Since nobody wants to answer the question about our "peer" group the last decade, I took a stab below. Excluded are the blue bloods: Kentucky, Kansas, Duke, UNC, and UCLA as well as Gonzaga and Nova (as were all well aware of their success):
Michigan: 1 F4, 3 E8, 6 S16, 2 Conf tourney titles
Mich State: 2 F4, 3 E8, 2 Conf tourney titles
Louisville: 1 E8, 1 S16, 1 Conf tourney title
Syracuse: 1 F4, 3 S16, 0 Conf tourney titles
Arizona: 2 E8, 4 S16, 4 Conf tourney titles
Florida: 1 F4, 2 E8, 1 Conf tourney title
Indiana: 1 S16, 0 Conf tourney titles