Rodgers, Brady, Newton, Brees, Rothlisberger, Wilson, Rivers, Palmer, Luck and Romo are all better than Eli. You can argue a spot or two but he'll always be borderline top 10, if you consider that one of the best then I guess you are right.
His pocket presence this year has been awful. He doesn't ever fight to not get sacked and holds on to the ball too long rather than throw the ball away, he isn't a cerebral QB like Brady or Rothlisberger
He's also had an injury plagued career and has had to play for many different coaches and systems while Eli has had the same team, coach and system his whole career. I'll give you that Eli has had a better career than Palmer but to say Palmer has only been a little better than Eli this season is laughable, he's an MVP candidate.
My only point was Eli is not one of the best QB's, he's never been one of the best QB's in a single season. I admitted he's had a better career but Palmer is way better than him this year. I give Eli credit for winning two Super Bowls and for staying healthy, he's a good QB but has never been one of the best.
A wild card was never in realm of possibility for the NFC East. It's all or nothing in that division.
2011?
The recievers outside of OBJ are pretty underwhelming, but Eli has also been very inaccurate recently. Right around 50% for the past few games. He started out great this year but hasn't been good the last few weeks
Mau, chill brother. Been a Giants diehard since I was an infant and love Coughlin and Eli for helping to bring us two rings and because they are a part of the Giants family but I will always call it like it is. I want Coughlin gone because he's done a horrible job this season and he probably should have retired a season or 2 ago. Eli puts up good numbers but is too mistake prone and just isn't elite in my opinion, I didn't even say they should go in a different direction at QB but if there was someone out there we could get that would be better than Eli I would happily go in that direction. I want the Giants to have the best chance of winning conference championships and Super Bowls, if I don't think Coughlin and Eli can do those things I call it out. No clue where you are getting that I hate Eli??? I don't think Daniel Hamilton is as good as Ben Simmons either, doesn't mean I hate Hamilton.
I remember them well and Eli is way better than them. Jay Cutler is possibly the best QB in Bears history but I still think he sucks. If you're trying to make a point that Eli is better than those scrubs you have a pretty low bar.
Their on the 3rd and 4th TE's with their best a rookie out of Stony Brook. But hey if he was a Top 10 QB he wouldn't need a TE. None of the good ones have one didn't you know that?
