August_West
Conscience do cost
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2011
- Messages
- 51,417
- Reaction Score
- 90,686
Horatio said:Brie is too "proper" and "Knightly". She won't just kill Stanis, she'll try to arrest him and bring him to trial or turn him over to someone .That's probably why we didn't see him die.
And that is a huge problem I have with the show and Brienne. She's supposed to be "so honorable" and " knightly" right?
" oath keeper"..... and Renly's death and Catelyns death " don't release me from my oath" and all that bs. It is like her raison d'etre, no?
Well here is my gripe with her. Why was she sworn to Renly in the first place in the war of the 5 kings? I mean she sides with everything that is " right" , no?
She is virtuous , no?
Well Renly Baratheon never had a legitimate claim on the Iron throne. if Brienne played by the rules she would've had to have supported Stannis' claim, right? If she believed the stories about joffrey and the rest being illegitimate, then Stannis is the one with the only valid claim on the throne.
So why support Renly if she is such a moral compass.
Show sucks.