Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 2h2 hours ago
I don't think it's realistic for Big 12 to expand by more than 2. Presidents tend to want bare minimum movement.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 2h2 hours ago
We should assume that there are 2 spots in the Big 12 at most and that will be it for P5 expansion for a generation.
Mickey Scott@mickwithtwins
@frankthetank111 @SIPeteThamel could XII add 4 teams and see TV value? UC SDST BYU & BSU? Adds markets and brands.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
In theory, yes, but if you're on outside looking in, you hope for Big 12 expansion by 4 or 6. Not realistic, though.
Randall.@JRC_
@frankthetank111 Big question is: Are B12's expansion options (i.e., BYU, Cincy, Memphis, etc.) palatable to Texas or OU?
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
That's the billion dollar question. OU has been more publicly open to expansion. Texas has many diverging interests
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Maximizing short-term revenue for UT and OU = no Big 12 expansion. Long-term league stability = Big 12 expansion.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Notre Dame will not be shut out of the playoffs for not being in a conference. Popular thought, but simply untrue.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Neither the Big Ten nor SEC want *anything* to do with ND joining the ACC and empowering a direct geographic rival.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
One of my pet peeves in realignment talk is the thought of Notre Dame being "forced" to join a league. It's completely untrue.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
No conference wants Notre Dame to join *a* league. They want ND to join *their* league. Otherwise, they want ND to stay independent.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
It's a disadvantage in the same way that the Big 12 is at a disadvantage w/o a CCG. It's not a concrete wall, though
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Plus, I deal with a lot of Domers. Independence is a *mentality* for them beyond TV money. No reasoning with them.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
OU would leave for B1G, SEC or Pac-12 in a heartbeat and they'd all invite OU *alone*. Issue is tie to Oklahoma St.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Unless there is an actual structural rule that you HAVE to be a conference champ to make the playoff, Notre Dame is NOT joining a league.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Low probability of not making the playoff does not cut it with ND's alums re: independence. They have to have a 0% chance by rule to change.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
As I've explained, a rule locking out independents from the playoff won't occur b/c both B1G and SEC do NOT want ND joining the ACC.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
I deal with Domers everyday. Independence is NOT about football. It's a school *identity*. They are insane about it.
Michael DeCourcy@tsnmike
@frankthetank111 Also, would be in courts 5 minutes after rule passed
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
Exactly. Making CFP access for independents and G5 really difficult is one thing. Closing access entirely is another
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 1h1 hour ago
I think the ACC has solid ties. No poaching power like B1G and SEC, but schools genuinely like ACC (unlike Big 12).
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 59m59 minutes ago
As a B1G guy, I'd love to see UVA, UNC, GT & FSU jump here. It's just a lot tougher to poach ACC compared to Big 12.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 57m57 minutes ago
FWIW, I think UVA would be most realistic target for B1G from ACC. UNC harder to poach b/c of Texas-like influence.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 54m54 minutes ago
It's a catch-22. ACC only dies if UNC leaves, but UNC won't leave unless the ACC is dead.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 53m53 minutes ago
Duke is *extremely* valuable. B1G and SEC would take UNC/Duke combo immediately. Not the same as OU/OSU.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 52m52 minutes ago
In fact, both the B1G and SEC would take Duke by itself. Duke basketball is what ND FB was for prior generations.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 50m50 minutes ago
Hoops matter very little (and I say that as a hoops guy), but UNC and Duke are 2 schools that are key in that front.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 50m50 minutes ago
From B1G view, getting into North Carolina is big for football for long-term demographic growth and recruiting.
Colby Moorberg@ColbyDigsSoil
@frankthetank111 @BunkerF16 You underestimate the impact the NC congress would have if UNC would try to leave the same conference as NCSU.
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 49m49 minutes ago
Oh, I personally don't think UNC is moving from ACC at all. Texas is much more likely to leave Big 12 by comparison.
BunkerF16@BunkerF16
@frankthetank111 No way B1G takes Duke by itself....CBB nowhere near $$ CFB is..I can see UNC/Duke, B1G would rather UNC and GT (ATL market)
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 47m47 minutes ago
If the Big Ten would take Rutgers for a TV market, they would take Duke for *many* reasons. Not a doubt in my mind.
NC@JabbsNNJ
What are the reasons?
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 32m32 minutes ago
Elite academics, #1 national TV hoops draw, large state delivered for BTN, great recruiting area for both FB and BB
tuart Waugh@sg2waugh
@frankthetank111 Can't see Duke being first ACC school to move. Somebody else has to break the seal. B1G/SEC must pick another strategically
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 30m30 minutes ago
I agree, although if I were Jim Delany, I'd send out feelers for a UVA/Duke combo.
Adam Gold @AGoldFan 29m29 minutes ago
@frankthetank111 what in the heck makes you think any ACC team is leaving let alone Duke? I love expansion talk, too. But please.
Adam Gold @AGoldFan 24m24 minutes ago
@frankthetank111 and then you thought Delany should send out feelers for a UVA-Duke combo. Again, I LOVE this game of Risk, too. But, c'mon
Adam Gold @AGoldFan 22m22 minutes ago
@frankthetank111 Grant of Rights should end any speculation. Plus, the league I'd say was most vulnerable to poachers would be the B12
Frank the Tank @frankthetank111 27m27 minutes ago
I personally don't think anyone from the ACC is leaving. Just responding about value of Duke.