Official Start Boyle Based on Overinterpreting Garbage Time Thread | The Boneyard

Official Start Boyle Based on Overinterpreting Garbage Time Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree, but would like to see Boyle get more than one series when it means something. He is our quarterback going forward more than likely.
 
Those last two throws were pro throws. Whitmer's arm just isn't as strong, but he is the leader of the offense right now
 
.-.
jbdphi said:
I think if Boyle handed the ball off to Newsome in the 1st quarter, Arkeel wouldn't have fumbled it.
Expand ...
Haha. What if it was Johnnie Selvie?
 
Jax Husky said:
Well, I'd start Boyle but for reasons different than his performance today.
Expand ...

If Boyle can get the offensive line to block for him, I'd be all for him starting.
 
Tommyboy said:
I would rather lose with someone who might get better down the road. Whitmer provides nothing.
Expand ...
I don't think Whitmer will be the starter for the rest of season. But to my eyes he looked better today than he did weeks 1 + 2. He looked good enough to play against at least some of our AAC foes.
 
.-.
junglehusky said:
I don't think Whitmer will be the starter for the rest of season. But to my eyes he looked better today than he did weeks 1 + 2. He looked good enough to play against at least some of our AAC foes.
Expand ...

Whitmer actually looked fine today. Boyle was okay in that last series but we did not lose this game because of Whitmer.
 
junglehusky said:
I don't think Whitmer will be the starter for the rest of season. But to my eyes he looked better today than he did weeks 1 + 2. He looked good enough to play against at least some of our AAC foes.
Expand ...


And what does that do for the program?
 
junglehusky said:
I don't think Whitmer will be the starter for the rest of season. But to my eyes he looked better today than he did weeks 1 + 2. He looked good enough to play against at least some of our AAC foes.
Expand ...

He definitely looked better but he is still too quick To Bail out of the play. Would be ok if he was fast but he isn't. Toss in the weak arm and the backbreaking Ints and it's tough to watch.
 
Garbage time or not, he looked good. He looked like he deserves more snaps. Whitmer was better than uusual but he proved once again that he is not good enough to carry an offense with an inexperienced line and stone handed WRs
 
LRock34 said:
Garbage time or not, he looked good. He looked like he deserves more snaps. Whitmer was better than uusual but he proved once again that he is not good enough to carry an offense with an inexperienced line and stone handed WRs
Expand ...

He does have a great arm. He did do while Boise dominating Dline was on the bench.

I would like to see him continue to get a couple of series a game.
 
Bill Sussman said:
Whitmer actually looked fine today. Boyle was okay in that last series but we did not lose this game because of Whitmer.
Expand ...


Not by a long stretch. Whitmer is not responsible for more than 1 sack. Can't replace the OLine though. Whitmer has yet to prove that he can get through a game without a couple TOs though, so from that standpoint, there's not much upside unless Boyle just isn't going to ever start here. I don't think that's the case though. He did, at least, look a little composed today. Let's see if he's made a leap from last year.
 
.-.
I thought Boyle looked good last year for the first half-dozen plays ... and then he didn't.

This is a process. He will get more snaps and more opportunity. If we win in the coming weeks with Whitmer, we will keep going that way (with some Boyle). If we play flat (AND Boyle shows more leadership), maybe we see Boyle for the next 3 years.
 
Jax Husky said:
And what does that do for the program?
Expand ...

If our defense continues what it's been able to do for the past 10 quarters, I think this team can win some games in conference play (plus Army) and make a run at a bowl bid. That's kind of important.

Boyle saw one series with actual defense being played and had a three and out. I have no problem with him getting meaningful snaps in the future like that and if he is able to sustain drives then I'm all for him getting more play but as the OP sarcastically implied, reading too much into the last series is just too easy.
 
Whitmer gave it his best shot. But that pick when we were coming off the stop killed us. It was everything bad about Whitmer all balled together in one play. He has to be the #2 for the rest of the year.
 
junglehusky said:
might as well get this thread up.
Expand ...

This is how I see it. Is Boyle better than whitmer... Who knows. Was it garbage time? Yes. But Boyle looked competent ... I like his arm. This team is growing learning. Boyles redshirt is gone ....since it's gone might as well use him and let him grow and learn in live games .... At this point I see more positives than negatives working Boyle towards a starting role.
 
Palatine said:
Official receivers let Boyle down again thread is more like it. He cant throw it and catch it.
Expand ...

I was watching as a walked out. The drops by Thomas and Bradley were brutal. Both hit the receiver on the number in the chest, both right in the hands. Perfect touch pass to the front corner of the end zone by Boyle as well. Just sad. They were in this game the whole way. Again turnovers just killed em.
 
If they're going to continue to lose and drop passes on offense move forward with Boyle. The experience is huge going into next season.
 
.-.
I didn't watch Boyle play, but I think I've been watching Whitmer for most of the last 4 seasons

I'm not really sure what more needs to be said
 
It blows my mind how they don't block up front but catch the ball for Whitmer and do the total opposite for Boyle.
 
Ok guys I'm new here. So be gentile. I'm gonna give you one reason why he shouldn't get a lot of reps this year. It has been mentioned a few times in different threads. The O line. He is our quarterback of the future. Of the 3 quarterbacks he has the most raw talent. You don't want to get him killed or a string of concussions before the oline and the rest of the team has a chance to mature and get better. Let him watch and learn and get the occasional snap.
 
Waquoit said:
Whitmer gave it his best shot. But that pick when we were coming off the stop killed us. It was everything bad about Whitmer all balled together in one play. He has to be the #2 for the rest of the year.
Expand ...

this, every big spot, this

a turnover machine that doesn't make quick reads and gets sacked for too much because of such

he pulls down the ball and tries to run and he can't run, it's just a bad combination, it just doesn't work

I'm really surprised there are so many defenders still 30 or 40 games later, we saw what somebody else can do when he was benched last year

I'm resigned to giving Diaco time to build his program
 
gmc1055 said:
Ok guys I'm new here. So be gentile. I'm gonna give you one reason why he shouldn't get a lot of reps this year. It has been mentioned a few times in different threads. The O line. He is our quarterback of the future. Of the 3 quarterbacks he has the most raw talent. You don't want to get him killed or a string of concussions before the oline and the rest of the team has a chance to mature and get better. Let him watch and learn and get the occasional snap.
Expand ...

You really are new here, your post posted about 6 times.
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,409
Messages
4,571,765
Members
10,477
Latest member
Goose91


Top Bottom