Then we agree - I think. But my point is we need to continue to run a diverse offense even if it doesn't work here. If the play is there go for it. If we bail because of a few bad throws we'll never get the timing down. Shirreffs needs the reps in the game after being conservative for 2 years. Maybe he can't do it but the alternative is just a more agonizing slow death.
We do agree, and you're right we shouldn't totally abandon it, but we also need to find other ways to get those players involved in ways they can actually contribute - like using Thomas on sweeps (we did), using Thomas and Hergy on slants that BS can actually complete (we did). I would add in other short pass plays that give Thomas room to run, and maybe try going over the top a bit. But if your QB consistently misses all of his long throws, going back to it over and over is just wasting opportunities to get your best players the ball. UH's secondary has been anything but impressive tonight. Their D-line is excellent, but their secondary has been ridiculously beatable, if our QB could throw over the top.