Odell to Cleveland | Page 10 | The Boneyard

Odell to Cleveland

ConnHuskBask said:
Sorry, let me clarify, I'm not despondent over a professional athletes feelings. I just appreciate his legacy here.

Better?
Expand ...

I wasn't suggesting you were being melodramatic. I *am* despondent -- over the direction this team has gone in. I'm 10000000x more bummed out about the state of the program than I an concerned about the most overpaid player in the NFL.
 
intlzncster said:
Then why bother paying all these people if it's so easy?

Fact is, some guys are better at it than others, and that edge is what it takes to win in the NFL, because the margins are so small.

So your job, as an owner, is to hire the best guy--a guy who's better than you--and let them do their thing.

It's a really weird take to justify owners making personnel decisions ESPECIALLY in the the salary cap era. Figuring out how to manage the cap going forward, while replenishing/stocking piling talent, picks etc, is a science in and of itself.
Expand ...
Don’t be so black and white on this issue. Lots of owners meddle lightly on personnel. Little here and there....especially in football.
 
Exit 4 said:
Don’t be so black and white on this issue. Lots of owners meddle lightly on personnel. Little here and there....especially in football.
Expand ...
Lots of owners will weigh in on personnel decisions, but 90% of successful franchises don't have owners making the personnel decisions. If I'm Gettleman and he walks in and tells me to trade OBJ I'm telling him to take a walk and step back
 
navery12 said:
Lots of owners will weigh in on personnel decisions, but 90% of successful franchises don't have owners making the personnel decisions. If I'm Gettleman and he walks in and tells me to trade OBJ I'm telling him to take a walk and step back
Expand ...
And then you are fired. Guys, this world is far more nuisanced.
 
huskysupporter said:
Can’t believe they are going to pay Eli his roster bonus. They need to release him and take the cap hit this year. Win 2 games and draft Tua or Fromm.
Expand ...
It might be hard to out tank Miami this year. They are going all in for Tua. I'm not sure Fromm is going to end up being the uber prospect some people think he will be. Mediocre arm, below average athlete, and I'm betting he measures shorter than his height is listed....not that it means what it used to. Not sure his NFL ceiling is that high. I was actually wondering at times if Georgia should be playing Justin Fields over him at times this year. Fields has a much higher ceiling if it all comes together for him. I guess we will see how he does at Ohio St this year. Maybe the Giants keep Eli this year and the go full tank the following year for the real prize...Trevor Lawrence. Hell, half the league may tank for him so there will be competition to tank for Trevor.
 
.-.
JohnFSilver said:
I get that’s what people think, but no ceo is ever going to act like that. Owners are always involved. And as far as Giants, the Mara’s know football and only started the giants in the 1920s.

Think about how crazy this situation is. After 95 years of football, people are taking the side of a wide receiver over the owner.
Expand ...

The owners are involved. That’s why the team stinks out loud.

At least Dallas stinks for the same reason.
 
Exit 4 said:
Don’t be so black and white on this issue. Lots of owners meddle lightly on personnel. Little here and there....especially in football.
Expand ...

I know owners meddle. To their detriment. And for the record, I'm not talking about owners not wanting to sign types of guys who beat their wives or something. I get GMs going to an owner and asking if it's OK to sign this/that guy based on real character concerns or what have you.

Now take a guy like Kraft for example. He really didn't become a good owner until he learned to step back*. I remember when he forced Parcells to draft Terry Glenn (which was an awful call) and that led to Parcells' famous "shop for the groceries" press conference. Parcells soon left.

One of the conditions Belichick had before he was hired was that he wanted complete control of personnel/football decisions--and this was before Belichick became Belichick. Learning from his past mistakes, Kraft gave it to him.

Kraft's advice to every new owner in the NFL now is to hire the best people, and get out of their way.

You can look at a number of the crappy franchises in sports and they often have a meddlesome owner. Knicks and Jets come to mind quite quickly. (NB: I consider baseball a bit different given no cap)

Owners who like to 'make a splash' in free agency are an albatross to a team.

*if only he had someone to organize his personal life
 
Last edited:
JohnFSilver said:
I don’t have sources. I am just being a message board savage. But, tell me who wrote that and I will tell you if it is Stop or not. When it was written is an issue too.

Obviously, we all know Tisch family likes the marketing of Odell etc. it’s the Mara’s that are the football people.

Odell is legitimately great. I love the talent. Hard to give that up. But old Giants fans like me have seen them win 4 Super Bowls and plenty of playoff appearances.

People act like Odell was their best talent. I think Barkley is best talent, and best back I saw in college since Barry Sanders. So, that might be just me jumping on the bandwagon.

They had LT and Strahan and plaxico and a young Eli. They have had plenty of superstars.

They will have stars again. Beckham is 5 years left in his career at this level. I think the giants will survive.

Get a QB, a pass rusher and I would like an OT that starts at RT and moves to LT when we cut Solder.
Expand ...
I've never heard one person say Odell is the best talent the Giants have ever had. They had LT for crissakes the best football player ever to strap on pads, IMO.

Odell is the best wideout they ever had.

There is no way around this being a terrible move and the Giants being horribly mismanaged for years now, so you can stop twisting yourself in a pretzel.
 
navery12 said:
How many star players does Gettleman have to drive away as a GM before he stops getting a pass? We're at at least 4 already, does he need to get to 5?
Expand ...
The Giants only have one more “star player” and he’ll be worn out and worthless in three years. Sad times to be a Giants fan.
 
Exit 4 said:
And then you are fired. Guys, this world is far more nuisanced.
Expand ...
That's my point, I'm not working for an owner who's telling me who stays and who goes. Maybe it's because I've seen decades of it fail as a Knicks fan, but it's just not a formula that works
 
.-.
navery12 said:
That's my point, I'm not working for an owner who's telling me who stays and who goes. Maybe it's because I've seen decades of it fail as a Knicks fan, but it's just not a formula that works
Expand ...
The Knicks are an extreme example of what can go wrong. Lots of other organizations have owners involved with a light touch and are not nearly as disasterous. Of course owners should remain as removed as possible, but there are very few that really can and will stay completely out of the way.... especially in football.

And it’s easy to take a hard line on this issue now, but I am rather certain in most circumstances a GM would not. GM jobs don’t fall out of the sky.
 
Exit 4 said:
The Knicks are an extreme example of what can go wrong. Lots of other organizations have owners involved with a light touch and are not nearly as disasterous. Of course owners should remain as removed as possible, but there are very few that really can and will stay completely out of the way.... especially in football.

And it’s easy to take a hard line on this issue now, but I am rather certain in most circumstances a GM would not. GM jobs don’t fall out of the sky.
Expand ...
I think we mostly agree on this, I don't have a problem with an owner being involved and in the room for discussions. I just don't like an owner saying this guy stays, this guy goes.
 
This is a good smart trade and any Giants fan should be on board with it. Add in the Vernon Trade, and we got two quality starters(and Jabrill has all-pro upside) that play every game and will upgrade their positions significantly. We also got a 1st and a 3rd that will be part of the foundation of our team moving forward, giving us 5 picks in the first 3 rounds of a very good draft.

I loved Odell, and we'll always have 'the catch' in Dallas, but he was unreliable due to injury and his persona. Also no one likes mentioning it but he had some big drops the last couple years. Honestly, he doesn't belong on a crappy team and we don't need him to rebuild our team.

You can quibble about the mechanics of it, or previous decisions by Gettleman, but this seems like a pretty strait forward win.
 
They gotta get a QB and bite the rebuild bullet. They aren’t good enough on defense to have a 38 year old QB.

Rebuilt offensive line and RB with a good TE and Shepherd is A decent WR on offense. But not dynamic with no Odell and short with depth at WR.

Makes little sense to keep Eli in this scenario. They are going to be bad anyway. Especially on defense.
 
Well all signs point to Eli staying for 2019...at least that is what most media insiders seem to think. The Giants save 5MM by cutting him, but I dont think there are enough available free agents of interest to Gettleman to find a use for the savings..so what's the point. And I am not saying I agree with that POV, just reading the tea leaves about how the Giants seem to be approaching free agency.

The real debate that has to be raging in the front office at this time is how hard to go after Josh Rosen.
 
Last edited:
.-.
Exit 4 said:
Well all signs point to Eli staying for 2019...at least that is what most media insiders seem to think. The Giants save 5MM by cutting him, but I dont think their are enough available free agents of interest to Gettleman to find a use for the savings..so what's the point. And I am not saying I agree with that POV, just reading the tea leaves about how the Giants seem to be approaching free agency.

The real debate that has to be raging in the front office at this time is how hard to go after Josh Rosen.
Expand ...

Problem with Eli is he will probably lead them to 5-11 - 6-10 again.

I like to win, but they aren’t a playoff team around Eli. To me, getting rid of Odell should mean no more Eli.

You can’t throw Eli out there with only a RB and TE and a suspect right side of the OL.
 
.-.
Their 3 best receivers now all belong in the slot. I get wanting to spend money but it just doesn't seem to fit a plan.

Also FWIW this possibly reduces a 3rd round comp for Collins
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,498
Messages
4,578,855
Members
10,489
Latest member
Djw06001


Top Bottom