OT: - Best Pizza in CT | Page 18 | The Boneyard

OT: Best Pizza in CT

Nostical said:
The best pizza is Greek style pizza. Anyone remember Rialto Pizza in New London? It was the best. Marblehead House in MA is also awesome. All the rest--Pepe's etal --are pretenders. Of course that's just my opinion. But I'm right!
Expand ...

I think the world of you Nos but unless Greek pizza from southeastern CT is far closer to Neopolitan than Greek pizza from the southwestern part of the state I cannot dislike the post (and dissent from the opinion) enough. I will admit that I've never had Rialto or Marblehead but will also (for the purpose of full disclosure) admit that two of my grandparents were born in Italy and one was born in Greece.
 
FfldCntyFan said:
I think the world of you Nos but unless Greek pizza from southeastern CT is far closer to Neopolitan than Greek pizza from the southwestern part of the state I cannot dislike the post (and dissent from the opinion) enough. I will admit that I've never had Rialto or Marblehead but will also (for the purpose of full disclosure) admit that two of my grandparents were born in Italy and one was born in Greece.
Expand ...

I think he's gotta be trolling . No other explanation. Pizza cut in squares makes me chuckle. ( unless it's a nice slice of NYC Sicilian)
 
Colony is the best. Rico's imitates them and is very good. Pepe's just isn't on the same level.

Dominos 5-5-5 deal needs to come back now.
 
UConn5 said:
Colony is the best. Rico's imitates them and is very good. Pepe's just isn't on the same level.
Expand ...
I agree that Pepe's isn't in the same stratosphere. I don't even think it's the same product. Pepe's is apizza. Colony is a blistering disc of acid sauce covered in oil.
 
I'm not reading 16 pages to find out if this has been mentioned, but for a different feel than NYC/New Haven style, I really like Luna Pizza (West Hart/Simsbury). It's got a nice light sauce, tasty cheese, and beautifully crispy crust. You have to dine in though or it becomes soggy.
 
Have receipes, oe some other sig factor, changed since this thread started??
 
.-.
I've just discovered a place called Ray's on Route 156 in Niantic. Try it out, you won't be disappointed.
 
In Bristol CT - try San Gennaro in Forestville Center and Chunky Tomato on Route 6.

Bristol has a ton of pizza places but they are all pretenders compared to these.
 
alexd. said:
In Bristol CT - try San Gennaro in Forestville Center and Chunky Tomato on Route 6.

Bristol has a ton of pizza places but they are all pretenders compared to these.
Expand ...
thks- will do when I'm ub there!
 
.-.
We actually have people talking about best pizza and they aren't referring to New Haven? Crazy talk.
 
intlzncster said:
Definitely not trying to rain on your parade, but it won't be as good as the New Haven place, if previous form holds. Manchester Pepe's < New Haven Pepe's imo. Could be in my imagination of course.

That said, you won't find anything better around there, so you'll be loving that. And you don't have to drive. So yes, it's a win.
Expand ...
I agree with you. The Pepe's in Manchester is not nearly as good as New Haven. But it's still way better than anything up here.
 
I moved from Rome (Italy, not NY) to Westport, CT and I did not puke when I ate the pizza at Westport Pizzeria. ;)

It's worth a try - they recently moved to the Post Rd. from their location on Main St. where they had been for 45 years.

So sad to see them move - that was one of our main hangouts when I went to Staples HS. That street changed a lot over the years - when I first moved there they had an old style barber shop, a pharmacy, a coffee shop and a gas station. Now they have J Crew, Gap, Banana Republic, Nike Store and Pottery Barn. I think there's a Tiffany's there too now.
 
HooperScooper said:
I agree with you. The Pepe's in Manchester is not nearly as good as New Haven. But it's still way better than anything up here.
Expand ...

BINGO……..come to WesMass and try our pizza where Red Rose in Springfield is king and doesn't hold a candle to some of the CT local pizza parlors never mind Modern, Sally's or Pepe's……….actually you can hardly call it pizza………lol
 
.-.
August_West said:
Bar is excellent. It is a little off course from the traditional New Haven Pie, but is really good. Some creative offerings. I really like the Mashed potato and bacon pizza.
Expand ...
Bingo. Just logged on to say the same. It's right there with the holy trinity (Pepe's, Sally's, Modern) imo. Second on the mashed potato/bacon pie (they will recommend white, but get it red, trust me). Their salad is also very good, as are all their traditional and other pizza offerings. Just be warned that it is probably the thinnest crust you've ever had and it doesn't last or travel well. It cools really fast. Also, their house beers tend to be average at best imo (except for the aptly-named Damn Good Stout), so stick to the guest beers otherwise if you are a fan of micros/craft beers. He usually has a pretty nice selection.
 
CTBasketball said:
Has anyone been to BAR in New Haven? I'm too lazy to filter thru 17 pages of pizza comments...
Expand ...

Last time I was there a few months ago the pizza was off a bit but I'm assuming they just had an off night. The challenge with Bar is getting out of there early enough if you have kids with you because the club crowd comes in quick and then the fun starts. Prob best to be out by then. My sad reality is that I have to get out early with the kids when Bar used to be one of my favorite trolling grounds when I was single.... I hate getting old!
 
My contribution to this list is Joey Garlics on the Berlin tnpke in Newington, but ONE pizza in particular.... Order the "clams casino" pizza without the clams! If you like bacon, it's off the chain!!!!! BTW, don't think you can go to the one in Farmington or the spinoff in Simsbury and have the same pie because they are NOT as good as Newington! In fact, ordering that pie at these locations isn't even close!
Your welcome!
 
Doggie Style said:
My contribution to this list is Joey Garlics on the Berlin tnpke in Newington, but ONE pizza in particular.... Order the "clams casino" pizza without the clams! If you like bacon, it's off the chain!!!!! BTW, don't think you can go to the one in Farmington or the spinoff in Simsbury and have the same pie because they are NOT as good as Newington! In fact, ordering that pie at these locations isn't even close!
Your welcome!
Expand ...
I went to the Joe Pizza one in Simsbury and it was excellent pie. I didn't have any exotics like you, but the pie was really really good. Very underrated.
 
Doggie Style said:
My contribution to this list is Joey Garlics on the Berlin tnpke in Newington, but ONE pizza in particular.... Order the "clams casino" pizza without the clams! If you like bacon, it's off the chain!!!!! BTW, don't think you can go to the one in Farmington or the spinoff in Simsbury and have the same pie because they are NOT as good as Newington! In fact, ordering that pie at these locations isn't even close!
Your welcome!
Expand ...

Try their eggplant fries if you haven't already. They're one of the greatest pleasures one can have with their pants on.
 
CTBasketball said:
I went to the Joe Pizza one in Simsbury and it was excellent pie. I didn't have any exotics like you, but the pie was really really good. Very underrated.
Expand ...
Wasn't Joe Pizza the original? The tomato pie without mozz is terrific.
 
.-.
TRest said:
Wasn't Joe Pizza the original? The tomato pie without mozz is terrific.
Expand ...
I always thought Joey Garlics was the originals, but I'm not sure. And yes the tomato pie is fantastic. If you live in Northern/Northeastern CT, Joe Pizza should be at the top of your local list.
 
CTBasketball said:
I always thought Joey Garlics was the originals, but I'm not sure. And yes the tomato pie is fantastic. If you live in Northern/Northeastern CT, Joe Pizza should be at the top of your local list.
Expand ...

What used to be an underrated pie was Berkshire Pub in Torrington…….changing of the guard has brought inconsistencies there and I haven't been there for a while but it was very good and their salads were killer also with ham, salami and cheese and a solid home made dressing…….
 
August_West said:
I think he's gotta be trolling . Pizza cut in squares makes me chuckle.
Expand ...

Ha! I'm not trolling. It's all a matter of taste. I've had Pepe's etc but much prefer the pizza made in pans---not the thick Chicago style-- but CT or MA style. BTW, none of the Greek style pizza I favor is ever cut into squares. Just like the old mustard v ketchup on a hot dog (mustard by a mile)----or---ice cream in a cone or a cup (sugar cone), that's why (no pun intended) they make chocolate and vanilla.
 
Nostical said:
Ha! I'm not trolling. It's all a matter of taste. I've had Pepe's etc but much prefer the pizza made in pans---not the thick Chicago style-- but CT or MA style. BTW, none of the Greek style pizza I favor is ever cut into squares. Just like the old mus v ketchup on a hot dog (mus by a mile)----or---ice cream in a cone or a cup (sugar cone), that's why (no pun intended) they make chocolate and vanilla.
Expand ...
:-). Certainly taste is subjective which is why I enjoy these threads. Makes me want to try different places. Everyone has their favorites.....

...... But there is pretty much only 2 things in this world that people from outside of Connecticut envy and is acknowledged as the best:
1) our basketball program
2) our pizza


In regards to number 2 that reputation wasn't built on an eastern CT Greek pizza place :-)

The daily meal which has the most reputable food lists in America did a top 101 pizza places in the country list recently.
New haven pies took number 1 ( pepes) number 7 ( Sally's ) and number 11 ( modern) .

That's just insane for a small city in any list.

http://www.wfsb.com/story/23759145/pepes-white-clam-pizza-named-number-1-in-country
 
I haven't lived in New England for a long time, but I was driving from Manhattan to Springfield a few weeks ago and I stopped in New Haven to go to Pepe's, didn't feel like dealing with the line, and grabbed a pizza from Sally's instead. Had never been. Good lord it was terrible. I'm not plugged into the CT pizza scene but are there people who will go to bat for Sally's?
 
BigErnMcCracken said:
I haven't lived in New England for a long time, but I was driving from Manhattan to Springfield a few weeks ago and I stopped in New Haven to go to Pepe's, didn't feel like dealing with the line, and grabbed a pizza from Sally's instead. Had never been. Good lord it was terrible. I'm not plugged into the CT pizza scene but are there people who will go to bat for Sally's?
Expand ...

Sounds like you may have caught them on a bad day, I guess? I prefer Pepe's, but Sally's is usually very good.
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
167,930
Messages
4,545,411
Members
10,426
Latest member
kmbazz15


Top Bottom