Favorite Holloween Candy or

[Husky25]

I'm a traditionalist. I like the chocolate based candy. Kit Kat, Butterfinger, Twix, 3 Musketeers, Snickers, Baby Ruth, Milky Way and of course Reese's Peanut Butter cups. I used to not like coconut, but that's grown on me. We used to get a lot of Sugar Daddys and Sugar babies too.

Worst -
1. Good n' Plenty
2. Necco Wafers
3 Candy corn
4. Non-candy items. A pencil is not a treat. I don't care how many Pac-Man ghost erasers come with it.

 

[Dream Jobbed 2.0]

I love the fruity tootsie rolls and I wouldn’t touch whoopers

 

[Dream Jobbed 2.0]

I'm a traditionalist. I like the chocolate based candy. Kit Kat, Butterfinger, Twix, 3 Musketeers, Snickers, Baby Ruth, Milky Way and of course Reese's Peanut Butter cups. I used to not like coconut, but that's grown on me. We used to get a lot of Sugar Daddys and Sugar babies too.

Worst -
1. Good n' Plenty
2. Necco Wafers
3 Candy corn
4. Non-candy items. A pencil is not a treat. I don't care how many Pac-Man ghost erasers come with it.

Forgot good n plenty. So disappointing

 

[elmcityboy]

I love the fruity tootsie rolls and I wouldn’t touch whoopers

the fruity tootsie rolls are underrated. and they seemingly only come out at halloween.

i love good & plenty.

 

[Husky25]

the fruity tootsie rolls are underrated. and they seemingly only come out at halloween.

i love good & plenty.

Which also seemingly only come out at Halloween.

 

[boba]

Best: Balut or Hákarl

Worst: All that sweet stuff...

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

I got candy cigarettes several times. Not sure they are still produced. Just terrible! I kid you not one house always gave me circus peanuts

One time I got coupons.

 

[boba]

I got candy cigarettes several times. Not sure they are still produced. Just terrible! I kid you not one house always gave me circus peanuts

One time I got coupons.

Were the coupons for candy corn or Necco wafers?

 

[Deepster]

the fruity tootsie rolls are underrated. and they seemingly only come out at halloween.

i love good & plenty.

Why are good and plenty two different colors? They're the same flavor.

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

Were the coupons for candy corn or Necco wafers?

It was for McDonald's. When I went to use them a week later to buy a milkshake this McDonald's told me the coupon was not valid since it wasn't Halloween anymore. Never forgot that.

Felt like Rodney Dangerfield

 

[Husky25]

It was for McDonald's. When I went to use them a week later to buy a milkshake this McDonald's told me the coupon was not valid since it wasn't Halloween anymore. Never forgot that.

Felt like Rodney Dangerfield

Did they get one of @Deepster 's religious apples to the front door?

 

[uconndennis]

Best: $100,000 Bar
Worst: Candy corn

This is the only correct answer

 

[ZenConn]

Whoppers are awesome.

Worst. Anything with almonds or hazelnut. I'm allergic to them. Although it hasn't stopped me from eating Bit-O-Honey - just take an antihistimine after.

 

[Chuck]

It was for McDonald's. When I went to use them a week later to buy a milkshake this McDonald's told me the coupon was not valid since it wasn't Halloween anymore. Never forgot that.

Felt like Rodney Dangerfield

That McD's screwed you. I remember getting those coupons. They were meant to be given out on Halloween, not used on Halloween. Some people would give out a whole book of them, others were just give you one ripped out. As a chubby kid that would certainly enjoy a burger and fries, I didn't mind getting these, but they generally went unused thanks to my mom trying to get me to eat better. Maybe if they were for Arby's...

 

[storrsroars]

Best: Balut or Hákarl

Worst: All that sweet stuff...

Sounds all fun and games until your neighbors start feeding that hakari back into your central AC system and the kids egg your house with baby bird parts!

 

[Cuse Socks]

Best: King sized anything
Worst: Circus peanuts
Also worst: anything that included a pencil and a homemade bag of random assortments

 

[Bezzz]

When I was in grammar school there was a really popular teacher who lived in the neighborhood. So many kids went to his house on Halloween that by the end of the night he was handing out loose change. I remember getting a few pennies and nickels.

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

That McD's screwed you. I remember getting those coupons. They were meant to be given out on Halloween, not used on Halloween. Some people would give out a whole book of them, others were just give you one ripped out. As a chubby kid that would certainly enjoy a burger and fries, I didn't mind getting these, but they generally went unused thanks to my mom trying to get me to eat better. Maybe if they were for Arby's...

Statute of limitations ran on the class action unfortunately by thirty-five years otherwise I would seriously consider it. Do Arby's still exist? If so I would like to check one out. Did you ever get the candy cigarettes? A study showed sixth graders who received candy cigs on Halloween were twice as likely to actually smoke.

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

When I was in grammar school there was a really popular teacher who lived in the neighborhood. So many kids went to his house on Halloween that by the end of the night he was handing out loose change. I remember getting a few pennies and nickels.

Nice dog

Cooool story! lol

 

[Huskybass]

We used to cover half of Sandy Hook every year. We walked miles and miles to essentially fill up a pillowcase.

Best: $100,000 bar
Worst: Candy Corn

Other interesting treats:. Big Buddy, Charleston Chew, Jolly Ranchers, Bubble Yum, Caramel Apples

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

Best: King sized anything
Worst: Circus peanuts
Also worst: anything that included a pencil and a homemade bag of random assortments

Circus peanuts are worse than coupons. JMHO

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

We used to cover half of Sandy Hook every year. We walked miles and miles to essentially fill up a pillowcase.

Best: $100,000 bar
Worst: Candy Corn

Other interesting treats:. Big Buddy, Charleston Chew, Jolly Ranchers, Bubble Yum, Caramel Apples

YES! Charleston Chew! YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Just got first trick or treater. Went with letting kids pick out of the bowl.

 

[Deepster]

Did they get one of @Deepster 's religious apples to the front door?

Have you never seen one of these?

 

[BLUEDOGHOUSE]

Have you never seen one of these?

View attachment 47627

LOL

 

[Hogoff]

the goat for me is the pumpkin-shaped reese's cups

whoppers are the worst -- one of the few types of candy i won't actually eat

Any of the holiday Reese’s cups are superior to the standard ones. The peanut butter to chocolate ratio seems to be higher.