Part of me actually finds it refreshing that an organization would so quickly realize they misread a situation completely and then go the opposite way by trading away pieces and rebuilding. It's important that the Giants finally realized this was the case.
What I have an issue is that the same guy who so badly misread the situation, is the same guy we're entrusting the next decade of our franchise to?
Since we can't change the past, I would do the following:
1) Trade the 2nd round pick for Rosen. I pretty much think most young QBs are a toss up, but we need to hitch our wagon to one of them. Sticking with Eli just delays the inevitable.
2) Take a pass rusher at #6, and then BPA with the other first round pick, be it a OL, EDGE, or CB.
3) Go crazy with the 1829 picks we have and take primarily defensive players.
I'd do that - but I have no faith in Gettleman, Mara or Shurmur to execute.