Bourbon & Rye | Page 7 | The Boneyard

Bourbon & Rye

I went to my local shop to get Champagne today for V Day and I evidently won a raffle. Two nice bottles of Privateer rum and a Mad River bourbon.

E290C225-D0A8-4DDD-B9E0-76A03578C060.jpeg
 
I thought I remember @Fishy mentioning an infinity bottle that he keeps, but didn't see it in this thread. I just started one. I've been finding that when I get to the bottom of a bottle, I'm left with too big of a pour, or I go with my desired pour and only have a smidge left.

I started with two bottles that were just about kicked. A bit of Michter's US1 Small Batch and a bit of Barrel Bourbon. For any that do an infinity bottle do you track what and how much you are adding and when? When do you start drinking from the bottle and do you try to keep it from going below a certain level? Do you try to deliberately create tastes and profiles or just let it rip? Any other tips?
 
Chuck said:
I thought I remember @Fishy mentioning an infinity bottle that he keeps, but didn't see it in this thread. I just started one. I've been finding that when I get to the bottom of a bottle, I'm left with too big of a pour, or I go with my desired pour and only have a smidge left.

I started with two bottles that were just about kicked. A bit of Michter's US1 Small Batch and a bit of Barrel Bourbon. For any that do an infinity bottle do you track what and how much you are adding and when? When do you start drinking from the bottle and do you try to keep it from going below a certain level? Do you try to deliberately create tastes and profiles or just let it rip? Any other tips?
Expand ...

I really didn’t track it, but I generally know what was in it.

I just tried to keep to two rules…nothing with peat as that would take over and I generally kept it 3/4 full. The upside/downside is that you can get it to a really good place and then the next thing you add can blow it up.

My recommendation is that if you get a blend that you really like, stop adding and start a new bottle.
 
.-.
Chuck said:
How was yours?

What's the general consensus on the private editions? I got a Barrell one and liked it. Picked up this Makers.
Expand ...

We enjoyed it. They're neat additions to a liquor shelf or good to bring to a friend's house as something different.

But, I'll say the same thing I say about the Jefferson's Ocean. At that price point I think I can do better. I say that knowing I don't have the most refined pallet nor do I care. I can give about 2-3 flavors or spice profiles and then I'm over my head.
 
Chuck said:
How was yours?

What's the general consensus on the private editions? I got a Barrell one and liked it. Picked up this Makers.
Expand ...
Barrel is going to be different than Makers. Barrel is blending different things in most cases. They source from more than one distillery (but a lot of it is Dickel).

Maker's uses some odd combinations of staves to produce some variations between different store selections. They can be amazing if you like what they did, or very much not. Makers is also a wheater, no rye in the mashbill. So certain wood can overpower it a bit.

Lots of good stuff out there.
 
HuskyHawk said:
Barrel is going to be different than Makers. Barrel is blending different things in most cases. They source from more than one distillery (but a lot of it is Dickel).

Maker's uses some odd combinations of staves to produce some variations between different store selections. They can be amazing if you like what they did, or very much not. Makers is also a wheater, no rye in the mashbill. So certain wood can overpower it a bit.

Lots of good stuff out there.
Expand ...
Yeah, I was just wondering about the general consensus on the Private Selections from stores. I was happy with the Barrell I got, but I like the Seagrass, Dovetail and Armida better (just bought, but haven't tried Vantage yet), and it was the same price. The Maker's tasted like an elevated Maker's. A bit more substantial.

I guess the private selections are kind of crap shoots. You can't really get reviews. The price on both were in my typical "nice pour" range (I think the Barrell was $75 and the Maker's was $70) so I was happy with both. I don't know that I'd pull the trigger if it was over $100 unless I had some way of getting a review or taste.
 
Chuck said:
Yeah, I was just wondering about the general consensus on the Private Selections from stores. I was happy with the Barrell I got, but I like the Seagrass, Dovetail and Armida better (just bought, but haven't tried Vantage yet), and it was the same price. The Maker's tasted like an elevated Maker's. A bit more substantial.

I guess the private selections are kind of crap shoots. You can't really get reviews. The price on both were in my typical "nice pour" range (I think the Barrell was $75 and the Maker's was $70) so I was happy with both. I don't know that I'd pull the trigger if it was over $100 unless I had some way of getting a review or taste.
Expand ...
Everyone has different views. My general thoughts divide somewhat on whether a store pick is just a specific single barrel of a normally single barrel product, or is something unique. Also, not all stores are the same. Many don't do any actual "picking". I'm fortunate with two local stores that have great reputations and real people going to pick barrels. NH is the only state that does that by the way, for control states.
  • Knob Creek single barrel store picks are usually worth it and rarely have a premium.
  • Russell's Reserve SiB store picks are good, but not usually worth a premium over RR SiB on shelves
  • Four Roses store picks are expensive, but excellent. It's a product you can't get in non store pick form. Regular 4R SiB is a different thing.
  • Makers store picks can be good, are a bit expensive and like 4R aren't something you can get in a regular version. There is no comparable normal product except the annual limited releases.
  • Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace - not usually worth any premium (often there is none)
  • Whistle Pig 10 store picks seem to be much better than the regular product
  • Barrell store picks aren't very different from the regular bourbon releases. The other Barrell products you mentioned are already fairly unique and diverse.
  • Jack Daniels SiB store picks are good, but like Russell's not necessarily better than a normal SiB.
  • High West finishes and store picks are a total crapshoot. Can be great or meh.
  • Tumbling Dice store picks have been excellent.
  • Craft bourbon store picks - total crapshoot. Try first if you can.
 
HuskyHawk said:
Many don't do any actual "picking". I'm fortunate with two local stores that have great reputations and real people going to pick barrels.
Expand ...

Where I work the staff pics like 9/10, some are sent by the distiller, some of them bring it out ( Barrell as an example ).

HuskyHawk said:
  • Knob Creek single barrel store picks are usually worth it and rarely have a premium
Expand ...

Almost always a grab for me, and have not had a bad one yet.

HuskyHawk said:
  • Eagle Rare and Buffalo Trace - not usually worth any premium (often there is none)
Expand ...

Agree, have had several and the originals are actually better.

HuskyHawk said:
  • Barrell store picks aren't very different from the regular bourbon releases. The other Barrell products you mentioned are already fairly unique and diverse.
Expand ...

We depart opinions here. Our store has done, I think 5 or 6, and without question, none of the standard products come close to those. Better flavors, ages etc. Perhaps we have just had good luck, and our rep and the folks are Barrell do love us ( we are their top in market seller ). Who knows but I always look forward to our newest Barrell ones.
 
.-.
HuskyHawk said:
Barrel is going to be different than Makers. Barrel is blending different things in most cases. They source from more than one distillery (but a lot of it is Dickel).

Maker's uses some odd combinations of staves to produce some variations between different store selections. They can be amazing if you like what they did, or very much not. Makers is also a wheater, no rye in the mashbill. So certain wood can overpower it a bit.

Lots of good stuff out there.
Expand ...

Kinda funny you mention the wheat mashbill of the Maker's. Was drinking some of the Maker's 46 last night. Mrs. Diesel isn't a fan of it, she says it gives her headaches (insert joke here). She was enjoying some Four Roses Single Barrel (which, OBTW, for the under $50 price range, Four Roses Single Barrel is a great pour).

A few years ago I realized wheat beers often gave me an itchy, scratchy throat and almost felt like having seasonal allergies so I quickly dumped drinking those beers. Last night with the Maker's I was getting the same reaction and I told Mrs. Diesel I felt like I was drinking wheat beer.

Short story long, I don't know my point. Mrs. Diesel is laid up tonight with a stomach virus and I'm drinking the J Henry Wisconsin bourbon I mentioned back in December. Still a great pour.
 
Chin Diesel said:
Kinda funny you mention the wheat mashbill of the Maker's. Was drinking some of the Maker's 46 last night. Mrs. Diesel isn't a fan of it, she says it gives her headaches (insert joke here). She was enjoying some Four Roses Single Barrel (which, OBTW, for the under $50 price range, Four Roses Single Barrel is a great pour).

A few years ago I realized wheat beers often gave me an itchy, scratchy throat and almost felt like having seasonal allergies so I quickly dumped drinking those beers. Last night with the Maker's I was getting the same reaction and I told Mrs. Diesel I felt like I was drinking wheat beer.

Short story long, I don't know my point. Mrs. Diesel is laid up tonight with a stomach virus and I'm drinking the J Henry Wisconsin bourbon I mentioned back in December. Still a great pour.
Expand ...
Well don’t blame gluten. One if the more brilliant but dumb marketing moves ever was when Tito’s labeled itself as gluten free. I know people who bought it for that. Yet gluten doesn’t survive the distillation process in anything. It does in beer though.
 
HuskyHawk said:
Well don’t blame gluten. One if the more brilliant but dumb marketing moves ever was when Tito’s labeled itself as gluten free. I know people who bought it for that. Yet gluten doesn’t survive the distillation process in anything. It does in beer though.
Expand ...

Unsure what prompted this but it made me think of this I saw on Instagram recently

 
HuskyHawk said:
Well don’t blame gluten. One if the more brilliant but dumb marketing moves ever was when Tito’s labeled itself as gluten free. I know people who bought it for that. Yet gluten doesn’t survive the distillation process in anything. It does in beer though.
Expand ...

I thought all vodkas were gluten free.

Didn't realize bourbon, whiskey and rum were all gluten free too.

Doesn't bother me if they use it for advertising for their own product so long as they don't make it seem like they are gluten free but other contain gluten.
 
Last edited:
Chin Diesel said:
I thought all vodkas were gluten free.

Didn't realize bourbon, whiskey and rum were all gluten free too.

Doesn't bother me if they use it for advertising for their own product so long as they don't make it seem like they are gluten free but other contain gluten.
Expand ...
Anything distilled is gluten free. Tito’s was brilliant to call it out.
 
.-.
HuskyHawk said:
Well don’t blame gluten. One if the more brilliant but dumb marketing moves ever was when Tito’s labeled itself as gluten free. I know people who bought it for that. Yet gluten doesn’t survive the distillation process in anything. It does in beer though.
Expand ...

@HuskyHawk .


We may have found the culprit. Was out of town from work and returned home tonight.

Mrs Diesel and I had sampled a few bourbon this evening and I started to sneeze. She said I do it every time I drink the Maker's 46.

No biggie. I can easily sideline that and not miss a thing.
 
Chin Diesel said:
@HuskyHawk .


We may have found the culprit. Was out of town from work and returned home tonight.

Mrs Diesel and I had sampled a few bourbon this evening and I started to sneeze. She said I do it every time I drink the Maker's 46.

No biggie. I can easily sideline that and not miss a thing.
Expand ...
It’s not even that good. But it’s not gluten!
 
Bought a bottle of Michter's Small Batch. Basically their entry level bourbon. Got it for about $50.

Meh. Nice, but nothing stands out. Really not any better than Woodford Reserve or other bourbons $10-$15 cheaper.

I wouldn't ever turn it down, but I don't think I'll buy it again.
 
Chin Diesel said:
Bought a bottle of Michter's Small Batch. Basically their entry level bourbon. Got it for about $50.

Meh. Nice, but nothing stands out. Really not any better than Woodford Reserve or other bourbons $10-$15 cheaper.

I wouldn't ever turn it down, but I don't think I'll buy it again.
Expand ...
I think I paid $35 for that. Was pretty ok with it, but wouldn't have been at $50.
 
HuskyHawk said:
I think I paid $35 for that. Was pretty ok with it, but wouldn't have been at $50.
Expand ...
Yea I think msrp is $40 at least in NJ. I actually like the flavor profile as a no frills standard 80 proof bourbon that is readily available (that used to be Eagle Rare for me but those days are long gone), but yea $50 is steep for what it is.
 
.-.
HobokenHusky said:
Yea I think msrp is $40 at least in NJ. I actually like the flavor profile as a no frills standard 80 proof bourbon that is readily available (that used to be Eagle Rare for me but those days are long gone), but yea $50 is steep for what it is.
Expand ...
I bought this recently. It was $42 I think. These guys distill what becomes Pinhook and some others. First of their own label. 4 years old

IMG_1442.jpeg
 
Deepelm said:
My customers give mixed reviews on this one. Thoughts?
Expand ...
It is early still, but mild thumbs down. Just has a little of that "craft" taste, where the wood tastes too much like wood. Likely needed another year. I should have grabbed the rye, it probably wouldn't taste as young. It's certainly not bad, but it's a very low rye bourbon, and that high malt content calls out for more time.

For comparison sake, I would put it behind Wilderness Trail and New Riff.
 
HuskyHawk said:
It is early still, but mild thumbs down. Just has a little of that "craft" taste, where the wood tastes too much like wood. Likely needed another year. I should have grabbed the rye, it probably wouldn't taste as young. It's certainly not bad, but it's a very low rye bourbon, and that high malt content calls out for more time.

For comparison sake, I would put it behind Wilderness Trail and New Riff.
Expand ...

Pretty much the consensus. They make a gin and a vodka that are OK. The rye I have not heard good or bad on as I have never seen it. We had their wheated version and it was supposed to be good.
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,215
Messages
4,557,558
Members
10,442
Latest member
StatsMan


Top Bottom