also thought they would have called for an onside kick with 2:48 to go. It didn't make sense to me to go for 2 at 24-16, but because they did, why not run it? The Giants were gashing Washington's run defense all afternoon. In both instances, they called for passes on both attempts. At least the Giants didn't give up a TD on the ensuing possession, which would have ended the game for all intents and purposes. OTOH, the field goal didn't really make it it any easier.

 

[Husky25]

The Commanders just acquired Marshon Lattimer from the Saints. They gave up some assets but now have a 4x Pro Bowler under their control for 2 more seasons after this one. He's going to make $16M per, so I wouldn't be surprised if the restructure and extend him. On the other hand he'll be in his early 30s by the end of his current deal.

This is huge with all 4 games left with Philly and Dallas. Washington has affirmed their intentions to stay atop the NFC East.

it's amazing how a toxic culture can kill a franchise and how a simple change at the very top can affect it.

 

[CardiacAndre7]

It’s genuinely funny how bad this guy is and how much money we wasted on him. Man oh man.

 

[navery12]

That should be Daniel Jones last snap of the season. I'm sure it won't be though

 

[Scoe]

10-0 it's over does anyone even care anymore. Tank for Joe Fagnano.

 

[Scoe]

That should be Daniel Jones last snap of the season. I'm sure it won't be though

Shouldn't you play him at this point to be the tank commander.

 

[navery12]

Shouldn't you play him at this point to be the tank commander.

Drew Lock is more than capable of losing every game the rest of the season. Jones will manage to get hurt and cost the Giants $23M in cap space next year if he plays

 

[CardiacAndre7]

Dude sit this guy on the bench for the rest of the season oh my god. I’m a Daboll supporter but he should be canned if he keeps trotting this guy out there.

 

[husky8273]

It’s genuinely funny how bad this guy is and how much money we wasted on him. Man oh man.

not funny

 

[Scoe]

Thank god for UConn basketball and yes thank god for UConn football as well.

 

[FfldCntyFan]

Fortunately for Jones, the pathetic QB play has company in things to be furious about with the moronic play calling and inept defense.

I call it the trifecta.

 

[navery12]

Fortunately for Jones, the pathetic QB play has company in things to be furious about with the moronic play calling and inept defense.

I call it the trifecta.

What was the moronic play calling today? I feel like Daboll's calls have been good so far today

 

[husky8273]

if only passes that hit your hands would be caught

 

[FfldCntyFan]

What was the moronic play calling today? I feel like Daboll's calls have been good so far today

That comment was more for the past two seasons in general but I'll start with the flea ficker on third and one.

The Malik Nabors sweep (after he was in the tent) when they had second and five at Carolina's six and were running effectively between the tackles could easily be called into question. but that occurred after my post.

I hate the idea of continually changing coaching staffs (which we've been doing for nearly a decade) but we do need to clean house here (including Schoen).

The worst part is we may be in position to draft one of the top QB's next spring but I'm not sure the available QB's are worth drafting.

 

[navery12]

That comment was more for the past two seasons in general but I'll start with the flea ficker on third and one.

The Malik Nabors sweep (after he was in the tent) when they had second and five at Carolina's six and were running effectively between the tackles could easily be called into question. but that occurred after my post.

I hate the idea of continually changing coaching staffs (which we've been doing for nearly a decade) but we do need to clean house here (including Schoen).

The worst part is we may be in position to draft one of the top QB's next spring but I'm not sure the available QB's are worth drafting.

The flea flicker is all on Daniel Jones. He had 2 wide open wide receivers, one of whom was Wan'Dale Robinson who would have walked in for a TD. No issue with the play call, especially when it's obvious the plan was to go for it on 4th down if Jones doesn't take a sack.

I won't be mad if they move on from Daboll, but it would be a dumb and shortsighted move. He deserves a chance to coach this team with a real QB

 

[AzHusky]

During the end of the game the question was asked if they stop selling beer and the answer is no they don't you can even purchase beer as you are leaving the studium.

 

[Scoe]

Was just gonna talk about how much I like Tracy then he fumbles but the more I think about I like him even more he's in on the tank job. I hate thinking of tanking it's a weird feeling but I just can't help it.

 

[FfldCntyFan]

The flea flicker is all on Daniel Jones. He had 2 wide open wide receivers, one of whom was Wan'Dale Robinson who would have walked in for a TD. No issue with the play call, especially when it's obvious the plan was to go for it on 4th down if Jones doesn't take a sack.

I won't be mad if they move on from Daboll, but it would be a dumb and shortsighted move. He deserves a chance to coach this team with a real QB

Year one I thought Daboll was great. A team that should have struggled to reach .500 made the playoffs (and won a road playoff game, no small feat) primarily because he never tried to do things the team (or any individual players) weren't capable of doing. It seems that once the final gun went off in the playoff loss in Philly, his approach has been "I'm calling the game as if we have weapons at WR, a high quality offensive line and a start QB" even though shy of the games Nabors has played this season, they have had none of any of those things.

If the spirit moves me I'll elaborate in detail, but in short, he seldom does anything to protect the team's weaknesses (primarily pass blocking), in fact he calls plays that requires strengths where the weaknesses are are throws his clipboard in a fit of rage when the play unfolds as anyone (other than him) would expect.

 

[navery12]

Year one I thought Daboll was great. A team that should have struggled to reach .500 made the playoffs (and won a road playoff game, no small feat) primarily because he never tried to do things the team (or any individual players) weren't capable of doing. It seems that once the final gun went off in the playoff loss in Philly, his approach has been "I'm calling the game as if we have weapons at WR, a high quality offensive line and a start QB" even though shy of the games Nabors has played this season, they have had none of any of those things.

If the spirit moves me I'll elaborate in detail, but in short, he seldom does anything to protect the team's weaknesses (primarily pass blocking), in fact he calls plays that requires strengths where the weaknesses are are throws his clipboard in a fit of rage when the play unfolds as anyone (other than him) would expect.

Couldn't disagree more. There's a reason why he never calls anything more than 5 yard passes. I think you're just wildly off base with everything you think you're seeing

 

[navery12]

 

[Husky25]

Drew Lock is more than capable of losing every game the rest of the season. Jones will manage to get hurt and cost the Giants $23M in cap space next year if he plays

I do not root for injury, but this would be poetic.

It’s genuinely funny how bad this guy is and how much money we wasted on him. Man oh man.

What about that playoff win?

 

[husky8273]

What about that playoff win?

1 since 2011. not as bad as '63-'81 but getting close.

 

[FfldCntyFan]

Couldn't disagree more. There's a reason why he never calls anything more than 5 yard passes. I think you're just wildly off base with everything you think you're seeing

Likewise.

I'll stop now as I have no desire to escalate this.