I think the critiques of Clingan's tape are fair, as are the critiques that he is playing against subpar competition.
@Fishy the kid could could up his level of competition and play against kids closer to his size and certainly more talented than him if he wanted to, and the fact that he doesn't is worth note.
I also think there are real reasons to want this kid. He definitely has real promise. Further, he's a local kid. Even if we thought he'd
only be a very four year player--rather than a 5-star first one-and-done--there value in locking down your region. Frankly, he's probably going to be somewhere in between.
I think we want him on the team for a variety of reasons--not least because he can very well be a dominating force--but
@polycom has some points.