"To Be or Not to Be"-Ernst Lubitsch-1942
This film was not a particular critical favorite when it was made. Bosley Crowther wrote a nasty revue for the New York Times. He wasn't the only one. Lubitsch wrote a letter trying to explain that the film was satire, and that he was sensitive to the issues involved. The film was a financial success, part of that may be due to the death of Carole Lombard in a plane crash shortly before the film opened. Lubitsch was an Austrian Jew who came to Hollywood in 1929 during the transition from silent to sound pictures. He was one of the pioneers of the screwball comedy. This genre featured fast dialogue, unusual settings, and both physical and verbal humor.
Two famous examples of this genre are "The Philadelphia Story" and "The Lady Eve."
Jack Benny was Lubitsch's first and only choice to play "That Great Polish actor, Joseph Tura. Benny was a major radio star, and he had a film background, but despite his success in "Charlie's Aunt", he wasn't being asked for major roles. Carole Lombard was a later addition; Miriam Hopkins was slated to play the role, but she and Benny were incompatible. The set was a happy one; there are litterally dozens of photos showing playful antics on the set.
The story begins in Warsaw in August of 1939. Inside a popular theater the troupe is rehearsing an anti Nazi play; representatives of the Foreign Office force the cancellation of this show. The troupe returns to "Hamlet."
A young Polish pilot frequents the theater sitting in the center of the third row. Lt. Sobinski (Robert Stack) is taken with Maria Tura (Carole Lombard). He sends her flowers and comes to the dressing room. They set up a meeting. The signal is a famous speech by "Hamlet." When Tura begins "to be or not to be" ; the Lieutenant
rises and crosses to the aisle. Tura notices and is shocked. Maria and the lieutenant meet several times; she goes up in his bomber. Several weeks into their relationship, Poland is attacked and Warsaw is bombed. Poland falls quickly and the aircrews flee to England to continue the fight. The theater is not open.
In England a professor meets with the aircrews, and they give him information about friends and relatives in Poland. He is supposedly going to Poland to meet with the underground, but he is actually a German secret agent. Sobinski suspects him because the professor has never heard of Maria Tura. This sets up the meat of the film where great efforts are made to prevent this information from going to the Gezpatcho.
I'm not going to revealthe rest of the plot, the jokes, the misadventures, the pratfalls, and the ending. This is classic Lubitsch; the film has steadily risen in appreciation of both audiences and critics. Mel Brooks re-made the film in 1983 almost word for word. Stick with the original. The is a Bollywood re-make; that I haven't seen; nor have I seen the Polish and Hungarian plays, nor the Broadway Musical. This is widely available, and it is one of my all time favorite comedies. In my opinion a great comedy that Yarders will laugh with. The humor is both clever and broad.
This film was not a particular critical favorite when it was made. Bosley Crowther wrote a nasty revue for the New York Times. He wasn't the only one. Lubitsch wrote a letter trying to explain that the film was satire, and that he was sensitive to the issues involved. The film was a financial success, part of that may be due to the death of Carole Lombard in a plane crash shortly before the film opened. Lubitsch was an Austrian Jew who came to Hollywood in 1929 during the transition from silent to sound pictures. He was one of the pioneers of the screwball comedy. This genre featured fast dialogue, unusual settings, and both physical and verbal humor.
Two famous examples of this genre are "The Philadelphia Story" and "The Lady Eve."
Jack Benny was Lubitsch's first and only choice to play "That Great Polish actor, Joseph Tura. Benny was a major radio star, and he had a film background, but despite his success in "Charlie's Aunt", he wasn't being asked for major roles. Carole Lombard was a later addition; Miriam Hopkins was slated to play the role, but she and Benny were incompatible. The set was a happy one; there are litterally dozens of photos showing playful antics on the set.
The story begins in Warsaw in August of 1939. Inside a popular theater the troupe is rehearsing an anti Nazi play; representatives of the Foreign Office force the cancellation of this show. The troupe returns to "Hamlet."
A young Polish pilot frequents the theater sitting in the center of the third row. Lt. Sobinski (Robert Stack) is taken with Maria Tura (Carole Lombard). He sends her flowers and comes to the dressing room. They set up a meeting. The signal is a famous speech by "Hamlet." When Tura begins "to be or not to be" ; the Lieutenant
rises and crosses to the aisle. Tura notices and is shocked. Maria and the lieutenant meet several times; she goes up in his bomber. Several weeks into their relationship, Poland is attacked and Warsaw is bombed. Poland falls quickly and the aircrews flee to England to continue the fight. The theater is not open.
In England a professor meets with the aircrews, and they give him information about friends and relatives in Poland. He is supposedly going to Poland to meet with the underground, but he is actually a German secret agent. Sobinski suspects him because the professor has never heard of Maria Tura. This sets up the meat of the film where great efforts are made to prevent this information from going to the Gezpatcho.
I'm not going to revealthe rest of the plot, the jokes, the misadventures, the pratfalls, and the ending. This is classic Lubitsch; the film has steadily risen in appreciation of both audiences and critics. Mel Brooks re-made the film in 1983 almost word for word. Stick with the original. The is a Bollywood re-make; that I haven't seen; nor have I seen the Polish and Hungarian plays, nor the Broadway Musical. This is widely available, and it is one of my all time favorite comedies. In my opinion a great comedy that Yarders will laugh with. The humor is both clever and broad.