It is true we are not getting the elite recruits anymore. Not being in the Power 5 may be one reason but is it the only reason? Other teams, not in the Power 5, continue to get elite (outstanding) recruits, e.g. , Gonzaga, Witchita, SMU, Cincinnati, Butler and others. Why not us? Are there other reasons? Hmmmm!!
Huh?
UConn has out-recruited all the teams you listed except Gonzaga.
Holding onto recruits is a bigger problem. The losses of MAL, Durham, Enoch, Vance Jackson, all of who signed to play for UConn, is troubling. BUT these players plus the likes of Daniel Hamilton, Jalen Adams and Alterique Gilbert are higher ranked than the kids at the schools you mention.
In 2014, UConn has grabbed the #18 ranked player in the country. Cincy grabbed the #94 in Gary Clark. None of Wichita, SMU, Butler had even a single player in the top 100. Gonzaga snagged Sabonis and Perkins.
In 2015, UConn grabbed the #31 and #48. SMU grabbed Shake Milton at #93. None of Cincy, Wichita, Gonzaga and Butler got a single top 100 player.
In 2016, UConn grabbed #32, #46 and #79. Cincy got Jarron Cumberland at #42. None of Wichita, Butler and SMU grabbed a single top 100. Gonzaga grabbed Zach Collins and Killian Tillie.
In 2017, UConn had #39 sign. None of the other schools including Gonzaga had a single top 100.
So, over the last 4 years:
Gonzaga: Sabonis, Perkins, Collins and Tillie.
UConn: #18, #31, #32, #39, #46, #48, #79.
Cincy: #42, #94
SMU: #93
Wichita: zero
Butler: zero
Clearly, UConn has outrecruited every school on your list over the last 4 years. UConn has also advanced further in the NCAAs than schools like SMU, Butler, Wichita and Cincy.
This years problems were due to injuries, and now we have departures. Of the 7 top 100s that UConn has recruited, only Jalen Adams and Alterique Gilbert are left. #18 left for the NBADL, #39 asked out of his signed LOI, #s 46, 48, and 79 just transferred.
Recruiting isn't the problem. You might say injuries, development, scouting, and temperament/attitude are the problems.