Memphis is joining the Big East | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Memphis is joining the Big East

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
1,684
Reaction Score
2,889
On another note, and in fairness to all new members, we need to evaluate them on their future prospects, and not their past records. Can UM rise from the ashes with a BE logo on their field? If you were not a UConn fan, you would have been skeptical that UConn was a major add to the BE last decade. On that basis alone, we have to give other teams the benefit of the doubt and assume they will advance (a la UConn and Ville) w/BE membership, and not continue to be mired in mediocrity. There is no reason UM can not thrive on the field.
Aside from the fact that Tennessee's population is 6.5 million, of whom the great great majority root for either the Vols, and to a much lesser extent Vandy, and that Memphis is a third tier, urban, commuter school, I can see the similarities to UConn. They have all the tools in place to compete at the highest level. Just like they proved in CUSA. Even Herbst has denigrated UConn's endowment of $350 million as woefully inadequate. Memphis' endowment is $180 million.

As far as Memphis being the 18th largest city in the US. I believe that NYC is the largest, so we should add Hofstra. If a team plays in a big city yet no one is there to watch it, did the game really exist?

This is purely a basketball move. Which if you have followed Marinatto and the BE is quite surprising considering Providence's disdain for the basketball onlies.
 

zls44

Your #icebus Tour Director
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
9,077
Reaction Score
24,430
Can't wait for Carl Spackler to explain how this will take the TV money to $25 million/year.
 

Dann

#4hunnid
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
9,901
Reaction Score
7,180
Aside from the fact that Tennessee's population is 6.5 million, of whom the great great majority root for either the Vols, and to a much lesser extent Vandy, and that Memphis is a third tier, urban, commuter school, I can see the similarities to UConn. They have all the tools in place to compete at the highest level. Just like they proved in CUSA. Even Herbst has denigrated UConn's endowment of $350 million as woefully inadequate. Memphis' endowment is $180 million.

As far as Memphis being the 18th largest city in the US. I believe that NYC is the largest, so we should add Hofstra. If a team plays in a big city yet no one is there to watch it, did the game really exist?

This is purely a basketball move. Which if you have followed Marinatto and the BE is quite surprising considering Providence's disdain for the basketball onlies.

agree. this was a bball ready team with a fball dream. they did this becuase lville is leaving and they are trying to keep this league together. the bball onlys will see thru this though. memphis isn't a school they want to be with, no matter the bball product. if we needed a bball school to keep the bball teams on baord and then there were better schols to add who don't mess up what were trying for in fball.

we could have added a xavier in bball and a ecu in fball. both sides would have been happier with that then memphis for everything. they was a last chance to keep the bballs on board and it will fail. in the long term of the new BE going to 16 with a east and west division, memphis prob would get a invite. they got it to early though as other teams are more important at this point.

uconn/ruty/temple/ecu/navy/usf/ucf
bosie/sdsu/uh/smu/memphis//?/?

the question is are we a fball only or not in the future.

pray for the b12 to go for the home run everyone. pray for it. if they can add 2-6 teams then we are gold. a lville/byu/fsu/gt/fsu/miami add(any 4 really) by them puts us in a great spot. the Big will eventually have to do something and nd will to. the best case id we get a Big invite one day with ruty and others. the worst case is a acc of unc/ncst/wake/duke/vt/uva/md/ruty/bc/cuse/pitt/uconn. both of those are miles better than where were heading.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
89,224
Reaction Score
335,838
Damn... and I just renewed my 3 year cycle tickets last night!
 

junglehusky

Molotov Cocktail of Ugliness
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
7,158
Reaction Score
15,481
#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder#BegHarder
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
22,836
Reaction Score
9,464
It's official. ESPN Radio just announced it on the 5 P.M. Sportscenter update. Joining for 2013 season.

There's nothing shocking about this at all. ESPN will spin it that way. Memphis basketball has been a target for Big East expansion since the 2002 split.

The shocking thing about big east expansion in this go around, is that football decision making and priority has overwhelmingly come in top priority. The conference, nevertheless, is still a hybrid. Memphis basketball will be a nice addition. Memphis football? Well, I guarantee that anybody associated wiht Memphis football is ecstatic.

As for the other 10 football playing members? I can speak as a fan of one of them, I'm pretty happy that Memphis is on board, because that's a program that's going to be quite a bit behind for at least a couple years, and every conference that has a 10, 11, 12 game winner, is going to have a team on the bottom end that doesn't have many wins, and I most definitely want to be the team that's getting the 10,11,12 wins.
 

Fishy

Elite Premium Poster
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
18,196
Reaction Score
132,593
It's actually more than a little shocking. The league presidents have always screened out Memphis for their academics and their inability to even pretend to abide by a rule book

It's another sign that UL is not long for the league.
 
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
1,776
Reaction Score
1,377
It's actually more than a little shocking. The league presidents have always screened out Memphis for their academics and their inability to even pretend to abide by a rule book

It's another sign that UL is not long for the league.
Or it is a sign that the second and third tier schools are firmly in charge of conference membership, which is even worse than UL being gone.
 

TRest

Horrible
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
7,866
Reaction Score
22,393
Or it is a sign that the second and third tier schools are firmly in charge of conference membership, which is even worse than UL being gone.
It's both. I can't believe ND can be looking forward to being in the same conference with West Tennessee State. Lew Perkins warned the state legislature, etc that UConn would be left behind in the coming split if we didn't upgrade football. This may be worse. Surprise, we let some CUSA schools in and the next thing you know they are recreating the Metro Conference and we have no better options.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
531
Reaction Score
610
look at the bright side if in fact they do make it necessary to win 7 games in order to make a bowl game it doesnt hurt to have a few easy wins on the schedule
 

ConnHuskBask

Shut Em Down!
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
9,016
Reaction Score
33,161
For everyone bashing the move - what were the other (realistic) options?

Not saying I'm thrilled about it, but at this point it's grab the biggest name and markets available.
 

MattMang23

Adding Nothing to the Conversation
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
5,150
Reaction Score
14,734
For everyone bashing the move - what were the other (realistic) options?

Not saying I'm thrilled about it, but at this point it's grab the biggest name and markets available.

I would have approached Temple (don't know if you consider that realistic with Nova's BCU-like stonewall), UNLV, Tulane, Tulsa, Fresno State, and Nevada before Memphis.
 

ConnHuskBask

Shut Em Down!
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
9,016
Reaction Score
33,161
I would have approached Temple (don't know if you consider that realistic with Nova's BCU-like stonewall), UNLV, Tulane, Tulsa, Fresno State, and Nevada before Memphis.

Fair enough, Memphis and Temple are one in the same to me. Temple has been a lot stronger in football recently, I will give them that. Temple would be the logical replacement if Louisville goes to the BigXII.

BE East: UConn, Rutgers, Louisville, Cincinnati, Navy, USF

BE West: Boise State, Houston, SMU, UCF, SDSU, Memphis
 
Joined
Aug 31, 2011
Messages
2,795
Reaction Score
4,908
Fair enough, Memphis and Temple are one in the same to me. Temple has been a lot stronger in football recently, I will give them that. Temple would be the logical replacement if Louisville goes to the BigXII.

BE East: UConn, Rutgers, Louisville, Cincinnati, Navy, USF

BE West: Boise State, Houston, SMU, UCF, SDSU, Memphis


Um, I think you need to swap UCF and the Ville.
 

ConnHuskBask

Shut Em Down!
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
9,016
Reaction Score
33,161
Um, I think you need to swap UCF and the Ville.

Doubt it. If Louisville is still in this version of the Big East they are going to demand (and rightfully so) to be aligned with the post 2003 "Original" BE members. There's no way a competent AD like Tom Jurich lets Louisville get further mired down in with all C-USA and MTN West teams.

UCF and USF even though they would be in different divisions will have an annual game.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
531
Reaction Score
610
Navy doesnt come on board until 2015 there doesnt have to be a rush to add anyone. why not wait out or BYU? then you could add a team to the western division that is actually in the west. Memphis wasnt going anywhere fast they were available today they would have been available in 2013 when we needed to send out the invite to get a team in the same time as Navy.
 

RS9999X

There's no Dark Side .....it's all Dark.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
5,626
Reaction Score
562
They can negotiate a championship game come September

.
Big East Commissioner John Marinatto said the league needs to get its expansion plans settled by September 2012 when it begins television contract negotiations.

The Big East current has a television contract with ESPN that expires at the conclusion of the 2012-13 academic year. Marinatto said the Big East will begin a 60-day exclusive negotiation period with ESPN in September 2012
 

SubbaBub

Your stupidity is ruining my country.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
32,115
Reaction Score
24,818
If Uconn is going to be stuck in this conference, then I have some demands, namely leveraging this new schools for better bowl tie-ins. I'm talking Liberty Bowl, Florida, Texas, Houston, Las Vegas, and New Orleans, especially if we are stuck playing the 2nd or 3rd bowl game in each local.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
7,411
Reaction Score
24,528
If Uconn is going to be stuck in this conference, then I have some demands, namely leveraging this new schools for better bowl tie-ins. I'm talking Liberty Bowl, Florida, Texas, Houston, Las Vegas, and New Orleans, especially if we are stuck playing the 2nd or 3rd bowl game in each local.

It would be great if the Big East champ could play in the Cotton bowl now that we have three teams near Dallas. "The Fed Ex Cotton Bowl"?
 

TRest

Horrible
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
7,866
Reaction Score
22,393
I still don't see the need for 12 football teams and a championship game no one will watch. Put together the best 10 teams you can, instead of projects and reaches like Memphis and SMU. And if the AQ status is gone, so will go Boise.
 

junglehusky

Molotov Cocktail of Ugliness
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
7,158
Reaction Score
15,481
^^^This.^^^

Perhaps there's back channels to NBC or whoever that's driving this, but I find it hard to believe Memphis is some executive's piece of the puzzle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
310
Guests online
1,892
Total visitors
2,202

Forum statistics

Threads
157,830
Messages
4,122,571
Members
10,013
Latest member
NYCVET


Top Bottom