Yeah, it isn't better than I think. Might even be worse...I realize that RPI can differ from year to year, but it seldom moves 50 places, so based on last year's final RPI, we only have 6 games against top 100 RPI assuming we play every one twice!
Using RPI as a be-all end-all is a mistake but since you insist on cherry pick stats, I can cherry pick too.
1. Griping about the bottom few teams in the conference is ridiculous. South Florida (except for 2011-12), Providence, DePaul and Rutgers all made habit of posting 150+ RPIs despite playing in a Big East conference where SOS made that almost impossible to pull off. Speaking of 2011-12: The Big East put nine teams in the Dance that year despite having four teams with RPI greater than 150. Do you ever recall the weak RPI of the bottom schools brought up against the strength of the conference, ever? Ever?
2. The AAC has five teams that had top-50 RPIs last year. Last year's ACC had 4 top-50 RPI teams, I don't recall it being denounced as a horrible basketball league last season. How does five top-50 RPI teams compare to some other power leagues? The Big 12, MWC had five. The Pac-12 had four. The SEC had three.
3. RPI's seldom change 50 spots in a year. Really? Top of mind: South Florida's fell from 51 to 151 last year. Kentucky's from 2 to 56. West Virginia's from 53 to 145. Baylor's from 9 to 67. Boise State's rose from 172 to 44. Miami's from 54 to 4. BC's from 243 to 112. Providence's from 155 to 89. Nova's from 117 to 51. And I can keep going with as many as you need to hear until you drop 'seldom' from your statement. And if we're betting on a school to move 50+ RPI spots, wouldn't the one Larry Brown took over, dropped almost the whole team and started bringing in his guys -- including a top-50 national recruit -- be at the top of that list?
Listen, if you want to compare the AAC to the prime years of the Big East, it's no comparison. But compare it to a major conference in a normal year and it stacks right up. Sounds to me like it's a tad better than you think.