OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 340 | The Boneyard

OT: Best Pizza in CT

What’s the best pizza joint near Fairfield CT ?


  • Total voters
    50
  • Poll closed .
Joined
Feb 20, 2022
Messages
181
Reaction Score
917
Stopped on the way up to the game Wed at a place that I don't recall seeing getting much love on this thread...Olde World in Hamden. I have to say, it was REALLY good. The thing that stood out was that it wasn't very crispy but I chalked that up to being a few minutes late for pick up ( I did immediately crush it right out of the box in their parking lot though).

For giggles, I checked out Portnoy's review and he actually noted the same thing about it not having much crisp to it. Nevertheless, I think the taste was outstanding and if you're in the area, do yourself a favor and order one up to eat fresh out of the oven.
 
Joined
Sep 6, 2011
Messages
13,397
Reaction Score
72,756
Coming from Boston before the game on Friday, will have time to hit up somewhere and my buddy wants pizza. I searched in this thread a little bit, but it's rather unwieldly. I understand there's not much quality in Storrs and just some okay places around the immediate Storrs areas .

What's the best pizza place East of Hartford and north of Mohegan?
 
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
16,451
Reaction Score
93,204
Coming from Boston before the game on Friday, will have time to hit up somewhere and my buddy wants pizza. I searched in this thread a little bit, but it's rather unwieldly. I understand there's not much quality in Storrs and just some okay places around the immediate Storrs areas .

What's the best pizza place East of Hartford and north of Mohegan?
Camille's in Tolland (195 right off I-84) is pretty good. Most convenient.

Best in the area you outlined would be Pepe's in Manchester.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
9,523
Reaction Score
35,250
Coming from Boston before the game on Friday, will have time to hit up somewhere and my buddy wants pizza. I searched in this thread a little bit, but it's rather unwieldly. I understand there's not much quality in Storrs and just some okay places around the immediate Storrs areas .

What's the best pizza place East of Hartford and north of Mohegan?
Try Gido’s Brick Oven in Sturbridge Ma. It’s at 367 Main St.

I presume you are coming in on the Mass Pike to 84, so it’s a perfect place to stop. It will take you 30-35 minutes to get to campus from there depending on traffic. Very good.

 
Joined
Apr 14, 2020
Messages
5,101
Reaction Score
23,164
For pizza loving Yarders living in Hartford County-Sally's opening at West Farms Mall (next to Jordan's Furniture) is Feb 13th. 80Ft big screen for sports
 
Joined
Nov 28, 2022
Messages
359
Reaction Score
1,361
How did a survey about Fairfield pizza get added to a legendary year's long pizza thread? Blasphemy!
 

dvegas

Duck Fuke
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
1,658
Reaction Score
4,309
Pepes in Watertown Mass last night. No issues, (I eat at NH at least 4x a year, and take out from Fairfield monthly) there was an insane amount of pepperoni on my red pie, perfect bake and char. But it was empty, granted we were in there around 5:05 pm.
 
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
16,451
Reaction Score
93,204
Camille’s is great but will probably be busy.
We went there before the Sacred Heart game (opening night) and got there about 5:00 and it got busy about 6:00. But I think there were still tables available even then. We actually called on the way down and asked if it was busy and they saved us a table and put in our order so that it would be ready shortly after we got there. They were very nice about everything.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
16,451
Reaction Score
93,204
Try Gido’s Brick Oven in Sturbridge Ma. It’s at 367 Main St.

I presume you are coming in on the Mass Pike to 84, so it’s a perfect place to stop. It will take you 30-35 minutes to get to campus from there depending on traffic. Very good.

We went there back in August after a Tree House stop. I thought it was gross. Yuck!
 

Dove

Who wouldn't want to be me?
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
16,415
Reaction Score
48,475
Coming from Boston before the game on Friday, will have time to hit up somewhere and my buddy wants pizza. I searched in this thread a little bit, but it's rather unwieldly. I understand there's not much quality in Storrs and just some okay places around the immediate Storrs areas .

What's the best pizza place East of Hartford and north of Mohegan?
Wiilibrew gets raves for their tap list and food. They have 10" Personal pizzas.
 
Joined
May 7, 2014
Messages
14,727
Reaction Score
30,967
Stopped on the way up to the game Wed at a place that I don't recall seeing getting much love on this thread...Olde World in Hamden. I have to say, it was REALLY good. The thing that stood out was that it wasn't very crispy but I chalked that up to being a few minutes late for pick up ( I did immediately crush it right out of the box in their parking lot though).

For giggles, I checked out Portnoy's review and he actually noted the same thing about it not having much crisp to it. Nevertheless, I think the taste was outstanding and if you're in the area, do yourself a favor and order one up to eat fresh out of the oven.
Definitely have heard a bunch about old world and, despite living in Cheshire for 6 months, never got some. Definitely want to. It’s because Cheshire has Fuoco, which is phenomenal; and Antonio’s and Sergio’s, which are both very good. So the furthest I would ever head into Hamden to eat was BRGRKO or Bangkok Boulevard for the most part since my pizza needs were more than satisfied
 
Joined
May 7, 2014
Messages
14,727
Reaction Score
30,967
Coming from Boston before the game on Friday, will have time to hit up somewhere and my buddy wants pizza. I searched in this thread a little bit, but it's rather unwieldly. I understand there's not much quality in Storrs and just some okay places around the immediate Storrs areas .

What's the best pizza place East of Hartford and north of Mohegan?
If you feel okay with stopping in Worcester on the way down, Volturno is a solid bar with some good creative pizzas. Obviously not Apizza, but a very solid option not far out of the way on your drive. The wife and I have stopped in a couple times driving to/from family in CT
 

Online statistics

Members online
300
Guests online
2,676
Total visitors
2,976

Forum statistics

Threads
161,225
Messages
4,255,257
Members
10,098
Latest member
Hillside


.
Top Bottom