OT: - List Your top 5 Groups or Artists of All Time, Then Post One Song From Each | Page 2 | The Boneyard

OT: List Your top 5 Groups or Artists of All Time, Then Post One Song From Each

Status
Not open for further replies.
.-.


Hard to believe anyone that young could have written this but then again there was only one John Prine
 
Carnac said:
1. Johnny Mathis (for over 60 years)
2. The Whispers
3. The Stylistics
4. The Carpenters (Karen died way too soon) :(
5. Steely Dan
Brenda Lee
Candy Dulfer
Nat King Cole
Nancy Wilson
Patsy Cline
Luther Vandross
Shalamar
Shilts
Tommy Edwards



I've had the pleasure of seeing Mathis in concert at least 10 times over the years. Every time I went, price was no object. I wanted the best seats that were available. The last time was in Las Vegas at the Hilton. I stood in line to enter the auditorium right behind the Late Bill Russell, who went to USF at the same time Mathis was attending San Francisco State in the mid 50's.
Expand ...

And Johnny didn't just attend SFT at the same time as Russell, he and Bill were two of the top high jumpers of their era!

Mathis' Christmas album from the late '50s is my go-to music to get me in the mood for the holiday. I wish I'd been along one of those 10 times, Carnac. You were blessed. My Dad loved Johnny when I was a little kid and I inherited his appreciation for that peerless voice.
 
.-.
Kaizen said:
I love their "Your Wildest Dreams" which I saw in their concert.

Expand ...

I'm with you, Kaizen. That song and 'I Know You're Out There Somewhere' were big hits in the '80s and brought the Moodies a whole new generation of fans.

It was always fun at their concerts to look around to see which generation got into which songs the most...
 
Scud49 said:
Sorry, I know its nigh on impossible to pick a top 5 fav groups, then select one tune from each - but I thought maybe we could run with it after giving it some thought...! In all honesty, my 2nd "top 5" groups I'm sure I like as much as the first 5.

Oh well, it's the off season still, we get to obsess over "other things" for a while longer. :)
Expand ...
No apologies, please, Scud49. That was a poorly done attempt at tongue-in-cheek humor by me. I love the thread and everyone's contributions!

As Littlemin just wrote, it's all about the beauty of music.
 
Beatles have to be the #1 group for me. Trying to pick one tune is hard, real hard. But I'll go with one off the "Revolver" album which is just amazing. This one is "I'm Only Sleeping':

 
Littlemin said:


Hard to believe anyone that young could have written this but then again there was only one John Prine
Expand ...


Saw him do this one live at a small club in Indianapolis, probably 1987 or so. It was just him and his traveling music partner, both on guitar. Just magical, they were perhaps only 20 feet from me and my buddies.
 
.-.
The deacon said:
The Moody Blues are number one for me, and I've been fortunate to see them starting in 1972 and then at the SPAC in 2018, I believe, just before they finally called it quits as a group. Love 'Have You Heard,' Bigboote!

Moody Blues/'Tuesday Afternoon' (by a narrow margin over dozens of others)
Bee Gees/'I Started A Joke'
Queen/'Bohemian Rhapsody'
Abba/'The Winner Takes It All' (although 'Dancing Queen' is pretty darned special)
Neil Diamond/'Be' (with apologies to our girl Caroline)

How, oh how, do I leave out Roy Orbison/'In Dreams'?

Thanks so much, Scud49, for confusing the heck out of me... this a such a difficult list to make.

And, bowing to my Irish heritage, U2, The Chieftains, Van Morrison and the Cranberries...
Expand ...
Didn't WNEW FM use "Dawning is the Day" as their lead in for station ID in the1970's ?
 
SCNCHuskie said:
1. Bruce Springsteen
2. U2
3. Railroad Earth
4. Van Morrison
5. Pink
HM: ELO, Yes, Paramore, Stones
Expand ...

I wrote the above list while driving in heavy traffic through Charlotte and later reflected on my choices. I got thinking it depends when I was asked this question.

If you asked me when I was 15 my list would look like this:
1. Queen
2. Kiss
3. Kansas
4. Styx
5. Blonde

If you asked me when I was 20 my list would look like this:
1. Springsteen
2. The Dead
3. The Doors
4. Yes
5. The Who

If you asked me when I was 25 my list would look like this:
1. Springsteen
2. U2
3. Van Halen
4. Guns N Roses
5. Beatles/Stones

If you asked me when I was 30 my list would look like this:
1. Springsteen
2. Garth Brooks
3. The Cure
4. Smashing Pumpkins
5. Blink 182

If you asked me when I was 35 my list would like this:
1. Springsteen
2. Springsteen
3. Springsteen
4. Springsteen
5. Springsteen

And, if you asked me when I was 10 my list would look like this:
1. America
2. The Partridge Family
3. Donna Fargo
4. Zager and Evans
5. Tanya Tucker

I really haven’t evolved much.
 
Last edited:
The deacon said:
And Johnny didn't just attend SFT at the same time as Russell, he and Bill were two of the top high jumpers of their era!

Mathis' Christmas album from the late '50s is my go-to music to get me in the mood for the holiday. I wish I'd been along one of those 10 times, Carnac. You were blessed. My Dad loved Johnny when I was a little kid and I inherited his appreciation for that peerless voice.
Expand ...
You would have loved his performance. Johnny sang all of his popular songs that we liked, and some songs that HE liked. I never saw any children or teenagers at his concerts. Mid 40’s and up. You listened to his music on the radio or on vinyl many many times. So when you get the opportunity to see him in person only several yards from you, that’s a treat.
 
.-.
As a Baby Boomer and a professional musician, making any list is next to impossible. I'm all over the place in terms of vocals, instrumentals, pop, rock, blues, jazz and classical. Today's top 5 will be different from tomorrows.

So, I'll pick one the present jazz band I'm playing with is doing. One of my favorite vocalists - Nat King Cole.

 
Scud49 said:
My Top 5:

1. Beatles
2. Crosby, Still, Nash, & Young
3. Steely Dan
4. Van Morrison
5. Santana

I'll start with Santana - I'll Be Waiting, such a beautiful, joyous song:

Expand ...

Very nice idea Scud.
 
Carnac said:
1. Johnny Mathis (for over 60 years)
2. The Whispers
3. The Stylistics
4. The Carpenters (Karen died way too soon) :(
5. Steely Dan
Brenda Lee
Candy Dulfer
Nat King Cole
Nancy Wilson
Patsy Cline
Luther Vandross
Shalamar
Shilts
Tommy Edwards



I've had the pleasure of seeing Mathis in concert at least 10 times over the years. Every time I went, price was no object. I wanted the best seats that were available. The last time was in Las Vegas at the Hilton. I stood in line to enter the auditorium right behind the Late Bill Russell, who went to USF at the same time Mathis was attending San Francisco State in the mid 50's.
Expand ...

Love Johnny Mathis. What a great voice.
 
AzHusky said:
1. Moody Blues - any song
2. Rippingtons - Caribbean breeze
3. Yes - Close to the edge
4. Genesis - Driving the Last Spike
5. Beach Boys - God only knows

Caribbean Breeze
Expand ...

Great call on the Rippingtons. I'm surprised I didn't see a song by them on the jazz thread.
 
SCNCHuskie said:
I wrote the above list while driving in heavy traffic through Charlotte and later reflected on my choices. I got thinking it depends when I was asked this question.

If you asked me when I was 15 my list would look like this:
1. Queen
2. Kiss
3. Kansas
4. Styx
5. Blonde

If you asked me when I was 20 my list would look like this:
1. Springsteen
2. The Dead
3. The Doors
4. Yes
5. The Who

If you asked me when I was 25 my list would look like this:
1. Springsteen
2. U2
3. Van Halen
4. Guns N Roses
5. Beatles/Stones

If you asked me when I was 30 my list would look like this:
1. Springsteen
2. Garth Brooks
3. The Cure
4. Smashing Pumpkins
5. Blink 182

If you asked me when I was 35 my list would like this:
1. Springsteen
2. Springsteen
3. Springsteen
4. Springsteen
5. Springsteen

And, if you asked me when I was 10 my list would look like this:
1. America
2. The Partridge Family
3. Donna Fargo
4. Zager and Evans
5. Tanya Tucker

I really haven’t evolved much.
Expand ...
Good call on the Partridge Family. Still watch that show to this day.
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,299
Messages
4,562,053
Members
10,453
Latest member
Storytory


Top Bottom