However true or not, what made you think it was overall helpful to add an uncomplimentary comment on CV to your complimentary assessment of Tarin Smith?
I didn't think it was uncomplimentary of CV. To say that the other aspects of his game are strong enough to give him a chance at the NBA is not an insult, but a compliment. To say a person has things he needs to work on to reach his goals is not an insult either, it is an observation.
Tarin Smith is an example of CV's competition for a limited number of NBA slots and the scouts compare them and similar players against one other. Both Tarin and Christian are 6'2", 185 lb -- they are both NBA point guard stature. Who would be drafted first, if the draft were long enough to take both? Probably Tarin.
I'm guessing if I put the Tarin Smith sentence in this thread and the CV sentence in the CV declares for the draft thread, you'd think it was fine. But since I'm comparing the two, as a scout would, the two sentences belong in the same post. In this case, the architecture of a message board may not be compatible with your sense of manners.